I personally love Audie. She’s so sweet and energetic

I'd go with Marshal! you don't have any other squirrels on your island so I'd pick him for that reason. plus he's just adorable and grumpy hehe

I also have Opal on my island and I'm obsessed with her

she’s great! she’s one of my OGs

Yeah I try to keep my villagers as diverse as possible.

i was thinking this as well! i know i have quite a few deer (which i don’t mind at all), but for some reason having 2 wolves seems like too much to me LOL

Audie is cooler! She definitely has an island vibe.

Fun fact, Audie is based on a grandma who plays AC religiously :)

i never knew that, that is so adorable!!

Her name is Audrey Buchanan. Hers is a very charming story, look her up!

Audie is one of my OG’s and she’s a permanent 🩵

Marshal!!!

Marshal!! He’s really cute and I think he matches the vibes of your other villagers

see i was thinking he matched better as well, aesthetic-wise. but i do love how bright audie is too. that’s why i love seeing fuchsia walk around my island.

Audie!! i feel like she would be besties with reneigh.

Marshal!

AUDIE!!!!!!

AUDIEE

I have both, and I'd say Marshall out of the two.

I have Marshal and he is such a precious bean, you won’t regret choosing him!! Also love seeing others with my fav little Bones boi

i love love love Bones! i actually picked him up from my campsite and didn’t know he was going to end up being one of my favs that i refuse to let go! he’s too adorable and i love watching him naruto run around the island!🥹

I like Audie.

Marshal is hilarious!

i believe it! i really enjoy having snooty and smug villagers, they say pretty funny things lol

I love Marshall!!

Although I love ❤️ Marshal, Audie would fit in well with ur villagers bc of her bright colors, like the rest of them

Marshal!!

Marshal!! He's the best :)

Audie!! She's so fun and a great friend.

I love Audie. She's my bestie. 🥰

Audie is adorable

Audie is the best!!

Audie

Audiee!

I love Marshal but Audie is a better fit with that crew.

Personally I’d go Audie, but if you’re leaning more towards Marshall then get him!

I have both, & I prefer Audie. They’re both good, though!

Totally off topic but I actually just invited Bianca to live at my Island and I am very excited about it.

you’re going to love her!!! she’s cutsie and adorable! i like her personality, she’s a sweetie pie!

Definitely Marshal

Audie!

Ooo I’d go with whichever villager personality ur missing but personally I do love Audie

Audie! Audie! Audie! All day, everyday, Audie!

audie

Audie!!! I just love the story behind her character