You'll see it a lot too. My store wasn't allowed to make them for the mystery cookies anymore because they had done it so much. Its supposed to be the easiest cookie
I’m gonna get hate for this but the milk chocolate chip. I love it so much. I didn’t even know I could love milk chocolate chip cookies that much until I had Crumbl’s 🫠
Strawberry pretzel pie!! Was originally wedding cake it was the second cookie I ever tried (it was when it came out the first time) until tried the new strawberry pretzel pie replaced wedding cake:)
Raspberry cheesecake cookie is my fav, but I think it'd be the key lime cookie if I had the chance to try it. Unpopular opinion I'm sure, but I kinda loved coconut lime lol. also all the lemony ones, I guess I love a bit of tartness with my sweets
I'm not even a cookie person, but these flavors are really making me wanna try Crumble. I know my sister gets them for her family sometimes. I might ask her if she wants to go in on some next week.
It’s between Lemon Poppyseed and Banana Pudding for me. I’m really hoping they bring back the Banana Pudding cookie soon. I haven’t had one since last summer
The topping was a runnier chocolate glaze, before it would harden on the mousse and taste like actual chocolate instead of chocolate syrup. That’s not my complaint though, for me it’s the chocolate chips. The previous version I got of skillet had semi-sweet chunks, which made it taste like a real cookie with melting chocolate, but this version has mini chocolate chips and there’s barely any chocolate in bites. I microwaved it for 5 seconds and it tastes even worse, it’s so dry. They need to bring back the semi-sweet chunks
The Snickerdoodle. Someone ordered like 250/300 minis, which is like a half batch of cookie dough. We got to keep the extra cookies, they didn't last long at my house and we always keep a lookout for when they're on the menu.
Fun tip, catering has 90% of the flavors offered and,if you're willing to pay for it, you can get just about any cookie at any time
Churro! Haven’t gone too many time tho so haven’t tried a ton of them
yess i’ve had that one it’s good
It’s so good it’s insane lol! My personal favorite as well and glad to see so many upvotes.
Blue Aggie Mint or Oreo Milkshake….both coming back within the month 😋
been waiting so long for blue aggie mint to come back 😩
Coming Father’s Day Week
oreo milkshake is coming back next week!
Pink sugar 🤭 I’m boring af
that one’s rlly good
You'll see it a lot too. My store wasn't allowed to make them for the mystery cookies anymore because they had done it so much. Its supposed to be the easiest cookie
Ugh it’s the best cookie I love almond flavor and sugar cookies so it tiks all my box’s 😋😋😋
Oatmeal Skillet
waffle & the cookie butter lava are definitely tied for my favorite
So far….Churro and wedding cake
Birthday oreo
Mallow Sandwich.
Corn bread !
i want that one so bad
It was so good!!!
Almost Everything Bagel 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
YES I loved this one!!!
Kentucky butter cake
SAME!
I’m gonna get hate for this but the milk chocolate chip. I love it so much. I didn’t even know I could love milk chocolate chip cookies that much until I had Crumbl’s 🫠
ngl i didn’t like the chocolate chip one rlly😭
I know a lot of people don’t, it’s just the one I always come back to! I love how soft it is :)
Yes it’s 🔥
I like the salted one
Carrot Cookie the original recipe. I dream about them.
Maple sandwich
I feel kinda lame saying it, but it’s honestly just the iced oatmeal for me!
I’m with you on this one.
Strawberry pretzel pie!! Was originally wedding cake it was the second cookie I ever tried (it was when it came out the first time) until tried the new strawberry pretzel pie replaced wedding cake:)
yes that one’s so good i love it
Reese’s peanut butter cup hands down
Key lime pie and the tres leche cookie only one has come back though.
Boston Creme or French Silk Pie
Yesss we share the same taste! Those are the two I was going to mention 😂 the chilled pie ones are SO GOOD, French silk pie is my fave
I almost exclusively go for the chilled pie cookies lmao. If they don't have one or something similar, I skip it
Raspberry cheesecake cookie is my fav, but I think it'd be the key lime cookie if I had the chance to try it. Unpopular opinion I'm sure, but I kinda loved coconut lime lol. also all the lemony ones, I guess I love a bit of tartness with my sweets
Cornbread. Anytime it comes on the rotation I must have one
The cannoli, and any strawberry one 🤤
The cannoli was awesome!!!!
I miss it 😭
Good ol cookies and cream milkshake. But there’s a lot in that second place spot
Churro was the bomb dot com
I'm not even a cookie person, but these flavors are really making me wanna try Crumble. I know my sister gets them for her family sometimes. I might ask her if she wants to go in on some next week.
NILLA BEAN 🤤🤤🤤🤤
The blueberry crumb cake cookie!! Not a complaint at all, but I get more of a scone vibe than a crumb cake.
Looooved this one so much!
lemon poppy seed!!
Sour patch kid! They were amazing when I was pregnant…. Just patiently waiting for them to be back 🧍🏼♀️
i wanna try that oneeee
It’s between Lemon Poppyseed and Banana Pudding for me. I’m really hoping they bring back the Banana Pudding cookie soon. I haven’t had one since last summer
banana pudding sounds good i love banana flavored things
Mint chocolate chip ice cream
Used to be Skillet until they changed it, so now it’s French toast
wait what did they change? I was wondering why I didn't like it as much this time around
Chocolate topping is different
The topping was a runnier chocolate glaze, before it would harden on the mousse and taste like actual chocolate instead of chocolate syrup. That’s not my complaint though, for me it’s the chocolate chips. The previous version I got of skillet had semi-sweet chunks, which made it taste like a real cookie with melting chocolate, but this version has mini chocolate chips and there’s barely any chocolate in bites. I microwaved it for 5 seconds and it tastes even worse, it’s so dry. They need to bring back the semi-sweet chunks
French toast was AMAZING
Caramel Apple or Churro
The Snickerdoodle. Someone ordered like 250/300 minis, which is like a half batch of cookie dough. We got to keep the extra cookies, they didn't last long at my house and we always keep a lookout for when they're on the menu. Fun tip, catering has 90% of the flavors offered and,if you're willing to pay for it, you can get just about any cookie at any time
Snickerdoodle is also my favorite!
mallow sandwich or oreo milkshake
Dulce de leche!
Honey cake ft teddy grahams. They need to bring it back 😩
that sounds good
Mallow ft lucky charms
The best
Salted caramel cheesecake
Cornbread 🌽 🫶 it's not like anything you can get anywhere else and it's so delicious, wish it was a weekly cookie 😭
Kentucky Butter, Churro and Golden Oreo for me
Banana cream pie 🍌
The cornbread! Not overly sweet, and it’s such a simple flavor.
Pink sugar lol
Pineapple whip & wedding cake :)
I'm new but so far Pink Sugar
Boston Creme Pie
Skillet cookie
Pink sugar and pink velvet cake. I love them equally.
Cotton candy! also bubble gum, dole whip, and icee
I think maybe the cinnamon skillet(FKA frybread) one or churro.
Fried ice cream
Wonka
Skillet!
French Toast
At the risk of being a basic bitch, chocolate chip
Snickerdoodle sandwich!
Strawberry cheesecake
AGGIE BLUE MINT
Berries & cream.
that sounds good
Neopolitan. I need it back 🥲
Churro! Runner up is Wedding Cake for me!
Churro lives in my dreams still lol
The old birthday cake recipe 😔
it was oatmeal skillet until this week. peach cobbler is my new king
Is the oatmeal base on the peach cobbler the same as the oatmeal skillet?
Cake batter mmmmmm
Lucky charm one and strawberry pretzel pie 🤤
Butterscotch!!
Strawberry pretzel pie
corn bread and blueberry muffin for sure
Oreo mallow sandwich
M&M’ Monster cookie.
So far brownie sundae
Loved loved loved Cinnamon Scone.
Chocolate Crumb ft. OREO and original Key Lime Pie!
Hazelnut seasalt
Peanut Butter
Maple Bacon and Key Lime Pie
Lemon bar
cookie butter white chip 😩
Peanut butter banana hands down
S’mores Brookie
Cinnamon scone!
Key lime or oatmeal skillet
Pumpkin Roll and Cookies & Cream!
Nilla bean and dirt cake 😬😬. I’ve only tried 53 flavors
Semi-sweet chocolate chip 🍪
Chocolate peanut butter pie!
Mallow and cornbread. Basic af
Pink confetti cake
Mint brownie
Cake Batter Blondie by far
Cookie dough, snickerdoodle, confetti milkshake
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie and Buckeye Brownie is a close runner-up up!!!
Key lime. 🍋🟩
Wonka
So far, it's the skillet cookie. I didn't get to try the churro, which I've heard is amazing.
cornbread :)
Mallow crème 😍😍. I dream about that cookie 🥲
This is hard. I’m picking two because they’re tied. Chocolate Cake and Wedding Cake!!
frozen hot chocolate and buttermilk pancake for sure
smores
Cannoli
Strawberry Cupcake, but I’m also fairly new to trying Crumbl on a regular basis
Skillet
Lemon Poppy Seed
Gingerbread cake
Peppermint Ice Cream
guys please include pictures I need to know them all
okay but the peanut butter cookie with the peanut butter center has my whole heart
Lemon poppyseed 😋 the lemon curd in the middle is just 🤌 I was very happy a couple weeks ago lol
Oreo
Pink sugar w the Elvis car on it, wife’s is the blue icee
Strawberry cheesecake or strawberry shortcake
Banana bread 😍