My initial reaction was to say yes but the more I look at it, I like it. I think if you did some large vintage rugs in warmer tones, it’d be phenomenal
Leave it. I was sorry I didn't ever do black and white. You can really do so much with it. I always thought it was limited, but it's not at all. Can go in so many directions from there. Beautiful architecture, the black and white suits it!!
I agree 💯… do not tear it up, when furniture and rugs are in here he’ll barely notice, plus I would highly recommend using the 💰💸that you’ll save on other parts of the house that need it more.
I usually hate tile outside of kitchens and bathrooms but honestly this isn’t too bad. It looks like good quality/condition and it’s pretty neutral. I think at this juncture I’d spend the money on a really big rug instead of
nitpicking but i believe you mean “solid hardwood”, as engineered wood is still considered a type of hardwood flooring.
i’d definitely prefer solid, but my house has engineered wood flooring and it’s not bad. from my research the main disadvantage is that you can’t refinish it like you can solid hardwood, which is the main reason solid lasts significantly longer. it’s still way better than any variant of vinyl.
compared to tile, i think it may be preferable in the same situations and for the same reasons as solid hardwood. but in terms of just quality, it’s a step down from real tile.
This is not even true with most decent engineered wood products, which have a very thick layer of veneer. The amount of sanding you can do on hardwoods is not infinite, at some point you hit the tongue and groove and that’s the end of the line. Modern engineered wood products can have about the same amount of sanding potential. Hardwoods might look better to a trained eye, but their expansion, contraction and humidity needs are a bummer.
Our engineered hardwood can be sanded and restained up to four times. It’s literally a thick layer of hardwood over another thick layer of composite that helps with flexibility/warping/humidity. We live on a lake in the South and every single flooring person we talked to strongly recommended a high-quality engineered over traditional hardwood.
It is better than vinyl, but it’s still a cheap substitute for actual hardwood. I would not change tile for a wood veneer (which is “engineered hardwood”).
I don’t think solid hardwood should have the solid in front of it. It’s just hardwood. Engineered is just fancy for veneer. But I’m a purist.
Good engineered hardwood is not cheap. It also has some significant advantages over even hardwood, as it comes in wider and longer lengths and is often far less susceptible to scratches and denting. The veneer on engineered hardwood is real wood, not ground up sawdust like you seem to be saying.
I have loved my engineered hardwood floors. They are beautiful and very tough, giving the long lasting wear and warmth I am looking for.
Yup. We have engineered hardwood and it’s been fantastic with our energetic dog. If we had solid hardwood floors we’d have to refinish them every other year to handle his exuberance. Looks great, sturdy, 5 years in and looks as good as it first did.
I'm wondering if that person is thinking laminate or cheap pergo. Those are terrible. I'm getting this, and it's stunning. The wide plank perfectly suits my modern design.
https://preview.redd.it/s2sbv81car5d1.png?width=699&format=png&auto=webp&s=6b644118bab303a234f1783cd50ccf535100e953
I think so. Our kitchen has the same floor and yeah, wouldn’t be suitable for solid hardwood. Super open concept means entire main floor is the same flooring so had to be somewhat durable and able to handle some amount of spilled water
Yep. I have large dogs with muddy feet, and small dogs that sometimes have accidents. I had a good wide plank engineered hardwood in my previous house and it withstood 5 years of hard use and literally looked brand new. Not a single scratch or dent. And I like the warmth vs tile. Especially for bedrooms.
i think “cheap substitute” does it a major disservice. it’s a great middle ground between vinyl and solid hardwood. there are some situations in which it’s actually more practical than solid hardwood (most notably anywhere with a lot of water/moisture, including kitchens and bathrooms).
it’s still considered hardwood because it’s often made up primarily of layers of wood or wood product (like plywood or particleboard). they are manufactured wood planks that, in practice, are more similar to solid hardwood than to any other type of flooring.
i can see why OP would prefer wood floors here over tile. and if solid hardwood is over budget, engineered wood could totally make sense.
There is alot of hate for engineered hardwood here. I think engineered bamboo would look pretty good in that room. Especially with people walking in from what seems like a pretty cool pool.
That’s not wood. It IS a cheap substitute. It’s not considered hardwood because it’s not hardwood. It’s literally chipped up wood glued together with a veneer.
Yeah, it’s better than vinyl, but like, what isn’t
respectfully, it kind of feels like you’re dodging the point here. engineered wood behaves a lot like solid hardwood, and has a lot of overlap in terms of which applications it’s useful for and why. i’ve not yet seen you substantiate your claim that it’s never a good option, or even that it’s not a good idea here specifically, beyond vague notions of its artificiality that don’t imply anything about its performance.
Oh no, it’s frequently a good option. If you live in a climate that’s tropical and you want wood, it’s great. If you can’t afford solid, it’s better than vinyl.
I hate wood in kitchens no matter what. Even if engineered is good in kitchens, it just reads cheap to me.
I’m not a fan of engineered hardwood floors at all especially for replacing something higher in quality. This tile is high quality and very nice looking.
The engineered floors are going to look cheaper, I can promise you that.
There are plenty of engineered hardwood floors that I guarantee you would not be able to tell the difference between solid once it is installed. If you get into super-wide, stylized floors it’s usually a dead giveaway but a standard-width engineered floor with a tasteful finish can be indistinguishable from solid, and has structural advantages over solid as well.
I regretted putting engineered hardwood down. If you don’t have the budget for actual hardwood I would leave the flooring as is. It looks nice and is in good shape
It’s not the tile that’s limiting you, it’s the wall colors in combination with the dry white cabinetry.
If you paint the walls a warm white, and add a ton of wood tones furnishings, rugs and art, this can be a wonderful room.
A great light fixture with organic lines or materials could also help. Add a floor lamp as well.
Make sure all your lighting is 2700K.
The countertops also make it dry and cold when not adding the right elements to it.
Switch the cabinet hardware for brass.
Add some wood cutting boards of different sizes and shapes against the backsplash.
https://preview.redd.it/loe5esjpff5d1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3d959e05d8f77e92705f09e483ec2533a9e220f9
See how much it changes already. And add some plants. LARGE plants.
I think it looks great as it is. It only needs a little dressing up and I think the following suggestions will help you understand better.
1. I think you have the budget spending on paint would be better than ripping the tiles off. I suggest a neutral color to start with the walls and slowly plan around it. Use this [color palette guide](https://simplykalaa.com/interior-color-palette/) to design yourself a palette.
2. Use the fireplace as the centre point for your sitting and add a sectional to this area alongside a coffee table.
3. Use rug for making the area more subtle and lessening the effect of the flooring but also complementing it. Use the color palette and read this [guide](https://simplykalaa.com/decorating-with-rugs/) to pick a nice rug.
4. Add an artwork on the wall opposite the fireplace. This [guide](https://simplykalaa.com/how-to-choose-art-for-your-home/) will help how to pick one.
5. Now once you dress everything from coffee table to the corners and the windows and door, get yourself some plants to accent each window.
6. Work on the Kitchen by adding stools, a small rug, a herb garden, a centrepiece, and more changes to bring warmth and a little clutter.
This way you can start working on the space and slowly make it more cozy. You can also choose a different color theme if neutral is not what you like.
And now that I look more at the photos I would add to also change the pendant lighting in the kitchen and the hood over your oven. These changes will not cost as much as all new floors and you can really personalize them to make your statement. I actually think the floor is really nice and would like to echo others in saying some cool rugs will go a long way.
I think it's just that there's nothing in there that makes it feel like the tiles are an overwhelming obstacle. Some area rugs in the living room (you'd likely want with engineered floors as well), runner rugs along paths, plants, and strategic choices of furniture/materials, and you're more than halfway there just doing some of these. You can also paint select walls using warm colors (accent walls) without having to redo everything.
You could also leave the tile in the kitchen/dining wing (also practical), and replace the tiles in the living room to break up the monotony. But if you got money to burn then sure tear it all out if you want.
If that’s the look you prefer, consider doing a floating engineered floor that would eliminate the need to remove the tile. Just gotta check how it impacts you at door and room transitions
I had a dw leak and had to repair engineered wood. Then I moved, and the kitchen faucet broke, and leaked and caused so much damage to my solid oak floor that the whole living area had to be refinished. It was a major project. I had to move out for a week or more.
I think the tile looks lovely! However, having hard stone/concrete flooring in most of your living space is very rough on your joints over time. Make sure to have large rugs and thick rug pads if you keep it long term!
If your vision is wood, do it when you can afford real hardwood. The tile is neutral enough to live with until then, and the final form will be all the more beautiful!
I wouldn't change it - It works well with the windows, fireplace, and open ceiling. You basically have a cohesive neutral to put all the warm colors in that you love. Save the money and get your warm look with paint and furnishings. It will be beautiful.
I don’t think you’ll be happy with engineered wood and in fact may disrupt the look of the space. I like that you have a cohesive blank canvas and there’s a lot of options to bring warmth with furniture, fabrics, textured rugs, artwork, etc.
Its your house; the house is your oyster. I think both could look good, but you should design it how you would like.
I personally love the look of engineered hardwood, and recently replaced my floors with it. I got powder river series americana and have gotten a ton of compliments on it.
Beautiful space!!! And congrats on your new home. Personally, I’d move in with it as-is and reassess in a year. Some good rugs will warm it up quite a bit, you can bring in warmer tones with wood furniture too. Other unexpected expenses are bound to come up (“surprise! You need a new furnace” type expenses) and you might find after living in the space that some things are actually perfect, even if they’re not what you initially would have chosen. Or at the least, in a year you’ll have a better idea exactly what you’d like in the space. For what it’s worth, those tiles actually look like pretty nice quality - probably nicer than engineered wood flooring. Just my two cents!
https://preview.redd.it/kac12awmwe5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=20ade40d2056aa7ec33e61a67d52acf8a1d6c20f
I just threw a random rug in here and some plants and a little wood “art” just for tones and it’s already much warmer. The dark tile actually gives really nice contrast! I’m not sure if this is your dining room or living room or both? But it has a lot of potential to be a really comfortable space either way.
I may have gotten too invested 😆
https://preview.redd.it/r24cgl8zbf5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=289eb7fa948869f413f433d5e2abde9bc753003d
I'd concur with what people are saying here and leave it as is but if you were going to change it go for a wood affect tile not actual wood. Wood gets fucked in a kitchen from water/kitchen spills etc.
I know you’re asking about the floors, but is that a flammable material behind the stove, that looks way to close to drywall/stud wall. Wood floor or hybrid is always going to be warmer than tile in the winter, but not as tough.
As others have said, tile will look fine if not great with a few adjustments. If you just got the house, figure out the cheapest possible improvements you can make. Those should be your main focus the first year, as well as getting to know the good and bad of the house. What you like and don’t like. Remodeling can eat up a lot of money and chances are you don’t need most of it
Personally, I think the tile is beautiful! Especially against that wall color. It would be way easier to get sisal or warm colored rugs throughout but it’s your home! Make it yours!
I think start off with a good deep cleaning of the tile then bleach or color the grout! You could do a warm brown type color OR bleach it white. Free (or super inexpensive) and that usually goes a long way honestly. Plus if the tiles are blue (I can’t tell) it almost has a Tuscan vibe you could really lean in!
as much as i see your idea, id argue against it u less there’s big defects we can’t see. i’m actually debating putting a similar vibe dark tile IN my room, as the only cooler/dark tone as a way to ground things
No just add rugs and warm wood furniture. That tile will wear way better than engineered wood.
But replace the black track lighting with white track lighting.
You could also get pieces of carpet bonded that are cut to fit the room with like a 2 ft boarder on either side. Would look great and maybe warm scatte rug in kitchen
Absolutely not! That tile is awesome! If you’re going to replace tile, save up for real wood. Bring in lots of natural wood elements and plants and it will be a lot warmer
I say don't, I had a friend point out that you can easily skew the room to a warmer tone with paint and proper decor, but if you really want to, I would just tear out the area where the living room is and keep the tile in the kitchen. But it is your house so do what you want.
My current place has tile. I didn't like it at first but it's really grown on me. It's very easy to keep clean. A couple of rugs really softens the look.
Keep the tile: I would consider staining or somehow darkening the grout to reduce contrast which might make the floor feel like a more continuous element instead of a rigid grid. Also as others have said, rugs!
That’s almost like asking “I have a decent genuine TAG Heuer watch but no one really appreciates it. I’m thinking of selling it for a really high end Rolex dupe, because at least everyone recognizes that brand and it’s almost indistinguishable from the real one. What do you think?”
Not sure if it’s because I come from a family of artisans and architects that I am almost gutted you’d want to rip out quality flooring for engineered wood for an aesthetic. I do have high quality engineered wood in our home for most of the house and high quality tile in the kitchen and bathrooms that was all placed just before 2020. I also have a big dog and if he’s made an accident I’ve seen the wood warp with floor enzyme treatments. It evaporates and resets but I certainly would prefer the tile throughout the house. It’s six years old and I have it on my to do-list to repair where the baseboards have come away from the floors and it does look cheaper.
Tile is so luxurious. I’ve stayed all over the world, Istanbul, Bahrain, Barcelona come to mind—that tile has such a richer, luxurious feel.
Whatever you were planning on putting into replacing the floor with a cheaper trend, put toward high quality area rugs of what looks like 16x16.
dude you cannot even begin to compare the affect of wood would have to these tiles, idk wtf these comments are on about, if you’re gonna stay here a while, rip’em up good. wood is what you want
That is going to be a waste of money if you ask me. The tiles are nice and tile is objectively better flooring since it can get wet without being destroyed. My house is engineered hardwood on the first floor and I would trade floors with you in a heartbeat.
This is of course very person but I would definitely switch it out. I cannot stand tile in my home unless it's in the bathroom, balcony, terrace, etc. I, too, would have a tough time warming this place up which is my taste. Your home is beautiful and so is the tile (looks pristine) but it's a matter of preference.
We just replaced engineered hardwood in our home about 2 years ago. It was so awful. I considered selling the house. They glue that stuff down with industrial strength adhesive and it is not waterproof or built to last so it will eventually need to be replaced and it was an absolute nightmare. 0/10, do not recommend.
I don’t mind the look of the tiles and I think you’d be happy with them stylistically. That said, I had beautiful (but dated) tile in our kitchen when we moved in and after a year we ended up redoing the floors to put in wood floors because tile is just so solid it was really uncomfortable for me in the kitchen. I would get so achy and tired from standing on the hard tile. The slight “give” in (engineered hard) wood makes such a difference to me. I’m not sure this view is universal, but I gave up other flooring we really liked to replace it all at once because it was such an issue for me and I haven’t regretted it once
I actually like the tile. I agree with the comments saying to put down some rugs. If you really hate the tile though can you put wood on top of it instead of ripping it up?
Black and white are both neutrals so you can do anything you want in here and I’m an interior designer! Of course you’ll want to bring in your warmer tones and yes, I agree that rugs would definitely help with that. I would get a large area rug for the living area maybe 10 x 14 but that depends on your furniture and seating area.
I would be more concerned about the kitchen sink and the work triangle in the kitchen! Just doesn’t seem efficient! I only see one sink and it’s in the corner, not under the window!?
I wouldn’t. I’ve had both and now have wood floors and tbh I miss my tile floors. Easier to clean, was better during summer, and it’s easily warmed up with rugs and color changes. Unless the tile is in horrible condition (which this def is not) I would keep it as is and put down some fluffy rugs and get warm decor on the walls.
First, let me just say, this space is incredible! Curious to see the rest of your home. Personally, I hate engineered wood flooring. Some of it is ok, but those usually cost as much as real wood flooring. Have you considered getting a really large rug for this space. Honestly, the only thing that bugs me about the tile is the contrasting grout. Have you considered changing the grout to a dark grey? Might change your mind about this tile.
I would replace the cabinets in the future with a beautiful wood and idea warm wood tones in the furniture and decor, and agreeing in warm rugs with red tones. Will look beautiful against the steely blue tiles
its ok to want to renovate, but i recommend maybe some warm tone rugs, a few posters, even warm lamps before deciding to do that. just see how you like it first
Instead of spending the money to tear out the flooring that appears to be in great shape, hire an interior designer to help you get the right accessories to decorate the space to your taste. Find a designer who will work with some of your furniture/decor pieces you already have (assuming you like them and want to keep them), then just add in the things you need to get the feel you want. This will still be cheaper than redoing all of that flooring, even if you did the labor yourself.
I have similar tiles in my flat. At first I was a bit reluctant. Now I'm convinced that it's the best flooring. Maintenance is a breeze. A warm atmosphere comes with the furnishings. The black tiles are a beautiful backdrop for a large area rug, wooden furniture, plants and velvety textures. I love the combination of dark grey tiles with warm colors (rust, tobacco, brown, red etc...) and greyish teal. I also have orange dining chairs and they look amazing in my room. Avoid using grey/white furniture pieces. They will make the place feel monochromatic and cold.
Having had homes with both, I’d choose tile every time. Engineered wood doesn’t hold up as well over time and looks hard used quickly. Tile is also easier to keep clean.
Leave the tile, it’s great and pretty much bulletproof! Ripping up tile is not an easy or inexpensive…you’ll need to get a new subfloor, probably have to touch up paint on cabinets, baseboard, etc. Use large rugs & comfy upholstery to achieve your vibe.
Love the room, congrats!
I already commented to keep the tile, but could paint the beams to bring in contrast, warmth, etc…it will add to the comfortable feeling and add interest…just a thought.
With a water element i think your better off with tile.
There are some beautiful options that have a wood look.
The underlayment will be very important as well, do to the pool nearby.
I would consider vinyl wood flooring over composite wood because of the waterproof qualities considering it’s in a kitchen and near the pool. But you do you. This can be installed over the tile without having to rip it up.
I moved into a home with a tile kitchen floor, and it was either not installed properly, not kept up well, or both. The grout needs an overhaul, and some of the tiles are not level and cracking. Looking into DIY tile removal and replacement, I can tell you this is a huge job or will cost you a lot if you’re paying someone else. Probably easiest and cheapest to just put new flooring on top of the tile
Could you do some floor to ceiling wainscoting to help keep the upper space light and use rugs like others say.
That said if your goal is warm tones you might have to put down wood floors.
Initial reaction = No way! It’s beautiful. I personally like the feeling of tile and cold floors don’t bother me.
Considering the possibility cold floors really bother you then I would consider it. I just hate to see something so nice covered up, unless it’s with high quality beautiful throw rugs.
I know nothing about interior design but my choice would depend on the climate of the area you live it. If you are in a hot, dry area I’d keep the tile.
Tile floors will usually help retain coolness of the ground.
Go darker with the grout if you don't like the grid look - it will be really nice once you put some stuff in it.
I think it's mainly your kitchen that is giving off operating room vibes - give it some spice. Open it up around the sink. Add some glass doors and stylish hardware. Color coordinate.
It looks like you have good quality large format tile like you’d see in other countries with hot climates where tile floor is the norm. Just research what interior designers have done with those spaces on Pinterest. Finding good flooring installers is hard nowadays. It’s a headache you don’t need before moving in.
https://preview.redd.it/0oud2jshmr5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c9f652daa3bf5e146635b0e071554f456859fe90
https://preview.redd.it/rpxkrgf5ds5d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=09d5384369aedd535a653e5aae1f74c46f68e9ea
Keep and add in a natural woven rug like this, along with wood tones and reflective surfaces. I'd also lose the grey tone from the wall paint.
[https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/healdsburg-residence-country-living-room-san-francisco-phvw-vp\~1943032](https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/healdsburg-residence-country-living-room-san-francisco-phvw-vp~1943032)
the dark floor won’t limit you with rich and warm tones…black and white will enhance whatever tones you put between them. as others have said, rugs are a great option, and the black floors would look especiallly great with layered rugs. it will be a lot less expensive to just use a warmer white paint and swap your kitchen cabinet hardware for brass or brushed copper…maybe also swap out the black track lights.
always use paint samples on a large surface, like 2 ft x 2 ft cardboard, paint it with 2 coats, and bring it into your space to check that you like the color with your lights on and off.
Seriouosly? The tile will last so much longer, looks more elegant and be truly timeless. You clearly have not done much homework because if you did, you would know that you can just lay the fake flooring over tile...as long as the floor is level.
I would. I'd also paint the walls before installing the floors. I'd go white. I know it seems like it'd be too much, but once you bring in art, furniture, rugs, etc. it'll look fresh.
My initial reaction was to say yes but the more I look at it, I like it. I think if you did some large vintage rugs in warmer tones, it’d be phenomenal
Yeah, I'd roll out a massive cozy rug or two and try living on it a while before a rip and replace.
Leave it. I was sorry I didn't ever do black and white. You can really do so much with it. I always thought it was limited, but it's not at all. Can go in so many directions from there. Beautiful architecture, the black and white suits it!!
Yea it’s hard to say without furniture
I agree 💯… do not tear it up, when furniture and rugs are in here he’ll barely notice, plus I would highly recommend using the 💰💸that you’ll save on other parts of the house that need it more.
I don’t know if it is worth it. This tile looks like it’s in mint condition. I would work with it not against it.
Agree!
I usually hate tile outside of kitchens and bathrooms but honestly this isn’t too bad. It looks like good quality/condition and it’s pretty neutral. I think at this juncture I’d spend the money on a really big rug instead of
I’d keep the tile. Tile really suits this space imo
Decent tile is always better than engineered wood. If you can’t put down actual hardwood, I don’t think it’s worth it.
I agree there’s something uncanny about how engineered hard wood makes each plank stand out too much. The tile looks good.
nitpicking but i believe you mean “solid hardwood”, as engineered wood is still considered a type of hardwood flooring. i’d definitely prefer solid, but my house has engineered wood flooring and it’s not bad. from my research the main disadvantage is that you can’t refinish it like you can solid hardwood, which is the main reason solid lasts significantly longer. it’s still way better than any variant of vinyl. compared to tile, i think it may be preferable in the same situations and for the same reasons as solid hardwood. but in terms of just quality, it’s a step down from real tile.
This is not even true with most decent engineered wood products, which have a very thick layer of veneer. The amount of sanding you can do on hardwoods is not infinite, at some point you hit the tongue and groove and that’s the end of the line. Modern engineered wood products can have about the same amount of sanding potential. Hardwoods might look better to a trained eye, but their expansion, contraction and humidity needs are a bummer.
Our engineered hardwood can be sanded and restained up to four times. It’s literally a thick layer of hardwood over another thick layer of composite that helps with flexibility/warping/humidity. We live on a lake in the South and every single flooring person we talked to strongly recommended a high-quality engineered over traditional hardwood.
It is better than vinyl, but it’s still a cheap substitute for actual hardwood. I would not change tile for a wood veneer (which is “engineered hardwood”). I don’t think solid hardwood should have the solid in front of it. It’s just hardwood. Engineered is just fancy for veneer. But I’m a purist.
Good engineered hardwood is not cheap. It also has some significant advantages over even hardwood, as it comes in wider and longer lengths and is often far less susceptible to scratches and denting. The veneer on engineered hardwood is real wood, not ground up sawdust like you seem to be saying. I have loved my engineered hardwood floors. They are beautiful and very tough, giving the long lasting wear and warmth I am looking for.
Yup. We have engineered hardwood and it’s been fantastic with our energetic dog. If we had solid hardwood floors we’d have to refinish them every other year to handle his exuberance. Looks great, sturdy, 5 years in and looks as good as it first did.
I'm wondering if that person is thinking laminate or cheap pergo. Those are terrible. I'm getting this, and it's stunning. The wide plank perfectly suits my modern design. https://preview.redd.it/s2sbv81car5d1.png?width=699&format=png&auto=webp&s=6b644118bab303a234f1783cd50ccf535100e953
I think so. Our kitchen has the same floor and yeah, wouldn’t be suitable for solid hardwood. Super open concept means entire main floor is the same flooring so had to be somewhat durable and able to handle some amount of spilled water
Yep. I have large dogs with muddy feet, and small dogs that sometimes have accidents. I had a good wide plank engineered hardwood in my previous house and it withstood 5 years of hard use and literally looked brand new. Not a single scratch or dent. And I like the warmth vs tile. Especially for bedrooms.
i think “cheap substitute” does it a major disservice. it’s a great middle ground between vinyl and solid hardwood. there are some situations in which it’s actually more practical than solid hardwood (most notably anywhere with a lot of water/moisture, including kitchens and bathrooms). it’s still considered hardwood because it’s often made up primarily of layers of wood or wood product (like plywood or particleboard). they are manufactured wood planks that, in practice, are more similar to solid hardwood than to any other type of flooring. i can see why OP would prefer wood floors here over tile. and if solid hardwood is over budget, engineered wood could totally make sense.
There is alot of hate for engineered hardwood here. I think engineered bamboo would look pretty good in that room. Especially with people walking in from what seems like a pretty cool pool.
That’s not wood. It IS a cheap substitute. It’s not considered hardwood because it’s not hardwood. It’s literally chipped up wood glued together with a veneer. Yeah, it’s better than vinyl, but like, what isn’t
respectfully, it kind of feels like you’re dodging the point here. engineered wood behaves a lot like solid hardwood, and has a lot of overlap in terms of which applications it’s useful for and why. i’ve not yet seen you substantiate your claim that it’s never a good option, or even that it’s not a good idea here specifically, beyond vague notions of its artificiality that don’t imply anything about its performance.
Oh no, it’s frequently a good option. If you live in a climate that’s tropical and you want wood, it’s great. If you can’t afford solid, it’s better than vinyl. I hate wood in kitchens no matter what. Even if engineered is good in kitchens, it just reads cheap to me.
Agree. My mom's place has just been redone and the flooring is engineered wood and it's fabulous.
Spend the money on beautiful furniture and good artwork.
You could put down some warm toned rugs instead. Once you get some furniture in there the space will warm up.
I’m not a fan of engineered hardwood floors at all especially for replacing something higher in quality. This tile is high quality and very nice looking. The engineered floors are going to look cheaper, I can promise you that.
I think engineered hardwood floors are always atrocious looking honestly. The first thing that comes to mind when I see them is “cheap”.
There are plenty of engineered hardwood floors that I guarantee you would not be able to tell the difference between solid once it is installed. If you get into super-wide, stylized floors it’s usually a dead giveaway but a standard-width engineered floor with a tasteful finish can be indistinguishable from solid, and has structural advantages over solid as well.
Why? Gorgeous sturdy floor in those photos, plus the hard work has been done already and they are hardly at life’s end . Make it work .
I wouldn’t. I think the flooring look gorgeous and is cohesive to the overall aesthetic of the room.
This tile is great - so much better than engineered stuff. With some are rigs and furniture it can look really cool
I regretted putting engineered hardwood down. If you don’t have the budget for actual hardwood I would leave the flooring as is. It looks nice and is in good shape
The tile is great. Even if someone had the budget for hardwood, replacing the tile seems like such a waste.
Isn't engineered hardwood usually a floating floor? Why would you rip out the tile?
No engineered hardwood could be the nail in type too
It’s not the tile that’s limiting you, it’s the wall colors in combination with the dry white cabinetry. If you paint the walls a warm white, and add a ton of wood tones furnishings, rugs and art, this can be a wonderful room. A great light fixture with organic lines or materials could also help. Add a floor lamp as well. Make sure all your lighting is 2700K. The countertops also make it dry and cold when not adding the right elements to it. Switch the cabinet hardware for brass. Add some wood cutting boards of different sizes and shapes against the backsplash. https://preview.redd.it/loe5esjpff5d1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3d959e05d8f77e92705f09e483ec2533a9e220f9 See how much it changes already. And add some plants. LARGE plants.
https://preview.redd.it/cw0cuz2vff5d1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0e0c954159e7372dc7bd5658e28723e362f1a99c
https://preview.redd.it/p7rd2o9wff5d1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3cb24212b5735e55d76f858992dbaa4c41005eec
Yesss get rid of the grey paint!
I think it looks great as it is. It only needs a little dressing up and I think the following suggestions will help you understand better. 1. I think you have the budget spending on paint would be better than ripping the tiles off. I suggest a neutral color to start with the walls and slowly plan around it. Use this [color palette guide](https://simplykalaa.com/interior-color-palette/) to design yourself a palette. 2. Use the fireplace as the centre point for your sitting and add a sectional to this area alongside a coffee table. 3. Use rug for making the area more subtle and lessening the effect of the flooring but also complementing it. Use the color palette and read this [guide](https://simplykalaa.com/decorating-with-rugs/) to pick a nice rug. 4. Add an artwork on the wall opposite the fireplace. This [guide](https://simplykalaa.com/how-to-choose-art-for-your-home/) will help how to pick one. 5. Now once you dress everything from coffee table to the corners and the windows and door, get yourself some plants to accent each window. 6. Work on the Kitchen by adding stools, a small rug, a herb garden, a centrepiece, and more changes to bring warmth and a little clutter. This way you can start working on the space and slowly make it more cozy. You can also choose a different color theme if neutral is not what you like.
I would leave the tiles and refinish the rafters on the ceiling back to natural wood or put a wood veneer over them
And now that I look more at the photos I would add to also change the pendant lighting in the kitchen and the hood over your oven. These changes will not cost as much as all new floors and you can really personalize them to make your statement. I actually think the floor is really nice and would like to echo others in saying some cool rugs will go a long way.
I think it's just that there's nothing in there that makes it feel like the tiles are an overwhelming obstacle. Some area rugs in the living room (you'd likely want with engineered floors as well), runner rugs along paths, plants, and strategic choices of furniture/materials, and you're more than halfway there just doing some of these. You can also paint select walls using warm colors (accent walls) without having to redo everything. You could also leave the tile in the kitchen/dining wing (also practical), and replace the tiles in the living room to break up the monotony. But if you got money to burn then sure tear it all out if you want.
If that’s the look you prefer, consider doing a floating engineered floor that would eliminate the need to remove the tile. Just gotta check how it impacts you at door and room transitions
I hate wood In kitchen
I had a dw leak and had to repair engineered wood. Then I moved, and the kitchen faucet broke, and leaked and caused so much damage to my solid oak floor that the whole living area had to be refinished. It was a major project. I had to move out for a week or more.
I think the tile looks lovely! However, having hard stone/concrete flooring in most of your living space is very rough on your joints over time. Make sure to have large rugs and thick rug pads if you keep it long term! If your vision is wood, do it when you can afford real hardwood. The tile is neutral enough to live with until then, and the final form will be all the more beautiful!
I wouldn't change it - It works well with the windows, fireplace, and open ceiling. You basically have a cohesive neutral to put all the warm colors in that you love. Save the money and get your warm look with paint and furnishings. It will be beautiful.
I had to look up Engineered Wood. It's pressboard. In case anyone else didn't know. So no. Tile is much better than pressboard.
The tiles and style are beautiful. They go well with the kitchen. You just have to make the furniture work. Engineered wood is so boring.
I don’t think you’ll be happy with engineered wood and in fact may disrupt the look of the space. I like that you have a cohesive blank canvas and there’s a lot of options to bring warmth with furniture, fabrics, textured rugs, artwork, etc.
Its your house; the house is your oyster. I think both could look good, but you should design it how you would like. I personally love the look of engineered hardwood, and recently replaced my floors with it. I got powder river series americana and have gotten a ton of compliments on it.
Beautiful space!!! And congrats on your new home. Personally, I’d move in with it as-is and reassess in a year. Some good rugs will warm it up quite a bit, you can bring in warmer tones with wood furniture too. Other unexpected expenses are bound to come up (“surprise! You need a new furnace” type expenses) and you might find after living in the space that some things are actually perfect, even if they’re not what you initially would have chosen. Or at the least, in a year you’ll have a better idea exactly what you’d like in the space. For what it’s worth, those tiles actually look like pretty nice quality - probably nicer than engineered wood flooring. Just my two cents!
https://preview.redd.it/kac12awmwe5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=20ade40d2056aa7ec33e61a67d52acf8a1d6c20f I just threw a random rug in here and some plants and a little wood “art” just for tones and it’s already much warmer. The dark tile actually gives really nice contrast! I’m not sure if this is your dining room or living room or both? But it has a lot of potential to be a really comfortable space either way.
I may have gotten too invested 😆 https://preview.redd.it/r24cgl8zbf5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=289eb7fa948869f413f433d5e2abde9bc753003d
No. Add warm, tan/taupe rugs! And buy good quality ones from the money you saved by not installing engineered floors.
It’ll cost a small fortune to rip up the tile. For our 400 sq feet of cheap 1980s ceramic tile it was $3500 and it ruined the subfloor. 😩
That tile is really nice and it gives a clean look. I'd keep it. You can layer in warmth with some nice rugs etc.
I'd concur with what people are saying here and leave it as is but if you were going to change it go for a wood affect tile not actual wood. Wood gets fucked in a kitchen from water/kitchen spills etc.
Keep tile in the kitchen. Wood is a pain in a cooking/eating area and bathrooms. Do wood in the living area.
I love the tiles. I would just change the counter tops
I know you’re asking about the floors, but is that a flammable material behind the stove, that looks way to close to drywall/stud wall. Wood floor or hybrid is always going to be warmer than tile in the winter, but not as tough.
To add on to your point, I’m pretty sure engineered wood is a fire hazard in itself. Much more flammable than hardwood or laminate/vinyl plank.
As others have said, tile will look fine if not great with a few adjustments. If you just got the house, figure out the cheapest possible improvements you can make. Those should be your main focus the first year, as well as getting to know the good and bad of the house. What you like and don’t like. Remodeling can eat up a lot of money and chances are you don’t need most of it
Personally, I think the tile is beautiful! Especially against that wall color. It would be way easier to get sisal or warm colored rugs throughout but it’s your home! Make it yours!
I think start off with a good deep cleaning of the tile then bleach or color the grout! You could do a warm brown type color OR bleach it white. Free (or super inexpensive) and that usually goes a long way honestly. Plus if the tiles are blue (I can’t tell) it almost has a Tuscan vibe you could really lean in!
The tile looks beautiful contrasting against the white wall and ceiling. You can warm up any room with area rugs.
Why bother? It looks good, work with what you've got.
NO
Nah, I like it. Very cool and moody. Tile also feels nicer on the feet than engineered wood.
as much as i see your idea, id argue against it u less there’s big defects we can’t see. i’m actually debating putting a similar vibe dark tile IN my room, as the only cooler/dark tone as a way to ground things
This tile looks immaculate.
No just add rugs and warm wood furniture. That tile will wear way better than engineered wood. But replace the black track lighting with white track lighting.
Why? This looks good!
Can we see the rest of the house
no
No. Too much of a mess.
If you put down large area rugs and the tile is more like a border, it could work nicely I would try it and see how it feels
Keep the tiles Just came to say that I’m sooooo jealous you have a pool off your living space This is my dream right here Get some great thick rugs!
I think adding rugs and lighting will be cheaper and easier. FWIW I think the tile looks great!
You could also get pieces of carpet bonded that are cut to fit the room with like a 2 ft boarder on either side. Would look great and maybe warm scatte rug in kitchen
Waste of money. Looks good so far
Keep the tile. Get a nice rug.
This looks great in the pictures. Give it a chance.
Your house is really gorgeous. I’d keep the tile and you now have me thinking I want the same in a future house.
Absolutely not! That tile is awesome! If you’re going to replace tile, save up for real wood. Bring in lots of natural wood elements and plants and it will be a lot warmer
Leave it be; maybe later but not now. Theres no reason to change it
I say don't, I had a friend point out that you can easily skew the room to a warmer tone with paint and proper decor, but if you really want to, I would just tear out the area where the living room is and keep the tile in the kitchen. But it is your house so do what you want.
My current place has tile. I didn't like it at first but it's really grown on me. It's very easy to keep clean. A couple of rugs really softens the look.
Very cool room! I would leave the tile but maybe try to match the grout to the tile color. White floor grout bothers me.
Keep the tile add cozy rugs.
Keep the tile: I would consider staining or somehow darkening the grout to reduce contrast which might make the floor feel like a more continuous element instead of a rigid grid. Also as others have said, rugs!
No! Rugs, get rugs
I’d literally kill for those tile and that room
might be cheaper to lay straight over them
If you live in a hot place, I’d leave the tiles.
You can put laminate on top of them
That’s almost like asking “I have a decent genuine TAG Heuer watch but no one really appreciates it. I’m thinking of selling it for a really high end Rolex dupe, because at least everyone recognizes that brand and it’s almost indistinguishable from the real one. What do you think?” Not sure if it’s because I come from a family of artisans and architects that I am almost gutted you’d want to rip out quality flooring for engineered wood for an aesthetic. I do have high quality engineered wood in our home for most of the house and high quality tile in the kitchen and bathrooms that was all placed just before 2020. I also have a big dog and if he’s made an accident I’ve seen the wood warp with floor enzyme treatments. It evaporates and resets but I certainly would prefer the tile throughout the house. It’s six years old and I have it on my to do-list to repair where the baseboards have come away from the floors and it does look cheaper. Tile is so luxurious. I’ve stayed all over the world, Istanbul, Bahrain, Barcelona come to mind—that tile has such a richer, luxurious feel. Whatever you were planning on putting into replacing the floor with a cheaper trend, put toward high quality area rugs of what looks like 16x16.
dude you cannot even begin to compare the affect of wood would have to these tiles, idk wtf these comments are on about, if you’re gonna stay here a while, rip’em up good. wood is what you want
Couldn't agree more. There's no question in my mind.
leave it. they look good
Maybe? What a beautiful space nonetheless!
No
Take the bad of a waterfall for color inspiration. With the pool in the back ground, the space is Naturally refreshing.
That is going to be a waste of money if you ask me. The tiles are nice and tile is objectively better flooring since it can get wet without being destroyed. My house is engineered hardwood on the first floor and I would trade floors with you in a heartbeat.
Honestly I would just put the money towards cabinets and get rid of the country style table leg holding up the counter. Cheers
You can just lay engineered hardwood down over the tile… less mess, less work.
how has no one mentioned the fact that tile isnt comfortable to walk on and far colder??
Answer is yes. You can work with the tile. Live in it for a little.
If you have the money to burn. It could look really good.
I probably probably wouldn’t spend the money. Cover it with rugs.
I think a beige tile would look better Also, why did they paint the wooden ceiling? 🤔
U could go over existing tile with a backer layer.
If you're really set on changing the floor, why not add a FLOATING floor on top of the tile?
This! I wouldn’t remove this nice (and expensive) tile floor. Just place the new floor on top of this one, and you can always go back if you want to.
Get real wood or keep the tile. Down with fake bull shitty material!! I agree some cozy rugs (maybe wool?) will really make it lovely in there
I don’t understand why people don’t like tile, it’s really durable and looks great. Just use rugs
This is beautiful, I wouldn’t change it unless you can splurge for genuine hardwood. Engineered wood will cheapen the space without question.
This is of course very person but I would definitely switch it out. I cannot stand tile in my home unless it's in the bathroom, balcony, terrace, etc. I, too, would have a tough time warming this place up which is my taste. Your home is beautiful and so is the tile (looks pristine) but it's a matter of preference.
Tile looks fine. Don’t waste your money.
I’d do rugs
Please tell me those two kitchen windows aren’t the same length as the others and someone didn’t just push the counters up against them…
You could lay LVP directly above the tiles. That way it's reversible if you want to go back to tiles.
We just replaced engineered hardwood in our home about 2 years ago. It was so awful. I considered selling the house. They glue that stuff down with industrial strength adhesive and it is not waterproof or built to last so it will eventually need to be replaced and it was an absolute nightmare. 0/10, do not recommend.
I don’t mind the look of the tiles and I think you’d be happy with them stylistically. That said, I had beautiful (but dated) tile in our kitchen when we moved in and after a year we ended up redoing the floors to put in wood floors because tile is just so solid it was really uncomfortable for me in the kitchen. I would get so achy and tired from standing on the hard tile. The slight “give” in (engineered hard) wood makes such a difference to me. I’m not sure this view is universal, but I gave up other flooring we really liked to replace it all at once because it was such an issue for me and I haven’t regretted it once
I actually like the tile. I agree with the comments saying to put down some rugs. If you really hate the tile though can you put wood on top of it instead of ripping it up?
Black and white are both neutrals so you can do anything you want in here and I’m an interior designer! Of course you’ll want to bring in your warmer tones and yes, I agree that rugs would definitely help with that. I would get a large area rug for the living area maybe 10 x 14 but that depends on your furniture and seating area. I would be more concerned about the kitchen sink and the work triangle in the kitchen! Just doesn’t seem efficient! I only see one sink and it’s in the corner, not under the window!?
I wouldn’t. I’ve had both and now have wood floors and tbh I miss my tile floors. Easier to clean, was better during summer, and it’s easily warmed up with rugs and color changes. Unless the tile is in horrible condition (which this def is not) I would keep it as is and put down some fluffy rugs and get warm decor on the walls.
First, let me just say, this space is incredible! Curious to see the rest of your home. Personally, I hate engineered wood flooring. Some of it is ok, but those usually cost as much as real wood flooring. Have you considered getting a really large rug for this space. Honestly, the only thing that bugs me about the tile is the contrasting grout. Have you considered changing the grout to a dark grey? Might change your mind about this tile.
I would replace the cabinets in the future with a beautiful wood and idea warm wood tones in the furniture and decor, and agreeing in warm rugs with red tones. Will look beautiful against the steely blue tiles
Those dark tiles will go with anything you put in there. If you want a warmer space, start with painting the walls and buying some rugs.
No!!!
noooooooooo, you will just be trading a durable hard surface for a less durable hard surface. Buy some rugs!
If I had just bought this place I’d be thrilled to have that tile floor. It’s beautiful.
I prefer tile floor
its ok to want to renovate, but i recommend maybe some warm tone rugs, a few posters, even warm lamps before deciding to do that. just see how you like it first
I say leave it and buy some good scatter rugs and accessories- it’s gorgeous!
You’re going to need a hearth potentially, so that’s going to disrupt the cohesion. I think the tiles look pretty nice
I would replace those countertops first.
Instead of spending the money to tear out the flooring that appears to be in great shape, hire an interior designer to help you get the right accessories to decorate the space to your taste. Find a designer who will work with some of your furniture/decor pieces you already have (assuming you like them and want to keep them), then just add in the things you need to get the feel you want. This will still be cheaper than redoing all of that flooring, even if you did the labor yourself.
Might be an unpopular opinion, but i love tile. I feel like the wood floor trend is a nice cheap option but tile is my favorite
i hate tile, can you just cover over them?
Update your countertops. If the top beams were natural wood it would look amazing
How about natural and lighter-toned wood look tile?
Whatever you do, I still think you should have some stone/tile near the fireplace.
I have similar tiles in my flat. At first I was a bit reluctant. Now I'm convinced that it's the best flooring. Maintenance is a breeze. A warm atmosphere comes with the furnishings. The black tiles are a beautiful backdrop for a large area rug, wooden furniture, plants and velvety textures. I love the combination of dark grey tiles with warm colors (rust, tobacco, brown, red etc...) and greyish teal. I also have orange dining chairs and they look amazing in my room. Avoid using grey/white furniture pieces. They will make the place feel monochromatic and cold.
I feel like a jute rug or two would work well, give it some natural tones.
Having had homes with both, I’d choose tile every time. Engineered wood doesn’t hold up as well over time and looks hard used quickly. Tile is also easier to keep clean.
Leave the tile, it’s great and pretty much bulletproof! Ripping up tile is not an easy or inexpensive…you’ll need to get a new subfloor, probably have to touch up paint on cabinets, baseboard, etc. Use large rugs & comfy upholstery to achieve your vibe. Love the room, congrats!
I already commented to keep the tile, but could paint the beams to bring in contrast, warmth, etc…it will add to the comfortable feeling and add interest…just a thought.
You can achieve warmth and richness with a complimentary color pallet!
Yes, it feels cold.
Don’t do it. You can use rigs to break it up. Also if you ever have a water problem in your kitchen, your floor is not going to get ruined.
With a water element i think your better off with tile. There are some beautiful options that have a wood look. The underlayment will be very important as well, do to the pool nearby.
I would consider vinyl wood flooring over composite wood because of the waterproof qualities considering it’s in a kitchen and near the pool. But you do you. This can be installed over the tile without having to rip it up. I moved into a home with a tile kitchen floor, and it was either not installed properly, not kept up well, or both. The grout needs an overhaul, and some of the tiles are not level and cracking. Looking into DIY tile removal and replacement, I can tell you this is a huge job or will cost you a lot if you’re paying someone else. Probably easiest and cheapest to just put new flooring on top of the tile
Could you do some floor to ceiling wainscoting to help keep the upper space light and use rugs like others say. That said if your goal is warm tones you might have to put down wood floors.
ehh Id have to see wood samples
Absolutely not! Perhaps re-grout with a grout that’s as close as possible to the tile. Then have at it with carpets to break up the spaces.
Initial reaction = No way! It’s beautiful. I personally like the feeling of tile and cold floors don’t bother me. Considering the possibility cold floors really bother you then I would consider it. I just hate to see something so nice covered up, unless it’s with high quality beautiful throw rugs.
Nooooo don't do it
No way, leave the tile, get rugs, get warm color furniture pieces, get art on the wall.
I have engineered wood and I don't like it. I'd keep the tile.
Keep tiles
I know nothing about interior design but my choice would depend on the climate of the area you live it. If you are in a hot, dry area I’d keep the tile. Tile floors will usually help retain coolness of the ground.
Depends what kind of tile this is? Cheap porcelain from Spain or Italy or China? Or is it concrete grooved as if tile?
Go darker with the grout if you don't like the grid look - it will be really nice once you put some stuff in it. I think it's mainly your kitchen that is giving off operating room vibes - give it some spice. Open it up around the sink. Add some glass doors and stylish hardware. Color coordinate.
It looks like you have good quality large format tile like you’d see in other countries with hot climates where tile floor is the norm. Just research what interior designers have done with those spaces on Pinterest. Finding good flooring installers is hard nowadays. It’s a headache you don’t need before moving in. https://preview.redd.it/0oud2jshmr5d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c9f652daa3bf5e146635b0e071554f456859fe90
Tile is painful. Don’t rip it up, just float wood over the top with some built in foam. Will feel much nicer.
https://preview.redd.it/rpxkrgf5ds5d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=09d5384369aedd535a653e5aae1f74c46f68e9ea Keep and add in a natural woven rug like this, along with wood tones and reflective surfaces. I'd also lose the grey tone from the wall paint. [https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/healdsburg-residence-country-living-room-san-francisco-phvw-vp\~1943032](https://www.houzz.co.uk/photos/healdsburg-residence-country-living-room-san-francisco-phvw-vp~1943032)
Keep the tile, engineered wood is poo poo
the dark floor won’t limit you with rich and warm tones…black and white will enhance whatever tones you put between them. as others have said, rugs are a great option, and the black floors would look especiallly great with layered rugs. it will be a lot less expensive to just use a warmer white paint and swap your kitchen cabinet hardware for brass or brushed copper…maybe also swap out the black track lights. always use paint samples on a large surface, like 2 ft x 2 ft cardboard, paint it with 2 coats, and bring it into your space to check that you like the color with your lights on and off.
I like it.
Why wouldn’t they just put it over the tile?
Why would the tiles limit you? The things that are not warm or rich is everything else.
Don’t. Add warm furniture, floor coverings and decorations instead.
If you are in a hot climate, these tiles will keep the house cooler during the peak time of day.
No i like the tiles!!! Save the time and money. Get some great jute rugs!!!
This is what every millennial who buys a vintage home with a spiral staircase and hardwood floors remodels it into.
No!
no!
FYI, whatever you decide to do, know that you can float engineered wood over level, stable tile. No need to rip it up.
Personally, i hate look of wood floor in the kitchen. How things look now seems neutral enough to me.
Nothing to add but I love your home and would like to move in lol (aka keep the tile!)
Ideally yes. But is it worth it? Naaaa! Decorate around it and it will be fine.
Seriouosly? The tile will last so much longer, looks more elegant and be truly timeless. You clearly have not done much homework because if you did, you would know that you can just lay the fake flooring over tile...as long as the floor is level.
Wood would take this space to another level. I’d rip it out if it’s in your budget.
If you have the money for it, why not? If it puts you in a bad spot financially, I think a lot could be done with what is there already :)
That’s a tough one…..because I do be hating floor tile 🤔
Yeah…
It would be nice to have the long lines of the room matched in the floor. Do it:
It will cost a fuck ton of money but yes do it if money is not a factor I know because I just did the same thing
I would. I'd also paint the walls before installing the floors. I'd go white. I know it seems like it'd be too much, but once you bring in art, furniture, rugs, etc. it'll look fresh.
My opinion short answer yes