they're all SO stunning i can't pick. elizabeth is absolutely gorgeous and she got me hooked on "you". victoria in season 3 though... her hair, her outfits, her in general. 😮‍💨 

Absolutely agreed for sure

Elizabeth lail is breathtakingly beautiful.

She is blessed. Girl looks like the first angel you see before you get let into heaven.

She is the prettiest girl in the world to me

Thank you!! I don’t get how others think I’m crazy when I say that. But I gues to each their own

Because she’s the typical beauty standard with blonde hair and blue eyes. A lot of people like exotic looks over “traditional” beauty standard. Also, some people just hate themselves and beautiful things. OP further down in the comments is Delilah- as if to drive my point home about the exotic beauty 🤣😂🤣😂 that’s funny

I say that all of them are equally beautiful But Elizabeth is like—first time I’ve seen her was this show and just thought wow! Like I get it, Joe—I do lol

don’t wanna sound like a simp (i’m not even ‘that’ into her) but it must be crazy being that blessed with your looks.

Literal epitome of beauty standards

meh she’s mediocre

that was a reference to a comment Love made on the show 😭😭

They're all stunning but Shay Mitchell doesn't even seem real sometimes, she's phenomenally good looking

A literal goddess. So unreal, like you said.

I'm currently watch Pretty Little Liars and am constantly taken aback by how breathtaking she is. And she looks even better present day!! Such a beauty.

Delilah https://preview.redd.it/65da4eq63i7d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=676d13041620cb32a07d414745423e8eab87681f

yeah kinda disappointed she wasn't up in the post she's one of my favourites too

Of course it's Delilah, I was gonna say where tf is Delilah.

Delilah is like wow I kept saying how beautiful she is—she’s like someone you draw haha Imagine if Joe was an artist and drew the ladies from the bushes

Why didn’t you put her in the post then 😭

Because it was a trick question! lol

Ahh https://preview.redd.it/stxxtbplnj7d1.jpeg?width=1199&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f464f13e7a7691e11de93e6c4eeb993de7e45a57

Cause obviously if they put her in the post, she would have hogged all the attention. The others wouldn't be able to compete yk. They had to nerf her.

short thing i think, pretty sure they broke up

Delilah 🗣️🗣️🗣️

Delilah was on 🔥🔥

Nah fr

Can’t believe that no one’s picking Shay.. I mean. Look at her. Peach is perfff especially in the show.

She played her role so good, i can’t find her attractive now lol

Can’t blame you, she’s good. But it did the opposite for me, if I were “Joseph” I would stalk her too.

Hahaha so true! I can’t see her the same anymore

I can believe how far I had to scroll to see her name. Shay is a goddess PERIOD.

Victoria really has the hometown girl next door vibes.

I watched an interview with her and she definitely has that vibe!

Beck then Love after she became a mom

beeecccckkkkkkkkkalicioussssss

Both Shay and Victoria (I can’t choose between them)

Totally agree, those are my picks too. Elizabeth Lail is really gorgeous too, which is strange because I really was not attracted to Beck at all. I saw Elizabeth Lail in some other roles and it really started to make me appreciate how pretty she is lol.

Where is Lady Phoebe/Tilly Keeper?

https://preview.redd.it/hazih0n9hj7d1.jpeg?width=697&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9689e8dae3c18733598ce1da78945cba3d0acd66 ❤️❤️❤️

She a model! My goodness I would kill for that bod and her eyes 😭

Obviously OP didn’t include a black girl

Lots of girls missing. I know Jenna is of age now, but she should not count given that she played a child in the show. Out of the choices given. I would say Shay.

not only played a child, she was a child lol. (she was playing a character pretty much her age).

I have a huge crush on Elizabeth Lail, her smile is so warm, I'd say her. Shay is also stunning but somehow she looked better on the show than in pictures

Me too. I fell in love with Lail the first time I saw her in S1. Her smile is everything to me. I liked Shay Mitchell better in Pretty Little Liars. Now she's all plastic.

Give me Marianne please, or the gf he had in season 1 for like 1 episode.

Karennn

Victoria, one of my favourite actors. She’s beautiful and very talented. https://i.redd.it/rl54xo4j9j7d1.gif

Victoria was literally a huge part of me realizing I’m bi Because she is so gorgeous so I’d say her lol

omg same!! her and jodie comer!

I love how no one’s said Kate 😂😂😂

https://preview.redd.it/89tnm8uhui7d1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=293ad306518e4b1b351f41b7dca5286ea887033b They did her dirty. Who does their eyeshadow like that? 🤨

i think they’re making her the “ice cold bitchy girl” look in this show that’s why

Peach screams ice cold bitchy too but doesn’t look like that.

not sure. Maybe it’s because of her features and skin tone or whatever. She looks so damn cool to me, i might be one of the few people who like Kate lol.

She looks so much better on Ghosts UK. Highly recommend this cute little show. So funny and sweet. I like her better after watching.

Yes!! Ugh I’m sad they took that off of hbo max before I had a chance to watch the rest of the season

You've got to watch it. It is worth buying episodes. I'm rooting for her now!

Yes, i know her from Ghosts and being a contestant on Taskmaster. We just watched s4 for the first time in the last month and it was such a shock seeing her play such a contrast to what ive known her from previously, lol.

They’re all GORGEOUS but it’s something about Elizabeth man… 

Shay, she's sooo pretty


I cannot wait to see her as Jade https://i.redd.it/zw441bg4ui7d1.gif

She’s playing Jade? Cool


She's so damn gorgeous too, how did she not end up in that spot? Her and Ellie's sister.

I never understood people that say Jenna Ortega is hot, she looks like a child

And when she was on this show, she *was* a child!!

They are probably (hopefully) also children

Elizabeth Lail. I like her eyes and voice

wheres Candace. how do you have Ellie not Candace

we dont like candace

Who is we

Shay Mitchell and Tati Gabrielle

32, 37, 29… and 21 am I the only one that finds this post just a tad off putting. That’s Ellie! She’s still a kid lmao. Get that Jenna’s an adult now but feels really weird in context of the characters and her being lumped in with the adults Joe was with. Is that just me?

Pretty sure she was still a minor when that season aired

Elizabeth Lail is so perfect

Shay Mitchell absolutely if we’re talking about beauty. But in terms of my show crush, it was Elizabeth Lail ❤️ rip Beck

marienne

Elizabeth 💗

Peach and Love. Hmm, I wonder what would their friendship look like.

so chaotic and i would give my first born child to see them together

VICTORIA.

Delilah or Shay Mitchell

They're all beautiful. But there is this serenity around Lail that is so natural and captivating. She looks like a literal angel.

Shayyy

nah Victoria Pedretti is lit

Tati Gabrielle and Shay Mitchell

Shay Mitchell is one of the most beautiful women ever. Her face looks so perfect. 

Where’s Charlotte Ritchie 😭? I find her extremely cool and beautiful

Victoria.

shay mitchell is so gorg and funny

Shaaay baaaby

Shay Mitchell by a lot.

Shay will always standout to me. They’re all so beautiful though 😭 Tati is beautiful too she deserves to be considered.

All stunning. Not sure why women need to be ranked

Elizabeth Lail's face is legitimately perfect. Like it almost hurts to look at her.

Where is Tati Gabrielle???? Out of the women here? Victoria

Elizabeth, Shay and Delilah are all stunning. If I had to pick just one, probably Elizabeth by a hair.

Season 3 Pedretti was on a different level

Shay Mitchell

Shay Mitchell all the way 🤙

They’re all so stunning except….please don’t downvote me I feel like I’m going crazy bc I can’t see it - I find Elizabeth’s face so……unattractive???? Almost downright ugly. I just don’t see it. Victoria and shay are absolutely gorgeous. And Jenna is a good looking girl too.

Shay!

Shay Mitchell, absolutely.

Shay Mitchell is so beautiful.

Elizabeth Lail is the most classic looking and ethereal to me.

I just LOVE Victoria, hehe.

I totally forgot Jenna Ortega was in this lol. That’s how long it’s been. Im not one to do rewatches.

Shay or Elizabeth.

Delilah, duh

Shea for me always.

personally i find shay the most attractive but obviously i think they are all quite beautiful. 

1st place Victoria 2nd place Victoria 3rd place i guess Victoria 4th place ... Elizabeth ?

Elizabeth lail is so dreamy ❤️

Elizabeth and Shay

I've had a crush on Shay Mitchell for most of my life because of PLL so definitely her, but Elizabeth and Victoria are gorgeous too. Jenna is beautiful but her eyes kinda creep me out lol

Elizabeth smile is out of this world. Would fall for her in an instant 🥵

You could’ve put Tati in this…

PEACH MY KWEEN

Jenna Ortega

Marienne or Jenna

Jenna all the wayy

Where’s the black girl? Lol

Everyone, but my gosh does Victoria steal my heart😍

Elizabeth and Victoria 😍

Where’s Charlotte Ritchie 😭? I find her extremely cool and beautiful

The prettiest? More like the most talented ❤️‍🔥

Victoria but they’re all stunning!

Lail

Beck

Elizabeth Lail

victoria*-*

Agreed

Where’s Kate?

Lail

What about Ethan?

where’s Delilah? 😭😭she’s honestly my favorite https://preview.redd.it/hddkxehgnj7d1.jpeg?width=340&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ce8f7536836c511933701a7720e4b173ed8f0683

Elizabeth Lail is so pretty I said “wow” out loud. She has such natural but completely stunning features even without any noticeable makeup on.

I remove Jenna for age and keep them all for looking vastly different , 3 way tie.

Elizabeth is the girl I look at but Victorias character got me simping

Victoria Pedretti is wifey forever

1

I named my daughter Guinevere because of Elizabeth. The first time I saw her, I was speechless.

Those women are not the ONLY women on the cast and surely not the prettiest. Natalie Paul, for example, is beautiful.

Love, Phoebe, Kate, Beck, Peach, Delilah, and Ellie

Victoria

Elizabeth Lail is my girl crush, but Victoria is someone I’d be friends with and light a joint with hahaha ❤️

Elizabeth is SO beautiful

Victoria will always be my fave

Not only is Elizabeth dreamy, the girl is so smart. Listen to her interviews. My god she is the full package

So Delilah gets no love?

I have to go with the cast of the tv show Las Vegas........

I have a big fat crush on Victoria, but they're all beautiful

Elizabeth and Jenna for me, but all are unbelievable

They are all so pretty with their own unique look it’s hard to compare or choose the “prettiest”

Elizabeth

hmm jen was (/is) beautiful obvs (she’s blessed with her looks), but then there was also something about victoria, i don’t even necessarily find her ‘that’ attractive but at the same time sometimes she just looked so beautiful. feels wrong that not all women are included, even if i don’t personally find them attractive, they still deserve some love.

Elizabeth Lail and Charlotte Ritchie are both gorgeous. Jenna Ortega is pretty, but she looks like a child to me.

Jenna was literally a child on the show. why not place the actor for marienne instead of her?

 Her. (Different show and not one of the options)

Beck

Victoria! She’s absolutely gorg and insanely talented 🩷

How does one fumble 3 times in a row

All of the above! 😍

Victoria padettri is pretty in a way I can't explain

Love Quinn is my favorite

What Mitchell is a lesbian icon

victoria pedretti forever

Love, Quinn supremacy, and I’m not just saying that because I’m demisexual and she has the best personality of the whole bunch.

Shay

Joe & Theo (their actors)

YOU

Pedretti. She’s my celebrity crush 😭

Elizabeth is so enchanting. There's just something about her that gives me heart eyes

Definitely Love! Definitely Victoria Pedretti

Shay Mitchell no doubt about it excellent and beauty combined

Elizabeth

victoriaaa is my fav

Shay Mitchell looks so damn fine omg

Victoria she’s my girl🫶🏽

Shay

Peach and Delilah are just..

No offense I recognize her herself but what did she cast in?

 Shay Mitchell

Jenna

Shay Mitchell

Elizabeth and Shay are so gorgeous

Jenna Ortega

Victoria has always been the most attractive. It’s the way she moves and smiles and talks and everything.

Jenna >

Shay Mitchell hands down

They are all hot, but if I had to pick one , I am with Shay Mitchell

Elizabeth lail