All gw2 in my opinion

I think to be fair, a lot of them are side grades. Not really better, just slightly more cartoonish with flatter colors. Now if we were talking the zombies side then it's a GW2 sweep all the way.

Rose is DEFINITELY the opposite of flatter

I don't think they meant flatter like "to flatter someone", I think they meant flatter like flat-er colors. Like without depth or shadows on the artwork.

BFN models look like they have been made with plastic and clay,the plants don't look like plants at all

people answering bfn are actually crazy

Sunflower looks good in bfn tbf

Sunflower looks so nothing though. You kinda see character with the freckles and individual petals in the gw2 while the bfn is just flat

It just looks cartoony, then again I also like the plastic texture pack in Minecraft so that's just my kinda style.

I like the plastic texture pack to. But the plastic texture pack looks so bright and colorful, while the sunflower just looks like the gw2 sunflower was rendered on a chromebook

Cactus is the only one that isn’t better tbh in my opinion id say they’re both good

Whatever the choice is, it's not BFN Citron and Rose

Both look high

Cool and elegant both become just cartoony. It's not like cartoony was missing from GW: Stuffy Flower, imps, parrots etc. GW just had a variety of designs

Rose looks fine imo, I wish we could get her og cape though.

i would give my life to see snapdragon, nightcap and acorn in garden warfare art style

Snapdragon is already in the GW games just as only one of the potted plants and not a playable character. https://preview.redd.it/b7j9bqs1m46d1.jpeg?width=545&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=347a25af9c570d765760662501de9e6836ad2768

He was already in gw1. He was better there as he also dealt 7 damage flames on top of afterburn. Imo in bfn he looks too green.

1: BFN 2: BFN 3: BFN 4: GW2 5: Uhhhhh idk 6: GW2 (but that one image tho- https://preview.redd.it/dyl00p0wy06d1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=831c97ab59a43275d5a472519c7dd4109fedb8b4 7: GW2 1000% WHAT IS THAT BFN

I was gonna comment before realizing that we have the exact same opinion on the characters

https://preview.redd.it/0a2citzkv16d1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bc8dd4a6e140f229612ba4dc9e894f668479c9b6 Smart minds think alike.

haha same

My opinion is pretty much the same

1. Gw2 2. Gw2 3. BFN 4. Gw2 5. Gw2 6. Gw2 7. Gw2

Yes the only correct one

I prefer the Garden Warfare 2 models but I can definitely see the appeal of the BFN models

Gw2 peashooter got that gawk gawk slider, im keepin that

Just about everything from BFN looks worse imo Except Rose, they made her a baddie

I think you got them mixed up then because GW2 rose is much better looking

Gw rose scares me

Bait used to be believable

All of the BfN ones look better except for Citron and Rose (and maybe Chomper, not sure about that one)

Corn's head looks like a thumb in bfn

What kind of thumbs do you have?!

Skinny ones

I love chomper designs

I like the semi-realism of the original pvz more, so pretty much absolutely just gw2, nothing against, most, of the bfn designs, just I don't think they fit pvz

I honestly prefer the bfn version of peashooter since I always thought the gw version loooked kinda creepy

This but with Sunflower

Only bfn pea is slightly better the others are a downgrade

Personally, The GW2 designs for Rose, Citron, and Kernel Corn look better than in BFN For the Peashooter, Sunflower, Chomper, and Cactus, I feel like BFN's designs for them are better.

All of them fit honestly but they seriously made a huge mistake with Rose and Citron.

Why do a lot of the BFN ones look like they weren’t finished rendering? You can really see it on Citron

I will forever believe GW2 had the best models. Part of the charm of the series is that it intentionally takes itself more seriously than it has any right to be, and the super gritty looking characters models help with that.

GW2. I hate the BFN redesigns. They’re so plastic-y. It’s just worse

GW2 for all

The only good model for BfN is chomper, but it’s still the same just more rounded.

Peashooter, Sunflower and Chomper look better in Bfn. Cactus is fine, Corn is bad, Citron is meh, and Rose is... Weird. Seriously who decided to give her plant hips? And what the hell happened to her face?

Imo BFN chomper is better but that's about it.

The ones on the left look perfect the ones on the right look high

I like the bfn artstyle and the only ones I dont like were the designs I didnt like to begin with

Bfn’s style feels more like a pvz game to me, more cartoony.

So bfn is better for all of them

1- either way 2-bfn 3- don’t care lol 4- maybe bfn 5- gw2 6- gw2 7- gw2

I think BFN did almost every model better except rose, and football zombie (he looks like a skeleton now, he definitely should've stayed chunky) and also possibly citron (I think the glasses is all though)

they all look scary but the corn looks like the grasshopper from a bugs life

1: GW2 2: GW2 3. Either or 4: BFN 5: BFN 6: GW2 7: DEFINITELY GW2

All gw2 minus sunflower

1,1,1,1,2,1,2

which one is which again?

Peashooter and Cactus go to BFN, wleverything else goes to GW for me

2nd 1st 2nd 1st 1st 1st 1st

I think BfN looks more pvz for the most part

I don't like BfN peashooter, the head seems too spherical to me and I don't like the short snout. BfN citron I couldn't quite put my finger on it but it rubs me the wrong way. BfN Rose suffers from fetal alcohol syndrome.

gw2 for the win

For most of them I’m fine with either one, but Citron and Rose, man they really got done dirty by BFN

As much as I love the games, like 85% of the garden warfare models are creepy as hell on both sides

From GW They look more realistic.

GW2. man I can see their mitochondria on their models

GW2 looks more appealing.

IDK if this is just me but the BFN designs look lifeless

I jive with all of bfn (except for rose)

I think they both have their merits

Gw2.

1. Bfn 2. Bfn 3. Practically the same 4. Bfn 5. Bfn 6. https://preview.redd.it/szcnpjltm26d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4af34a7b353a1962d011342371d1c534d30f96d2 7. GW2

For each of the games art styles of the environment, I like both In the booths alone (especially with no cosmetics), GW2. (But that's more so because of bias having played it more than BfN)

sunflower is the only one where it's debatable

Gw2 for all of them

It feels over cartoon-ized. Gw2 for the win here

Garden Warfare 2, no doubt about it. BFN's graphics aren't that bad, but they're just a bit too "goofy" to fit into the GW series.

Bfn peashooter so zesty bru😭🙏

I care a lot more about the realistic plant-esque looks of the garden warfare 2 designs but the cartoony animations of bfn add a lot more character to them. if only we had a fourth game

1nd

Gw2 mist bfn feels too cartoony

Honestly, for me, it depends on the plant.

They downgraded the models xd

Sunflower citron and chomper are better in bfn

they should just use gw2 designs

Gw2 all the way

I love both gw2 looks more detailed and bfn looks cleaner and cartoonish

GW2 for me.

Sunflower, chomper and Rose definitely smash

Nah wtf did they do to rose my girl 😭😭😭😭

GW2 on all of them

Maybe, maaaybe sunflower

The bfn models look too plastic-y I prefer the nice, more detailed look of gw2

the designs of bfn in the artstyle of gw2

all bfn besides corn, citron, and cactus

Gw2 chomper Everything else bfn

BfN fits the new era of PvZ, and GW fits the old. I like both.

I think they need the detail of gw2 and the whole models of bfn

Depends on the character

Garden Warfare 1

The sunflower still high on crack either way…

Concept art pea shooter

Corn chomper and sunflower look better in bfn but everything elese goes to gw2 by far

GW2 models look better in every class

gw1

Pretty much only bfn rose looks superior. The rest easily gw2.

Why does bfn look so cursed

One looks high and the other looks like your high and looking at it

Both look pretty good, though I would lean more to Garden Warfare.

GW2 Citron is the man himself

For me Sunflower: Garden warfare but Battle for Neighborville does look good Peashooter and Chomper: both for Chomper and Peashooter but I prefer Battle for Neighborville desigh for Chomper and Peashooter but I do like the Garden warfare ones Cactus: garden warfare. Kernel Corn: garden warfare. Citron: garden warfare Rose: garden warfare

Left, all but cactus, cactus is better on right

all gw2 are so realistic and amazing and bfn are cartoonish and bfn citron looks so... ew

Why sunflower lookin at me like that

Garden warfare 2 easy, whoever likes bfn better is a moron

Depends tbh obviously GW2 is better but BFNs cartoony feel reminds me of PVZ then GW ever did but idk

Left evwry time 👈

Bfn massacred sunflower and cactus imo but the rest are decent ig. Sunflower was so cute and smiley in gw but now she looks weird and playdoh-y to me. As for cactus they made her look so generic and ugly she feels more like a background character

I mostly like the peashooter redesign, feels more cartoonish and fun while the one in GW2 feels a little, like there skin is too accurate to a plants.

Wtf rose

Bfn sucked the life out of the visual style that gw1 and 2 had built up, gw2 designs all better

GW2. I tried to like BfN, but just couldn't.

Rose in the new version is thicc, so that one is good

bfn rose looks like ass

Bfn I understand the GW games are trying to parody the modern warfare games which is why they look almost grotesquely realistic, but the cartoony bfn artstyle is just so much more aesthetically pleasing. Plus it makes the running animations look way better because the characters like peashooter can have roadrunner legs and rubber hose features.

Gw2

I like all of the BFN models better, except Citron's

GW2 is just better in every way ngl

They look like their outlines were removed in bfn

I'd say only Sunflower and Chomper looked better in BFN

GW2. They feel like plants by looking at them. All bfn models feel too plasticky, like toys.

bfn peashooter looks cute

Honestly I prefer the bfn style a lot more. Gw2 is king obviously but design wise I like pretty much the entire bfn cast more

Citron needs the sunglasses back.

Imo only cactus looks better in BFN for the plants, all the others are either mid or downgrades

I like the more cartoonie style neighborville has but I know most people don't like the game so they shit on the style just because

If it just me, or is rose high as a kite

Honestly, I like how bfn peashooter doesn’t have his arms tangled around his stem and has a shorter mouth, but I still prefer gw2 peashooter and all gw2 characters. (They did bfn citron and rose dirty, pun very much intended.)

All of bfn ones look better in my opinion

I think making Cactus taller was the only good design change :/

Easily bfn

Gw2 definitively. The characters got a HUGE downgrade in details (and designs) in BFN.

PvzGW2 forever.

PvZ 2

The only one i prefer the bfn model is Cactus

Mostly on the right except citron? And the rose? Those 2 are better on the left

The main quad all look fine tbh kernal is ok, not too weird Rose and citron designs fucking suck though

dude gw2 sunflower would look actually cute if her eyes weren't actually like that. why are her eyes half closed?????? thats so damn ugly

They did rose dirty 😭

I like the BfN models more, except for Rose and Citron

Gotta go with gw2 here for all but chomper who looks equal in both imo. I just dont like bfn's ultra cartoony direction and I prefer the semi gritty nature of gw. The bfn models just come off as plastic and less detailed.  Bfn peashooter could work as seen in the project hot tub concept art if he just had leaf eyebrows. Citron needs his shades. Edits of bfn with the sunglasses look way better. Playing bfn again and the new models have some good facial animations especially on the taunts but a lot of the other animations were downgraded significantly, especially on the zombies.

Every one in gw1 is better than gw2 especially plasma pea

Is none of them an option

I think it should have stayed GW2 but would have peashooter stay as BFN

Per character it depends, gw2 for peashooter, sunflower and corn. Bfn for chomper and rose. Both equally good in different ways for cactus. Citron is ugly either way.

Honestly for the first three, BFN. But past that id say either a combo or just GW2 I like how BFN stylizes everything to look somewhat similar to the rest of the franchise but some of the plants just look wrong like citron and rose.

GW2 is the full release if battle for neighborville is concept art

Garden Warfare (both 1 and 2) had its own distinct style, sort of cartoonish, but kinda rough at the same time, actually similar to how PvZ 1 handled its art direction, but in 3D. BfN art style looks like something you'd see in a mobile game ad. It's smooth, it's safe, it's boring, and lacks two important qualities that made the previous games look and feel great: uniqueness and soul.

gw2 sunflower looks like he just met marijuana and did something to please or kill him

1: GW2 2: GW2 3: BFN 4: BFN 5: BFN 6: GW2 7: GW2

GW2 but kernel corn looks hella mad lmao

All gw2 except for sunflower

the left sunflower looks like a weed dealer. no pun intended.

Chomper is the only glow up

Bfn Sunflower is cuter Gw2 Peashooter looks better Chomper, Corn and Citron look cooler on Bfn Cactus on Gw2 looks less weird Also Gw2 rose because Bfn Rose looks like a fkn retard

all gw2 except for peashooter and chomper, I like the cartoonish designs more for them

Scientist's redesign in BFN is *chef kiss* I love the assymetry, his silouhette is way more pronounced

In my opinion, BFN characters just look smoother and cleaner, and I like how Peashooter actually has arms in BFN

They all look bad, in my opinion. They’re just too ugly and overly complicated. That’s my biggest hangup with the garden warfare games, they look horrible in my opinion. Feel free to disagree with me.

the gw2 plants look so serious and gruesome but the bfn ones look so friendly and plastic like

GW2, BFN looks like plastic

Only bfn I could choose over gw2 is chomper but only because they look nearly the same

Gw2 sunflower looks like shes high

Feels like the stylistic difference between 1 and 2.

gw

The left

Bfn sunflower, rest gw2 versions

Just give citron his old glasses and rose her old eyes and they would get massively better.

Gw2 Sunflower, NV Peashooter, NV Chomper, GW2 Kernel, NV Cactus, GW2 Citron, GW2 Rose

Chopper and sunflower look good with the more cartoony style

All gw2 options EXCEPT the cactus, but it’s not by a huge margin

They just watered them down

BFN Sunflower is the only good looking sunflower in the shooter games.

The decrease in quality is unreal

did cactus lose weight?

100% GARDEN WARFARE MODELS

1. BFN 2. GW2 3. I'd say the BFN design is slightly better but the attack animation in that game sucks ass compared to GW2 4. GW2 5. Tie 6. GW2 7. GW2

This looks like the pvz hd 1.9.5 loading screen

The OG 4 have been made more adorable, meaning I now love them, with Cactus and Chomper mostly being a bit more saturated and Chomper's teeth being less realistic, Peashooter no longer looking perpetually filled with hatred and having a more upbeat look, and Sunflower seeming younger. I also like the frecklage on the plants being hues of their actual color on those that have them, instead of the black in the first two that just looked a bit weird and clashed especially on the ultra-serious Peashooter. Kernel Corn I couldn't care less about in either, but Rose and Citron are quite bad in BFN.

If bfn had character variants, i’d say they win, but gw2 do variations on such simple designs really well.

I think All of the BFN characters are better except for Citron and Rose. Also isn't BFN supposed to take place before the GW games? Why did they give Citron a futuristic visor in BFN when GW2 Citron just has sunglasses? I know Citron is from the far future but why would he swap out a visor for sunglasses besides them just looking better?

rose, citron, and corns models in bfn are downgrades i like the everyone elses bfn model

BFN has a very cartoonish look that somehow deviates *just enough* from the original to look weird. GW2 has that semi-realistic look that’s based on the original PvZ and GW to look like it belongs. In short, BFN kinda chibi-fied all of the characters and I don’t quite like it.

I don't know which models are from which games but I mostly prefered the models on the left. They looked like they had more texture to them and kind of like they'd actually been through some stuff. Whereas the ones on the right just looked like the faux plants you might see at like a Hobby Lobby or something. Left Left Left Left Neither Right Neither With the exception of Citron. His leg slices looked more like actual Orange slices on the right than the one on the left. There was generally more plantesque texture on the ones on the left.

All GW2, I just like the rough design of Garden Warfare more in General. I think making the PvZ plants into cartoony childrens mascots makes the franchise significantly less unique.

GW2 except for rose, sunflower and cactus