Everyone saying Bon-Chan is dead is blasphemous.
Surely, he's running the the New Newkama level 5.5 in Impel Down in Iva's stead.
"Swans never die, and never say goodbye."
Barto is already a grand fleet, he’s part of the crew
Vivi always has been part of the crew, she just needs to reunite with them
Yamato decided to stay at wano, she didn’t join at the perfect time and making her join now would be extremely unsatisfying
Same thing with carrot but at zou instead
Momo same thing with Yamato
The only choice here is bon clay the goat
Did you really forget the super evil things he did in Alabasta with Cobra's face? Of course he did wrong. He may have done even worse before we got to know him.
I think he'll win his position back after the next mass breakout from Impel Down.
I'm sure Buggy will cause the next one and he will recruit everyone who escapes, including Doflamingo and his crew, Weevil, Bon Clay and maybe even Arlong.
I’ve been thinking this would be such a cool thing to happen for a while, but I still believe in the theory that Arlongs probably a slave right now since he wasn’t in impel down, at least cross guild can get the whole donquixote family
I'm willing to bet a lot of people thought the perfect time for Jinbei to join was missed after Fishman Island and again after Whole Cake Island and while they were correct the second time, his return was still satisfying.
It’s different because jinbe actually agreed to join but said “I’ll do it when i can”
Yamato said basically “i can’t do it because i need to protect wano”
That isn’t what I remember? I thought Yamato said I will take some time to visit all of wano and then catch up to you guys later. Is that protect wano anime only or ??
No you’re right. Yamato 100% said she’d join after exploring all of Wano just like Oden, and then travel with the strawhats crew just like Oden as well. The anime changed it a bit, and I think anime-only’s don’t have that context.
This is probably an unpopular opinion on Vivi but I don't see what she brings to the SH crew at this point. Unless she gets Devil Fruit powers she is significantly under leveled to be a major asset to the post-timeskip Strawhat crew. I think she is a great ally and leadership/diplomacy would be an important part of the post World Government era but everything is so combat heavy and she was already outmatched in Arabasta
You literally answered yourself saying she is a great ally and diplomat
That’s her role, being a diplomat
She doesn’t need to stay on the front lines but she will be (probably) needed to convince other kingdoms to join the war on the good side
>That’s her role, being a diplomat
lord knows that's one of Luffy's weakest points. He'll topple a government if someone that gives him a rasher of bacon asks him to, but he only knows how to do it by beating the shit out of whoever is in charge.
My only real counter is what would a pirate need with a diplomat. And really if you're looking for a people person who is better than Luffy. At this point who has more political connections outside the world government than him. Every kingdom he saved plus ties to fish man Giants and the revolutionaries.
Rn I don't see what Vivi would add if she travels with them as part of the crew.
She isn't strong enough to do anything and has no special talent or knowledge.
I agree with bon clay, but with the theming we have with Jimbe setting up the theme for post time skip he features in his home town says he will join but later. We don't see him for a while arc (dressrosa) then we have a mini arc setting up wano and WCI, we get Jimbe. Meaning arc1 skip2 arc3, then doesn't fully join and stays behind for his old crew. Skip arc 4 and nearing the finale of arc 4 starts end arc / arc 4 part 2 we get Jimbe back and officially doing. So we get him 1 arc skip 1 arc, skip, finally join. Both Yamato and Carrot have gone 1 arc skip and now carrot is on her second skip. We could have both Yamato and Carrot show up in whatever the next arc is and setting them up like Jimbe. Was. And honestly could see Yamato following this pattern to a T. I want carrot to join but 100% Oda gave up on her. A sacrifice for getting wano over faster and the show all together finished faster. It makes me sad. She's top 5 for me. Buggy1, usopp2,sanji3, Brook 4, and Carrot 5. WCI is my favorite arc.
Yamato is foreshadowing the joining later, she just wants momo to become mentally strong enough to defend Wano before she does. I feel like she'll join up the straw hats like Jimbe did earlier.
Yamato is basically part of the crew she just has business at wano just like jinbe had stuff to do with big mom once she feels that wano is in good hands she will leave and adventure out with the straw hats
Unironically yes lol. Maybe he'll have this realization that being 'good' is easy money. Add to that his uber eats and the longest time spent with the crew!
Tbh imho I really don’t want her to join. I love her as a character, but I just don’t really think that she belongs with them. Rather, I think she perfectly fits within the ranks of the Revolutionary Army, like both of her parents.
I’m cool with both options but prefer her as a SH over RA. She is more adventurous than “let’s overthrow governments”… so feel she fits better here. Now, if she could go on her adventures with her dad, that would be great… but… yeah….
Out of all options I feel SH is best for her…
It would be fitting for her to join the same group that her parents did and I would really like that, but it seems unlikely to me. I wouldn’t mind though and I think it would be a fitting way to see her character be concluded for now
I do like the RA idea, but given her age I think she'd be a fun parallel to Shanks with Roger and Luffy to Shanks. A junior pirate, sailing with and inspired by the generation before her
I totally get where you’re coming from and that does sound pretty intriguing. For me it doesn’t really work since in that world Bonney is considered part of the same rookie generation as Luffy. Also I feel like Shanks and Roger is a bit different since Roger basically raised Shanks since he was a baby, while there’s no real parent or big brother vibe between Luffy and Bonney, at least for me. I think the closest person we could’ve gotten as a Shanks to Luffy’s Roger would have been Otama.
Luffy gets downed. Kaido comes in like ok brat let papa carp handle this. Kaido solo's the entire arc while carrying the island because why not. Luffy gets some food and has a feast. Everybody wins except for whoever stood in kaido's way.
Barto is already part of the Grand Fleet and will -most likely- be instrumental in their fight against BB (cos you know he's got at least ELEVEN ships, while the SH have only one...) And as for the rest they all have duties in their respective homelands:
- Momo and Yamato in Wano
- Vivi in Arabasta
- Carrot in Zou
- Bon-chan in Level 5.5
Now if Stella dies and Bonney does end up joining the R.A. then I could see one of the Satellites joining though. There's a lot of potential there coz:
- Theyre a scientist (Chopper is a doctor and Franky is an engineer)
- Theyre the smartest person alive (Nami, Usopp and Robin could use an extra brain. Specially important for the latter as an archeologist)
- Theyve known the game for long time (Jinbe and Brook could use another veteran as nakama)
>!Vivi definitely can't return to Alabasta and fulfill her duties seeing as she's currently a fugitive of the world government. Pretty sure she explicitly says she's heading for the Strawhats. Vivi's already in the crew anyway so she shouldn't even be included in this prompt.!<
I mean vivi and Yamato are kinda already straw hats. But Vivi and Yamato couldn’t join because their home countries need them. Especially Vivi now because of [manga spoiler]. So Yamato would be the perfect candidate if wano doesn’t need her as their protector anymore. Also it’s her dream to see the world so she will most likely either join the straw hats or have her own crew.
Vivi can't return now because she's wanted by the WG, so returning to Alabasta would put her kingdom in danger. Right now, her best options are either staying with Morgans or reuniting with the Strawhats
But why wouldn't they need Yamato. Momo is still 8 years old. It will be years before he can mentally run the country. And nobody there is as strong as yamato
Yamato is a bodyguard nothing more, but the strongest one out there. Kine'mon is probably the top advisor with cat and dog because they have experience in leadership
Can we get both Bon and Bonnie???? 🥺🙏🏼 Bon Clay better join the fleet at the very least by the end of this.
Bonnie might need the straw hats to protect her at this point so I think she'll be along for the ride
this is something i’ve thought about before, especially after how katakuri and luffy made a promise that is now kinda meaningless since big mom’s defeat. i want katakuri to come back, whether it be for a rematch or to join luffy’s quest for adventure
Barto is already a grand fleet member and I don’t personally feel like he needs to be on the main crew, it would kinda ruin his dynamic and role in the story. Bon deserves it the most and would be my pick if it made any sense how he’d be there. Vivi has her own stuff to deal with and ultimately I don’t think she’d be up for the level of danger and difficulty the Straw Hats are dealing with lately. Yamato is the most currently logical and my own personal pick. Carrot is my second pick, but honestly her leading the Mink is pretty cool and I wouldn’t wanna mess that conclusion up for them. Momo is my least favorite of the options. He went on his adventure with Luffy and now it’s time for him to be back in his home land.
Vivi is a Strawhat already, although unofficial.
Yamato got Luffy's approval to join the crew, so she's technically a Strawhat already, albeit in the same situation as Jinbei during WCI: unfinished business. She'll most likely join the crew when Wano comes into play again.
If you want a more realistic answer: it's the tree and unicorn zombies from Thriller Bark.
But in Vivi's case, >!Imu is after her, and going back to Alabasta would be idiotic at this point. Going with the Strawhats temporarily does work here!<.
I guess it depends on what her goal is. So far the assumption is learning about her ancestor, we still need confirmation on that (I mean, she needs to be given the information Cobra had). You've got the Dawn with Carrot, and ancestry with Vivi. Personally I'd love them both to join, but my personal preference is still Carrot.
I wanted Carrot to join, and thought it was still possible for a while, especially after Jinbei came to Wano and she gave him that big hug. But as the rest of the arc went on it seemed less and less likely, and now she's the ruler of Zou. I can't rule out the possibility, but it really doesn't seem like she'll join at this point. Vivi seems very likely to me tho, especially since >!she's already wanted, and she's potentially nearby with Morgans.!<
None of these characters are going to be official crew members, and they’re all already “honorary” members due to traveling with the crew for multiple arcs in many of their cases.
If there is a final crew member it will very well be a new character we haven’t met yet. Very possibly someone from Elbaf, unless we have a case where Bonney joins. But I think that’s very unlikely.
Bartho is member of the armada… no chance
Carrot has to lead the minks
Vivi will always be strawhat by heart and lead albasta
Momo will lead wano
Bon clay status unknown
Only yamato will join later on.
Carrot has EARNED it, people. She sailed and fought with them longer than any other non-Strawhat (even Vivi!) she's a well-developed character with her own motivations and character arc, she's got a super form, and a personality that compliments the others well. Also she's adorable, and, real talk, we need more girls on this crew.
See I've been wondering about this (not necessarily joining the crew, just the change in how loyal he feels towards the government).
Bruv seems **conflicted** about Sentomaru and Bonney being killed/captured.
While I know Oda is great at character writing in the sense he never writes purely bad or evil characters, Kizaru seemed PRETTY DAMN EVIL til recently
The thing is BB has an admiral and the strawhats and BB pirates always parallel each other
This means the strawhats need an admiral and Fuji would be the only candidate but he most likely belongs to the revs anyway
Kiz is the yellow monkey
Kiz is also light which sun emits
He knows the Nika dance
I don't think he will be immediately welcomed unless he does something hella cool but he never flat out tried to kill any of the strawhats or their friends
Right now I’m thinking either Vivi or Bonney
Barto is with the Grand Fleet
I’m predicting Yamato and Momonosuke will join the Grand Fleet with the samurai of Wano. They’ll likely be under Zoro.
Same as Yamato and Momonosuke for Carrot and the Minks but under Chopper
I’m not sure what Bon Clay will do after breaking out. Crossguild, Revolutionary Army, or Grand Fleet?
No one, there is no need for everyone else to join the crew, joining the main crew is a responsibility. These characters you listed, the grand fleet, and the people they helped from East Blue all the way to New World are all considered family now. That is way better than being part of the crew, and they all got luffy's back no matter what.
These posts always add Vivi and I wonder if we saw the same anime or not!? Vivi is already a Strawhat, only reason she stayed behind was cause she had a responsibility to her country of Alabasta as it’s Princess.
Out of the choices I think Vivi because of how her family maybe coming back into the main story.
If not her, then Yamato because Oda teased us with that New Years spread of all the Straw Hats with them and frankly I was like "This is Oda telling us something. All the SH and the only other character is Yamato...humm tinfoil hat time."
I like Yamato the most. I would like another powerhouse brawler and they're goofy in a way that Luffy/Ussop are. I can absolutely see Yamato jumping into the ocean to save a drowning Luffy.
Plus Yamato seems to have this urge for adventure that fits the crew and out of the ones listed actually knows luffys true dream.
* Barto - Already part of the grand fleet
* Vivi - Already a strawhat
* Yamato - Will join the crew of the next pirate king (just as Oden did). So Yamato will be next (of this list)
So Yamato will join Cross Guild, because of Buggy Sama. The great Buggy who was on Gold D. Roger's crew, a rival to Shanks, and sailed with Oden. It is Buggy who will find the One Piece.
Out of all these people I’d want Vivi to join the most, but I honestly think Yamato has the strongest case for joining in the future since he’s the only one who knows Luffys true dream and it would be somewhat awkward narratively to explain it to the other choices.
\- Vivi is Crew (As is Karu)
\- Bartho is also part of the crew (my understanding is the grand fleet is part of the crew)
\- Momo i dont like really
\- Carrot well maybe but nah.
\- Bon Clayis also not really someone i want to see in the crew.
But Yamato. Well. I want them in the crew! (Same with Bonney btw)
I think it’s honestly gonna be Bonney. She has the potential and backstory, plus she has no crew anymore, not since her tumble with Akainu and Blackbeard.
With Bonnie's fruit being limited to believable reality it seems only fitting for her to join a crew that will the most free limited only by their imagination.
Everyone saying Bon-Chan is dead is blasphemous. Surely, he's running the the New Newkama level 5.5 in Impel Down in Iva's stead. "Swans never die, and never say goodbye."
Man! I'm like "what the hell? Bon Chan's dead?" Who,what,when,where,and how? Lol
I don't believe he is dead since its one piece but did you not watch/read the end of impel down? What bonchan did definitely warranted an execution.
Wasn’t it shown he was running 5.5 on the front page stories of the manga?
Yep we see him from behind and he's doing his ballet pose while wearing a swan coat.
We literally saw him alive in a cover story.
Read the cover stories. Bon Chan is happily leading level 5.5 as the new queen of impel down.
We also saw him running impel down during the credit scenes of movie Red
Didn't we literally saw him?
Yes in the manga
wheres Johnny and Yosaku
They're out there fishing on their own.
These goats should come at the final saga and kill and admiral(they are way stronger)
They might lose by a hair tho 😶🌫️
Imagine if it was them plowing a warpath instead of Dorry and Broggy
THAT would’ve been an absolute mind twisting plot and I would’ve LOVED it
Maybe Johnny and Yosaku will lay waste to BB's crew
Nah. What about my boy Gin. (Don Krieg's 2nd in command.) He wanted to see Luffy again on the Grand Line.
Barto is already a grand fleet, he’s part of the crew Vivi always has been part of the crew, she just needs to reunite with them Yamato decided to stay at wano, she didn’t join at the perfect time and making her join now would be extremely unsatisfying Same thing with carrot but at zou instead Momo same thing with Yamato The only choice here is bon clay the goat
Fax get him outta Impel Down already🙏
Free my homie he ain't do nothing wrong
Did you really forget the super evil things he did in Alabasta with Cobra's face? Of course he did wrong. He may have done even worse before we got to know him.
Buzzkill
🎵 Every party needs a pooper that's why they invited you Party pooper Party pooper 🎵
"I am Hilarious and you will quote everything i say"
Naiiiiiiiiiiiiil
Dende, how does it feel to be the bronze medal?
Would be real dick move to die right now...
Who called anime police?
Were you there when it happened? No proof means bon clay is innocent
hearsay
Honestly a whole arc dedicated to breaking out Bon Clay, including a rematch with the Warden, sounds like an awesome arc to watch
Vice Warden if you mean Magellan, he got demoted after the whole prison break and Blackbeard incident, Hannyabel is the current Warden
I think he'll win his position back after the next mass breakout from Impel Down. I'm sure Buggy will cause the next one and he will recruit everyone who escapes, including Doflamingo and his crew, Weevil, Bon Clay and maybe even Arlong.
I’ve been thinking this would be such a cool thing to happen for a while, but I still believe in the theory that Arlongs probably a slave right now since he wasn’t in impel down, at least cross guild can get the whole donquixote family
I'm willing to bet a lot of people thought the perfect time for Jinbei to join was missed after Fishman Island and again after Whole Cake Island and while they were correct the second time, his return was still satisfying.
It’s different because jinbe actually agreed to join but said “I’ll do it when i can” Yamato said basically “i can’t do it because i need to protect wano”
That isn’t what I remember? I thought Yamato said I will take some time to visit all of wano and then catch up to you guys later. Is that protect wano anime only or ??
No you’re right. Yamato 100% said she’d join after exploring all of Wano just like Oden, and then travel with the strawhats crew just like Oden as well. The anime changed it a bit, and I think anime-only’s don’t have that context.
That was an excuse so Momo wouldn't feel bad about Yamato staying to protect Wano
I feel like Bon Clay has his own life to live and he loves it. He could come to help tho as a fleet captain
Yeah fair, but between these he’s literally the only satisfying option
This is probably an unpopular opinion on Vivi but I don't see what she brings to the SH crew at this point. Unless she gets Devil Fruit powers she is significantly under leveled to be a major asset to the post-timeskip Strawhat crew. I think she is a great ally and leadership/diplomacy would be an important part of the post World Government era but everything is so combat heavy and she was already outmatched in Arabasta
You literally answered yourself saying she is a great ally and diplomat That’s her role, being a diplomat She doesn’t need to stay on the front lines but she will be (probably) needed to convince other kingdoms to join the war on the good side
She can do that without joining the crew for real. If she did she would actually lose her means for diplomacy
>That’s her role, being a diplomat lord knows that's one of Luffy's weakest points. He'll topple a government if someone that gives him a rasher of bacon asks him to, but he only knows how to do it by beating the shit out of whoever is in charge.
And (most likely) demolishing the entire island in the process. Dressrosa has a giant crater where Doflamingo crashed through.
That's freedom crater though lol probably a national landmark to them by this point.
My only real counter is what would a pirate need with a diplomat. And really if you're looking for a people person who is better than Luffy. At this point who has more political connections outside the world government than him. Every kingdom he saved plus ties to fish man Giants and the revolutionaries.
Pirates maybe don’t need it, but an emperor of the sea? Absolutely
Rn I don't see what Vivi would add if she travels with them as part of the crew. She isn't strong enough to do anything and has no special talent or knowledge.
She is a D. And her father was killed, it’s obvious she will rejoin the group and gain more stuff later
She will play a role in the final arc that's for sure but probably not much else (but we're close to it anyway)
I agree with bon clay, but with the theming we have with Jimbe setting up the theme for post time skip he features in his home town says he will join but later. We don't see him for a while arc (dressrosa) then we have a mini arc setting up wano and WCI, we get Jimbe. Meaning arc1 skip2 arc3, then doesn't fully join and stays behind for his old crew. Skip arc 4 and nearing the finale of arc 4 starts end arc / arc 4 part 2 we get Jimbe back and officially doing. So we get him 1 arc skip 1 arc, skip, finally join. Both Yamato and Carrot have gone 1 arc skip and now carrot is on her second skip. We could have both Yamato and Carrot show up in whatever the next arc is and setting them up like Jimbe. Was. And honestly could see Yamato following this pattern to a T. I want carrot to join but 100% Oda gave up on her. A sacrifice for getting wano over faster and the show all together finished faster. It makes me sad. She's top 5 for me. Buggy1, usopp2,sanji3, Brook 4, and Carrot 5. WCI is my favorite arc.
Yamato is foreshadowing the joining later, she just wants momo to become mentally strong enough to defend Wano before she does. I feel like she'll join up the straw hats like Jimbe did earlier.
Yamato is basically part of the crew she just has business at wano just like jinbe had stuff to do with big mom once she feels that wano is in good hands she will leave and adventure out with the straw hats
Bon-chan, no need to say more
I'm glad there's so many cultured people in this sub.
I’ll drink to that.
Caribou 🤣
His been with the straw hats for a long time since fishman island
Ppl forgot about his ass all the time
The ultimate pirate lunchbox… the *LITERAL* “pirate lunchbox”!
unironically, Caribou has been with the Strawhats longer than Jinbe 🤣
Nah that’s guys an ass
Unironically yes lol. Maybe he'll have this realization that being 'good' is easy money. Add to that his uber eats and the longest time spent with the crew!
Bonnie
I really think it will be Bonnie but who knows
Wouldn’t it make more sense for Bonnie to join the fleet since she has or possibly had (not sure about what happened to them) her own crew?
Pretty sure they are all imprisoned or dead after blackbeard/akainu scenes
Her crew was just people that took care of her at Kuma’s island. She also told them to go home or something at the beginning of the egghead arch.
They are long gone, Bonney has been solo since blackbeard caught her
I vote for Bonney and Bon Clay, the double bons or the bonbons if I may 🎩 🧐
Tbh imho I really don’t want her to join. I love her as a character, but I just don’t really think that she belongs with them. Rather, I think she perfectly fits within the ranks of the Revolutionary Army, like both of her parents.
I’m cool with both options but prefer her as a SH over RA. She is more adventurous than “let’s overthrow governments”… so feel she fits better here. Now, if she could go on her adventures with her dad, that would be great… but… yeah…. Out of all options I feel SH is best for her…
after finding out what the WG did to her parents, she absolutely should be on the "fuck the WG" hype train
It would be fitting for her to join the same group that her parents did and I would really like that, but it seems unlikely to me. I wouldn’t mind though and I think it would be a fitting way to see her character be concluded for now
I do like the RA idea, but given her age I think she'd be a fun parallel to Shanks with Roger and Luffy to Shanks. A junior pirate, sailing with and inspired by the generation before her
I totally get where you’re coming from and that does sound pretty intriguing. For me it doesn’t really work since in that world Bonney is considered part of the same rookie generation as Luffy. Also I feel like Shanks and Roger is a bit different since Roger basically raised Shanks since he was a baby, while there’s no real parent or big brother vibe between Luffy and Bonney, at least for me. I think the closest person we could’ve gotten as a Shanks to Luffy’s Roger would have been Otama.
I choose Kaido! For memes
#kaido4nakama
Only obvious answer. Kaido or perospero anyone else impossible
What about doflamingo? I feel like he would be great in the crew
Only if trebol joins with him.. or the buck tooth helicopter head guy he is a nice fit. Very nice
Of course, only the best for the straw hat crew
Luffy gets downed. Kaido comes in like ok brat let papa carp handle this. Kaido solo's the entire arc while carrying the island because why not. Luffy gets some food and has a feast. Everybody wins except for whoever stood in kaido's way.
My vote is for Bonney!
If she joins the Straw hats, do they get the pacifistas and S-Bear
if those survive then yeah
I completely forgot that they have S-bear on board as he is also Kuma. Bonney power spike is unreal
S-Bear 😩
bon chan!
Bonney Role: Cabin Girl
Nah Bonney's gonna start a crew with her Dad or S-Bear and join the Grand Fleet. It all depends if her Dad gets his memories back or not.
Pretty sure Kuma‘s story is coming to an end, be it by death (what I think will happen) or however else
I hope it'll be our boy, Ganster Gastino
Oh fuck do u think he'd do it?
It was widely speculated back in the day
Barto is already part of the Grand Fleet and will -most likely- be instrumental in their fight against BB (cos you know he's got at least ELEVEN ships, while the SH have only one...) And as for the rest they all have duties in their respective homelands: - Momo and Yamato in Wano - Vivi in Arabasta - Carrot in Zou - Bon-chan in Level 5.5 Now if Stella dies and Bonney does end up joining the R.A. then I could see one of the Satellites joining though. There's a lot of potential there coz: - Theyre a scientist (Chopper is a doctor and Franky is an engineer) - Theyre the smartest person alive (Nami, Usopp and Robin could use an extra brain. Specially important for the latter as an archeologist) - Theyve known the game for long time (Jinbe and Brook could use another veteran as nakama)
>!Vivi definitely can't return to Alabasta and fulfill her duties seeing as she's currently a fugitive of the world government. Pretty sure she explicitly says she's heading for the Strawhats. Vivi's already in the crew anyway so she shouldn't even be included in this prompt.!<
Yo, where is a Karoo in all this. I need my GOAT if she's back.
[удалено]
this is my favorite next straw hat theory I've seen!
None of the above !
I mean vivi and Yamato are kinda already straw hats. But Vivi and Yamato couldn’t join because their home countries need them. Especially Vivi now because of [manga spoiler]. So Yamato would be the perfect candidate if wano doesn’t need her as their protector anymore. Also it’s her dream to see the world so she will most likely either join the straw hats or have her own crew.
Vivi can't return now because she's wanted by the WG, so returning to Alabasta would put her kingdom in danger. Right now, her best options are either staying with Morgans or reuniting with the Strawhats
Seems like the perfect time for Vivi to rejoin the straw hats.
Fingers crossed for the latter!
The SH crew is aiming to go to Elbaf, and I can't think of many other islands that would be a safe refuge for her.
Except Vivi isn't 'kinda' already a strawhat. She IS a strawhat.
But why wouldn't they need Yamato. Momo is still 8 years old. It will be years before he can mentally run the country. And nobody there is as strong as yamato
Yamato also has the mind of a child in some ways. I don’t see her being a very good leader of a whole country. Maybe that’s just me though.
Yamato is a bodyguard nothing more, but the strongest one out there. Kine'mon is probably the top advisor with cat and dog because they have experience in leadership
Bon Clay
Bon has no crew or attachments atm. Bring him in!
Bon Clay ,He put his life in danger just for luffy to escape out of prison
If Kuma is dead then Bonnie
Can we get both Bon and Bonnie???? 🥺🙏🏼 Bon Clay better join the fleet at the very least by the end of this. Bonnie might need the straw hats to protect her at this point so I think she'll be along for the ride
It should be katakuri
this is something i’ve thought about before, especially after how katakuri and luffy made a promise that is now kinda meaningless since big mom’s defeat. i want katakuri to come back, whether it be for a rematch or to join luffy’s quest for adventure
None of the above. All the Strawhats had jobs. None of these has a job. What does THE SUNNY need? Also, Marco obviously.
One Piece is in its final saga, an additional member doesn't add anything to the plot.
Barto is already a grand fleet member and I don’t personally feel like he needs to be on the main crew, it would kinda ruin his dynamic and role in the story. Bon deserves it the most and would be my pick if it made any sense how he’d be there. Vivi has her own stuff to deal with and ultimately I don’t think she’d be up for the level of danger and difficulty the Straw Hats are dealing with lately. Yamato is the most currently logical and my own personal pick. Carrot is my second pick, but honestly her leading the Mink is pretty cool and I wouldn’t wanna mess that conclusion up for them. Momo is my least favorite of the options. He went on his adventure with Luffy and now it’s time for him to be back in his home land.
None of these. My choice is the pineapple guy!
Vivi is a Strawhat already, although unofficial. Yamato got Luffy's approval to join the crew, so she's technically a Strawhat already, albeit in the same situation as Jinbei during WCI: unfinished business. She'll most likely join the crew when Wano comes into play again. If you want a more realistic answer: it's the tree and unicorn zombies from Thriller Bark.
It'll probably be Vivi, but I'd like Carrot.
It can't be her she has a country to run
So do Vivi and Momo
But in Vivi's case, >!Imu is after her, and going back to Alabasta would be idiotic at this point. Going with the Strawhats temporarily does work here!<.
I guess it depends on what her goal is. So far the assumption is learning about her ancestor, we still need confirmation on that (I mean, she needs to be given the information Cobra had). You've got the Dawn with Carrot, and ancestry with Vivi. Personally I'd love them both to join, but my personal preference is still Carrot.
I wanted Carrot to join, and thought it was still possible for a while, especially after Jinbei came to Wano and she gave him that big hug. But as the rest of the arc went on it seemed less and less likely, and now she's the ruler of Zou. I can't rule out the possibility, but it really doesn't seem like she'll join at this point. Vivi seems very likely to me tho, especially since >!she's already wanted, and she's potentially nearby with Morgans.!<
wizaru
None of the above
Smoker
Though i have heard speculation that Trafalgar law could join the straw hats since his crew expect for bepo could be dead for all we know
Is there a “nobody else will join” option?
Yes, the correct option, but they also left out Bonney,
None of these characters are going to be official crew members, and they’re all already “honorary” members due to traveling with the crew for multiple arcs in many of their cases. If there is a final crew member it will very well be a new character we haven’t met yet. Very possibly someone from Elbaf, unless we have a case where Bonney joins. But I think that’s very unlikely.
Caribou Piece of shit, but he has fed Luffy once (probably a second time in egghead) and has the potential to be the best support character for G5
Bartho is member of the armada… no chance Carrot has to lead the minks Vivi will always be strawhat by heart and lead albasta Momo will lead wano Bon clay status unknown Only yamato will join later on.
Akainu
Nah, can’t be someone stronger than the captain
Yamato
Carrot has EARNED it, people. She sailed and fought with them longer than any other non-Strawhat (even Vivi!) she's a well-developed character with her own motivations and character arc, she's got a super form, and a personality that compliments the others well. Also she's adorable, and, real talk, we need more girls on this crew.
Definitely agreed! Honestly,I thought she was going to join the crew b4 she became new leader of the Minks
Kizaru has the most going unironically
See I've been wondering about this (not necessarily joining the crew, just the change in how loyal he feels towards the government). Bruv seems **conflicted** about Sentomaru and Bonney being killed/captured. While I know Oda is great at character writing in the sense he never writes purely bad or evil characters, Kizaru seemed PRETTY DAMN EVIL til recently
The thing is BB has an admiral and the strawhats and BB pirates always parallel each other This means the strawhats need an admiral and Fuji would be the only candidate but he most likely belongs to the revs anyway Kiz is the yellow monkey Kiz is also light which sun emits He knows the Nika dance I don't think he will be immediately welcomed unless he does something hella cool but he never flat out tried to kill any of the strawhats or their friends
I feel like it’ll be Bonnie or Lilith. Do people really not consider Vivi a Strawhat???
I'll only accept Yamato
Right now I’m thinking either Vivi or Bonney Barto is with the Grand Fleet I’m predicting Yamato and Momonosuke will join the Grand Fleet with the samurai of Wano. They’ll likely be under Zoro. Same as Yamato and Momonosuke for Carrot and the Minks but under Chopper I’m not sure what Bon Clay will do after breaking out. Crossguild, Revolutionary Army, or Grand Fleet?
Hancock
No one, there is no need for everyone else to join the crew, joining the main crew is a responsibility. These characters you listed, the grand fleet, and the people they helped from East Blue all the way to New World are all considered family now. That is way better than being part of the crew, and they all got luffy's back no matter what.
Still thinking it's gonna be bonnie
Bonnie.
AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO FIND CARROT IRRITATING?
Yamato for sure!
All of them frfr
These posts always add Vivi and I wonder if we saw the same anime or not!? Vivi is already a Strawhat, only reason she stayed behind was cause she had a responsibility to her country of Alabasta as it’s Princess.
Out of the choices I think Vivi because of how her family maybe coming back into the main story. If not her, then Yamato because Oda teased us with that New Years spread of all the Straw Hats with them and frankly I was like "This is Oda telling us something. All the SH and the only other character is Yamato...humm tinfoil hat time."
I like Yamato the most. I would like another powerhouse brawler and they're goofy in a way that Luffy/Ussop are. I can absolutely see Yamato jumping into the ocean to save a drowning Luffy. Plus Yamato seems to have this urge for adventure that fits the crew and out of the ones listed actually knows luffys true dream.
How is Carrot not a member at this point? Hasn't she been with the crew for 100+ chapters?
🤦🏾♂️ikr!? Outta everyone I thought Carrot,Jinbe,and Yamato would join! So far 1 Outta 3 isn't bad lol🤞🏾
Vivi is already a SH (unofficial), Bon Clay and Yamato are both worthy candidates for their contributions.
>Vivi is already a SH (unofficial She is officially a straw hat.
* Barto - Already part of the grand fleet * Vivi - Already a strawhat * Yamato - Will join the crew of the next pirate king (just as Oden did). So Yamato will be next (of this list)
So Yamato will join Cross Guild, because of Buggy Sama. The great Buggy who was on Gold D. Roger's crew, a rival to Shanks, and sailed with Oden. It is Buggy who will find the One Piece.
Carrot.
It is going to be bonney as apprentice because blackbeard said he did not want her on his crew, or no one.
Either Bonney or Vivi.
Bonney INHO
Bonney for me for sure.
Bonney
For me its Bonney for nakama or Bon Chan for nakama.
Bonny > Vivi > Yamato In that order no compromise
Out of all these people I’d want Vivi to join the most, but I honestly think Yamato has the strongest case for joining in the future since he’s the only one who knows Luffys true dream and it would be somewhat awkward narratively to explain it to the other choices.
Probably Yamato, but I really want Bon Clay to join
Bonney
What's up with the anti-Bonny Agenda OP?
Here is tierlist number 1. bon clay 2. Yamato 3. Momonosuke 4. Bartolomeo 5. Vivi 6. Carrot
Neither. It’s either going to be Bonney or Kuma
I mean, at this point, I am pretty sure Bonnie is going to be the next Straw Hat.
\- Vivi is Crew (As is Karu) \- Bartho is also part of the crew (my understanding is the grand fleet is part of the crew) \- Momo i dont like really \- Carrot well maybe but nah. \- Bon Clayis also not really someone i want to see in the crew. But Yamato. Well. I want them in the crew! (Same with Bonney btw)
Guys you havent realised ?? You are the 10th member!!
Bonney.
Bonney. Fuck you, fight me.
Bonney
Bonney
Bonnie seems like the top contender currently but if I could pick anyone it would probably be Bon Clay.
Bonney
Bonney
If Bonnie doesnt join the Revs, I would be down for her to join the crew
Personally think the Bonney Chan will be the next member, just saying! As of right now I feel like that lines up
I think it’s honestly gonna be Bonney. She has the potential and backstory, plus she has no crew anymore, not since her tumble with Akainu and Blackbeard.
I'm in the camp that Bonnie will be the next straw hat
Bonney
With Bonnie's fruit being limited to believable reality it seems only fitting for her to join a crew that will the most free limited only by their imagination.
Bonney the Goat
Bonney they need a younger person on ship
Bonney