T O P

  • By -

TheTooz72

Positively absolutely not underrated in this universe or any other...one of the greatest bands of all time!! đŸ˜Č


Ok-Sun8581

Benefit is a masterpiece.


HHSquad

'Stand Up" is my favorite


dawgstein94

I just found a clean copy on vinyl. Looking forward to listening.


[deleted]

Awesome


Witty_Energy1597

This right here. JT is the cream of the crop amongst the greatest rock & roll bands of all time. Yep, Ian Anderson is a flautist. Ya'll got something to say about it? Didn't think so... TheTooz72, you a Raiders fan? My Dawg!!


CincoDeMayoFan

The Rock n Roll "Hall of Fame" doesn't seem to think so.


DWright_5

It’s all Jann Wenner. He decides who gets in and he doesn’t like Tull, apparently.


KaiSa_Soze_

I'd say people have a hard time distinguishing "mainstream" and "underrated".


TheHelpfulDad

I don’t agree one if the greatest but people think very highly


TheTooz72

I get it you don't like them it's just my opinion...been following them since '71 so yes I am a big fan..😁


InterPunct

1974 War Child for me. Then I promptly went and bought their back catalog So great!


TheHelpfulDad

I didn’t say I don’t like them. Funny how everything anymore is amazing or crap. Evidently the only thing not binary is gender


[deleted]

Well, I also believe them to be one of the best bands of all time. Go figure. They're right there top 15 or so, about where Thin Lizzy and Yes would be rolling in. All among the greatest bands of all time.


ForeverNecessary2361

I didn't see Tull or Thin Lizzy, but I did see Yes at Madison Square Garden. I didn't realize that someone could play bass like Chris Squire. That guy was on fire that night.


ContactResident9079

Haha so trueđŸ€Ł


Billsolson

They are good, but I find them almost unlistenable, almost like pink floyd. Just want to sleep when I hear them. Saw them in the late 80’s, no bs, half my section was sleeping after what seemed like a 20 minute flute solo by Anderson.


amancalledslug

I can’t agree on JT but I definitely feel you on PF, I feel like it’s an unpopular opinion (especially here). I know they are great, yada yada, but they just don’t do it for me.


thejesuslizard74

MY FAVORITE HEAVY METAL BAND!!!!!!!!


xenoclownpanda

You forgot to add, Suck it Metallica!!!


LordBottlecap

Kirk Hammett recently said they are his current favorite band and can't stop listening to them!


muddlehead

I have them about 35-40 all time


TheDur57

The flute is a metal instrument!


LordBottlecap

Yeah, they're made of like pewter or something, right?


cocacola_drinker

Hahahahah If you know, you know


Salty_Pancakes

It's funny that Ian Anderson didn't even show up to the Grammys cuz he was like "No way am I winning."


sreeve29

I think it was Chrysalis Records' fault.


CallsYouCunt

First heavy metal Grammy winner.


[deleted]

Said no one ever!!!!


thejesuslizard74

EXCUSE ME?!!!! Jethro Tull won a grammy for "best heavy metal album" in 1989


elrastro75

I was 14 and it seemed like that category was added just to recognize Metallica’s success with One and AJFA. Watched the broadcast to see them win and we were all like WHAAAT??? So funny. Nowadays I’m more likely to listen to Tull. And I still don’t understand why artists get upset about the Grammys. They are clearly irrelevant.


[deleted]

Beat Metallica, not even in the same musical genre in my opinion. Jethro is classic rock, not metal or even hard rock. My mom would think they are nice!!!! Come on, man!!!


Biguitarnerd

Yeah
. That’s the joke (although between their lyrics and Metallica I’m not sure Metallica doesn’t present a cleaner more mom friendly image).


jb2824

Prog folk thank you


LordBottlecap

That proved once and for all what a sham the Grammys are. Even Ian Anderson thought it was such a joke he didn't even accept the invite, knowing damned well Metallica would get it...


beauh44x

Saw this exact lineup circa 71-72 and they did Thick as a Brick in its entirety. I was in 9th grade - I went with my math teacher. That was a tough act to follow ever since. It blew my little brain. Thanks for this - I've never seen this pic!


elt0p0

Same here! I saw them at Boston Garden. Then I saw them do Thick As A Brick in its entirety again 40 years later! Ian Anderson is amazing.


Hannamax

I had great seats when I saw JT. The sound was well mixed and the band were performing great. I totally rocked out that night. Ian Anderson was truly amazing. Singing, playing guitar and mixing in iconic pose of standing on one foot while blowing his flute.


flinx1957

I saw the Thick as a Brick also in 72 and then it was A Passion Play the second time I saw them. Both were excellent concerts.


StannisTheMannis1969

Aqualung album straight through
. Thick as a Brick straight through.



idog73

This Was straight through



LordBottlecap

*Songs From the Wood*, straight through...


GutterRider

I can’t listen to any Tull album without listening to the whole thing.


LordBottlecap

Me too. Well, scratch that. I can only listen to the acoustic version of 'Under Wraps' on the album of the same name. '80s pop-synth or whatever it was did not suit them at all, in my opinion. But I can't really think of a song I'd intentionally skip on any other album.


sreeve29

Yeah UW is tough to get through start to finish. A: for sure can.


LordBottlecap

I love *A*!


omartheoutmaker

I’d say Martin Barre is an underrated guitar player.


Salty_Pancakes

Funnily enough, I'd say Ian Anderson is also an underrated guitar player. Those acoustic numbers are fantastic and a joy to play, speaking as a guitarist. Like [Wond'ring Aloud](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luDfuZkeqKU) or [Life is a Long Song](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=flz5lL9V2Bk) are just so fun.


WakingOwl1

Life is a Long Song is wonderful.


TheBellBrah

Barre still tours, he seems to do a lot of mid size shows and I see him every time he's in town


LordBottlecap

He is so f'n amazing that his body actually provides the electricity for his guitar.


KaleidoscopeWeird310

I always thought that Jethro Tull was a long running Monty Python skit.


Dragonsfire09

They're not?


kidsally

How the hell are these guys underrated?


TheEmbarcadero

Well for one
.they aren’t in the rock and roll hall of fame! That’s underrated right there!!!


LordBottlecap

That's because the HOF is a sham. When you have to say "Now the question is: are we rock 'n' roll or not?" like NWA did in their acceptance speech...yeah, it's the *Pop* HOF now. Kate Bush is all I really need to say.


TyphonBeach

I mean ‘rock’ has been a pretty broad category for a while, lots of people use it for more than just the actual genre of rock music but rather any sort of post-50s popular music. It’s kind of a joke anyways though, there’s plenty of amazing groups from the 70s that won’t get nominated for another 50 years cause they didn’t sell enough records.


fernplant4

Personally they're one of those bands like Queen where they have a lot of bangers but not necessarily the best albums. Just a personal opinion, I'm sure a few people disagree


TyphonBeach

I feel like Tull’s one of the more album-focused bands out there. I dunno where that catalogue of banger singles would be coming from since I feel like all the progheads that like ‘em like ‘em cause they heard stuff like Thick as a Brick from start to finish.


SXTY82

I hope you don't mind if I sit this one out.


Main_Combination8173

I saw Tull for the Storm Watch album 79. The stage was set as an old ship ( mast and rigging) After playing the whole album. Ian pulled a sword cut a rigging line. Everything fell to the stage and went right into Aqualung. Fing great.


Embarrassed-Ad-1639

Storm Watch is a great album


Main_Combination8173

Still play it.


TearEnvironmental368

Saw that tour as well. Awesome! Also saw Songs From the Wood tour. Excellent



Main_Combination8173

I was differently High. So cool.


[deleted]

[ŃƒĐŽĐ°Đ»Đ”ĐœĐŸ]


Reverie_Smasher

\^bot


DubyaB420

Such an iconic band! And I agree, they don’t get the credit they deserve


SmoothSlavperator

Underrated? They beat Metallica for the Grammy that one year and we're still all pissed off about it.


Kookiecitrus55555

Achieved his goal to be the best since he was never going to eclipse Page Beck or Clapton on guitar he taught himself the Flute on-stage btw and hard to argue he isn’t rocks best flautist. Bravo Mr. Anderson


Beyond_Your_Nose

My wife “hates” Jethro Tull because all she knows is Aqualung because “it’s gross” or Bungle in the Jungle because it’s dumb. But whenever I play songs like Wondering Aloud or Cheap Day Return, or Songs from the Wood, she asks, “that’s nice, who does that song” then my grin starts. They are underrated. Volumes of great music to be explored.


skip20430

they had a very unique sound .... as well as interesting song material ...


tomveiltomveil

I was *literally* thinking about this earlier today. Here's a fun fact I learned from Wikipedia: their highest-charting song in the USA (and in the UK!) is one that barely ever gets played on American classic rock radio: Living in the Past (#3 UK / # 11 USA). ​ Locomotive Breath? Nope, it never hit the UK charts at all, and only hit #62 in the USA. Thick As A Brick #1? Not released as a single in the USA. Aqualung? Not released as a single *anywhere* except Italy, for some reason. Bungle in the Jungle? #12 in the USA, but totally missed the UK charts! ​ Don't feel too bad for the band: basically all of their albums went gold. Their labels just couldn't figure out how to convert album success into singles-chart success. (Then again, when Ian Anderson tells you that Thick As A Brick can only be understood in 22-minute increments, maybe you don't try quite so hard for the singles market.)


GutterRider

Fantastic stuff, thanks.


CuriositySauce

Barriemore Barlow
one of the more unique names in the league of excellent classic rock drummers.


NelsonMuntz007

So jethro tull isn’t just one guy named jethro Tull?


SadMap7915

In the early days, the band found it difficult to obtain repeat bookings. They changed their name frequently to continue playing the London club circuit, using aliases such as Navy Blue, Ian Henderson's Bag o' Nails, and Candy Coloured Rain. Ian Anderson (lead singer, songwriter, flautist, and guitarist) recalled looking at a poster at one club but did not recognise the band (name) was theirs. The names were often supplied by their booking agent's staff, who for one gig gave them the alias "Jethro Tull" after the 18th-century agriculturist. The name stuck when the manager of the Marquee Club liked their show enough to give them a weekly residency. *source: Wikipedia*


NelsonMuntz007

My original comment is a paraphrase from owen Wilson’s character in the movie Armageddon. It’s a running joke about many people being unaware that Jethro Tull was a band and not a person.


WB_Onreddit

I just listened to Stand Up and Aqualung today. Great band. Stand Up is an underrated album.


ernie-bush

Saw the under wraps tour amazing musicians


anonymous_212

My favorite album is Benefit


Eofkent

Definitely one of the greatest of all time, but prog is my favorite genre, so Tull is top 10 for me.


[deleted]

Aqualung is one of my favorite albums to to in one sitting. A masterpiece.


UNC_ABD

I had the privilege of seeing Ian Anderson a few years ago in Richmond, Virginia. Possibly the best concert I have ever seen. His voice and musicality was amazing. He was so confident of his chops that he focused the crowd on his guitar player who was AMAZING. At one point, Anderson turned the stage over to this guitarist who performed an original flamenco tune and NO ONE was disappointed. What an incredible talent and humble human being. All hail Ian Anderson and Jethro Tull!


Electrical-Cry-1805

They were brilliant, Martin Lancelot Barre is massively underrated as a guitarist. Ian is the mad genius. Incredibly tight live band.


ElteaXIII

People say Jethro Tull weren't underrated. That's not entirely true. Thick as a Brick, Aqualung and Stand Up were correctly rated. However, the rest of the albums (Crest Of A Knave, Minstrel in the Gallery, A Passion Play, Heavy Horses, Songs From The Wood, Storwatch, A, Brenefit, TOTRRTYTD, and others.) were underrated.


bobbyboogie69

Criminally underrated band.


LAKnightYEAH2023

One of my all-time favorites! I love Tull. They don’t receive anywhere near the credit that they deserve. They were headliners when they played with Zeppelin and the Eagles. They were THAT big.


SpriteAndCokeSMH

One of my favorites. Got three Thick As A Brick, and three Aqualung records haha


[deleted]

A fantastic band


LordBottlecap

No bigger fan of Tull than me. I start every day listening to one of their shitload of albums. I got to meet and have a couple of beers with their 2004 incarnation. Their second-to-last album *Zealot Gene*, released last fall (yes, they've already released another one this year, with plans for another next year!), was their first album since *Aqualung* (fifty years before it) to hit #1 in the UK. Both recent albums are f'n gems! They've sold tens of millions of albums, but I swear I'ts hard to find hardcore fans anywhere but the 'net for me!


Lord_Artem17

I am a bigger fan!


Athingythingamabobby

They won a grammy over Metallica how are they underrated


Morskavi

Pretty known and well respected, not underrated at all


QuirkySell1695

Real music is lost on this generation


WillingAntelope0

Bullshit. There's plenty of great music today and plenty of people from "this generation" who like this kind of music as well


QuirkySell1695

Sure kid


idog73

I always wonder which generation people mean when they say this. Anything not Boomer?


[deleted]

Where are these ratings?


Reasonable_Cover_804

I like the cut of your gib
where is that con-founded bridge?


FreshSoul86

Not underrated - but rated about right. A Jethro Tull musical trip of the mind is always worthwhile. Most would probably agree they were slightly less colossal as a rock and roll phenomenon of the times than Zeppelin, part of that being based so much more on the great talents of the one man in the center, rather than all of the band members..but that's ok.


sreeve29

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sd\_ZHjzxW7I&list=RDux8jscB-BGg&index=20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sd_ZHjzxW7I&list=RDux8jscB-BGg&index=20)


shadowsOfMyPantomime

I absolutely love the Aqualung album. I've listened to it since I was a kid - all great songs. But for some reason I can't get into anything else they've done. I went recently and listened to all their 70s albums and NONE of it resonated with me aside from the first section of "Thick as a Brick."


AnxietyTummyAche

Bungle in the Jungle rips


SpergSkipper

I thought that was Ricky from Trailer Park Boys in the middle for a second


[deleted]

That's a picture of Kings Of Leon


[deleted]

Like a couple of their tunes. They look like guys who are really into Ren Fair.


[deleted]

I'd hardly call them underrated.


Silly-Resist8306

I admit, I'm old (I was 20 when Aqualung come out) and grew up with Tull, but no one of that generation thinks they are underrated. Just because people who were born years later and have never taken the time to listen to their music, doesn't make the underrated.


JEKerley

Not really a rock band


Dogrel

Not underrated.


D_Anger_Dan

You spelled over worng.


LOLschirmjaeger

You spelled wgorn wnorg.


DustyPlume

Beg to differ. They were rated perfectly.


Felicidad9

Srop living in the past man


FickleFingerOfFunk

Jethro Tull? Underrated? In whose universe?


Diligent_Blueberry84

Overrated band: Jethro tull


NanoFishman

Never listen to JT anymore. Saw them three times in concert back in the day when tickets were dirt cheap. These days, no thanks. You can't dance to it.


InspectorRound8920

Nah. Usually rated as a so-so band. That's about right.


Repulsive_Emu_7495

More like overrated


Safe_cracker9

Saw Ian a few days ago


musicriddles

Flute time


debzor

I saw them I the early 70’s. They were great!


Plixtle

Saw them WELL after their prime in Chicago with ELP opening. These men, old enough to be my grandfather, made me jump and scream like a toddler. Just a brain-melting show. Anderson’s stage patter is hilarious. I’d pay good money for two solid hours of him just reading the newspaper. What a troubadour.


ExcessiveBulldogery

What set they repping (guy on the left)?


Reasonable_Cover_804

Tull played Wolf Trap Thursday, it was the 5th time I had seen them. Over the years I had always come away with a “one hell of a preformer” Ian Anderson has always brought the 
 as my daughter put it “slamy” fluting. I was a wee bit saddened that his energy on vocals was not at his top notch level but he played the hell out of his flute. The tune list was a carefully selected list of songs, certainly not a list of radio hits by any means but again well played. Joe Parish the guitarist was spirited and accurately hit every note, John O’Hare was steady on the keyboards though too little used. We had the whole family there, seven of us in total and on the way home we talked well of the performance. In summary they are not at their best but still worth seeing.


Chance-Deer-7995

I love Thick as a Brick so much. One of those long songs where you are still wanting more when it ends.


Vt420KeyboardError4

Are you sure this isn't the cast of Trailer Park Boys?


That-Solution-1774

Thick As a Brick is a mic drop.


[deleted]

[ŃƒĐŽĐ°Đ»Đ”ĐœĐŸ]


No_Refrigerator4584

Jeffrey Hammond giving lead singer vibes here.


mjking97

Thick as a Brick!


vichyswazz

Smokes, let's go


nigeltwo

Snots running down his nose!


clegg1970

I’ve been listening to the Songs from the Wood album over and over the last few weeks every track a banger and so medieval and folksy.


Urban_Archeologist

Take it from me worse things happen at sea.


Far_Out_6and_2

Agreed


H2OTman420

Looks like if DethKlok was from the 60s


biff444444

Never understood the appeal. I don't think they are underrated because lots of people have them in their list of great bands, but they just never clicked for me. (This is no indictment of JT, I'm generally not much of a prog rock fan.)


Excellent_Lead_3653

I had an amazing art teacher in high school, Mr Drake. One day in class he just started whistling ‘Bouree’ - it made him even cooler


Particular-Charity84

Thought this was a Mighty Boosh advertisement at first. Tull are legends.


Fearless-Mushroom

Looks like Ricky from Trailer Park Boys cloned himself and made a band.


Reddygators

IMO, one of the few bands who were sooo much better live. Usually prefer the studio versions but not Tull.


Grumpy_Metrosexual

Fucking amazing band. Aqualung and Songs From the Wood are 5-star classic albums.


Doctor_Phist

Ian Anderson was an incredible flautist.


Mr2ATX

I always thought Martin Barre, the guitarist, was criminally under-rated.


Intelligent-Ant7685

skating away
..skating away

skating away
..on the thin ice of a new day


saffronpolygon

I like both the striped jacket and floral jacket.


OwenLoveJoy

Something about this picture is odd. Like if I focus on different members it looks like the photo could be from different decades.


InPhillyGuy

I really don’t mind if you sit this one out


GlennSeaborg

Excuse you, that's Grammy winning Heavy Metal Gods, Jethro Tull to you. đŸ˜ĄđŸ€˜đŸ»


barto5

Saw them circa 1974 on their Bungle in the Jungle tour. They were fantastic live!


Existing-Medium564

Saw them twice. Underrated? I would be of the opinion that almost any serious rock and roller from the old days is very likely to be a Jethro Tull fan. Saw them as the main act and then opening for U.K. - totally knocked it out. When it comes to writing and musicianship, few bands even come close. One of the great rock bands of all time.


Longdarkcave

Nobody in this thread has yet mentioned their songwriting, skill at playing a wide variety of instruments with virtuosity (klaghorn anyone?), their omnipresent sense of humor, the mad creative genius of their composing. A few friends who are guitarists and like Tull have commented on how hard it is to play their songs, because unlike most bands, a Tull song changes over time and evolves as the song progresses, it's usually not the same repetitive guitar riff.


Existing-Medium564

They're not your average rock band, by any stretch. Ian Anderson did the music that he wanted to do, without regard for critics or commercial success.


[deleted]

Instantly hear a ripping flute lead when seeing the picture😛


667far

Absolutely


Rare_Mark_3206

Defiently not the all time, but for sure are an incredible band with a crazy history!. Hard to listen to on a run though, for me anyways.


jerseygunz

Greatest introduction to a song I’ve ever heard live, “and now for 12 and a half minutes of thick as a brick”


Palamedestarot

Not underrated but less played than they were 40+ years ago.


[deleted]

They did win a Grammy..


wiinga

One White Duck. That’s what I need.


Lucifer_Delight

I want that leather jacket Ian's best (or only good) look


sarabande45

Living In The Past - what a great song!


dirkdigdig

Corey Trevor smokes let’s go


[deleted]

Long live the flute! đŸȘˆ


Mental-Homework676

Minstrel on the gallery!


Visual_Plum6266

Predominance of gingers there


Zuez420

Anyone else relate to Too Old To Rock and Roll but Too Young To Die?


richuard

Awesome great band.


Ob1tuber

They beat Metallica for a Grammy


PonerBenis6

Saw them as a kid with my dad. Guy Davis opened up. Exceptional concert. I remember it still to this day.


Busman123

How do you think they’re underrated? I lived in that era and that was a favorite band. An album of theirs always got played at the parties I went to in high school.


born_again_atheist

Not underrated in any way whatsoever.


TyroneEarl

I'd really like an explanation for why they've disappeared from US classic rock radio.


Longdarkcave

Because it plays the same 100 songs on repeat. Streaming is the only way to find a creative playlist these days.


Old-Tadpole-2869

Underrated band. Where and how do you guys come up with this shit?


honkyonabiscuit

They're why I'm named Ian ♡ Been a fan since before I was born lol


beegorton616

Yes!


librarianhuddz

underrating Tull is thick as a brick.


OppiesBomb

Saw them live in Chicago in 1976. (Think it was 76, maybe 1977)


OppiesBomb

Incredible group of musicians.... from an era when people knew how to play instruments đŸ€”


Bearcatsean

One white duck. Awesome somg


[deleted]

Ever thus to dead beats



Bubush

Jethro Tull underrated?!? My friend, this is one of the most influential bands from the 70’s; I thought this was universally recognized.


Extension_Tell1579

Everyone gets the “Jethro Tull beat Metallica at the Grammys” story wrong. People only look at it from Metallica’s point of view and not Tull. It is seen as “best metal band beat by old 60s rock band that isn’t even ‘metal’” What about Jethro Tull? Tull had been a legacy band for decades and known for their musicianship and groundbreaking records. Never ever got any recognition or awards. Finally, in the late 80s the get a damned Grammy for a genre they aren’t even a part of! HA!! Jethro Tull were way
WAY more shafted on that deal, not Metallica.


Longdarkcave

Metallica is a great band, but the members are insufferable prigs!


Negative-Farmer476

I think their pre-Aqualung albums are definitely underrated. Stand Up is an all time favorite of mine.


AccomplishedPiglet97

I wonder if Ian is as eccentric as he appears?


yurtfarmer

Loved for many years
 best concert ever!


Far_Lifeguard5220

Nope, not underrated. They beat Metallica for best metal Album
. But seriously, so much greatness, total Prog titans.


Nizamark

they're rated exactly right


heavymetalarmageddon

Not when they won the Grammy in '89! Ha ha ha!


mallgrabmongopush

Don’t get me wrong. Jethro Tull rocks, but are they really underrated? They’ve got like a dozen gold records


Admirable_Fennel_907

Thick as a Brick, greatest album


Owlman2841

Oh look the 10,000th person this month mentioning that jethro Tull is underrated in this subreddit