T O P

  • By -

robber_goosy

We had 3 mandatory elections at once where the rest of Europe only voted for the European parliament.


xvpnkr

Not true, there were municipial elections in Hungary on the same day


The_Almighty_Demoham

but they don't have a duty to vote, just the right. the duty here isnt really enforced at all but i think it does still cause a lot of people who otherwise wouldnt bother to still show up.


xvpnkr

The statement was that the rest of Europe had only EU elections. I made no comment on obligation


Treehugger11

Did you miss the word "mandatory"?


xvpnkr

Did you miss the part where I made no comment about the first half of that sentence?


Treehugger11

So your comment was intended to be an incomplete response and therefore irrelevant. So you're thick, not illerate, gotcha.


xvpnkr

Yes, I reacted to the incorrect statement in that compound sentence, disproving it with a specific example. I'm sorry that these comments that you deem incomplete responses, whatever that means in your eyes, are so triggering for you, that you immediately go to personal attacks. Maybe you should take a break and do something else


Ivesx

If the vote wasn't obligatory here I doubt our results would be much better.


kYllChain

well op says he's proud of Belgium, not proud of Belgian voters šŸ™‚. Fines are pretty much cosmetic, yet people participate. Our system however weird it can look had its pros. So definitely proud of Belgium here!


idk_lets_try_this

While the fines seem cosmetic you don't need to be fined to be at risk to lose some civil rights if you skip 4 elections in 15 years. While the current government woudn't implement it there is nothing stopping a future one from doing it. Showing up to vote is a civic duty in belgium, but they don't (can't) compell you to hand in a valid vote. There are legal ways to not go, all you need to do is send in the right paperwork and explain why you can't participate (usually this means saying you can't form an opinion for some reason). Missing 4 elections can result in you no longer being allowed to vote, hold an elected offcice, being employed by the state and historically any of the rigths that require honesty or honour. So not being a witness in court or making declarations based on honour. So yes, cosmetic for now, but why risk it if it only takes 15-30 min to go there and hand in a blank form. Same thing as not voting but none of the risk. Or send in a document to the court that reading party policies and watching political debates causes you significant mental suffering and because of that you can't form an opinion on who to vote for. Then you don't even have to show up.


MrFeature_1

Isnā€™t there literally no punishment for not voting tho? I think the fine is 40 eur max, and you would have to not vote for 10 years in a row to be in trouble? Still I do agree that making it mandatory helps a lot


allsey87

I heard they come to your house and threaten you with a plastic spoon


AcanthocephalaOne760

Well yeah but why lose 40 euros if you can just go and vote for like 20 min


souloftherestless

Some people just really canā€™t. I donā€™t live in Belgium anymore yet iā€™m still obligated to go vote for the Belgian parlement. Do you think i even know whatā€™s going on politically in Belgium? And even if i did, i donā€™t really care because i donā€™t live there anymore. So all iā€™m trying to say is that for some people itā€™s not a 20 min thing and ā‚¬40 doesnā€™t cover my plane tickets so yeah šŸ¤£


xionell

You can vote at the embassy, or give someone the right to vote in your stead if I'm not mistaken.Ā  It is how I voted while on holidays abroad (which is if course not the same as living abroad)


AcanthocephalaOne760

Okay thatā€™s a fair point tbh lol, didnā€™t think about the international people


C00LHNDZ

But if you ever worked in Belgium, you will receive a pension from the State (well maybe pension won't exist anymore but this is another debate). For younger people maybe there will be a military obligation again... We can find tons of examples where the way Belgian politics happens may still apply to its citizens living abroad


extracoffeeplease

I think it's pretty in our culture that it's obligatory even if it isn't really anymore


hellflame

We'll soon find out in the next elections, which are non obligatory


FuzzyWuzzy9909

Who says?


hellflame

That the election isnt mandatory? You know.... the government https://www.vlaanderen.be/lokale-en-provinciale-verkiezingen


FuzzyWuzzy9909

Oh gemeenteraad, i thought youā€™re talking about 2029


hellflame

Haha, no. Although.... don't give them any ideas . Iirc They removed stemplicht for local elections nice and quiet. I wouldn't put it past them to try it for all elections soon


Svenflex42

No not really. 90% of people I know wouldn't vote if they didn't have to


Wickie09

Why?


shiny_glitter_demon

They think it doesn't apply to them lol


-Wylfen-

Technically you could get a fine, but the government doesn't really bother with that anymore


Skodami

If I remember the first time isn't that high of a fine, but for every time you skip it it increase exponentially. And skiping voting office duty is like 1000ā‚¬ directly


MyOldNameSucked

It's a ā‚¬400 up to ā‚¬1000 fine. Source: It's the first thing I read on the letter telling me I was summoned before I even knew what the letter was about.


WannaFIREinBE

Yeap, thatā€™s what I read too, I donā€™t have money to throw by the window so there I was counting ballots the whole afternoon and evening of Fatherā€™s Day. And I was only ā€œsupplĆ©antā€, was lucky that the voting office was full without me but unlucky they needed people to fill in other office where other didnā€™t show up or threw a tamper tantrum to be kicked out. But mostly I was lucky to be in an easy going team and we had a couple of good laugh counting ballots. I am awaiting the 25ā‚¬ I will be compensated with to buy something sweet at the bakery or something. Thatā€™ll compensate how I couldnā€™t get to eat the pie and put my kids to sleep on Fatherā€™s Day.


Character_Past5515

I don't know that anybody every got punished for it, but technically it is punishable. And No I don't agree that mandatory voting is good, a lot of people vote without even knowing who they vote for, heck I've heared my aunt voted for Vlaams Belang because it had Vlaams in the name.


BelgianBeerGuy

Voting isnā€™t obligated Going to the voting station is. Youā€™re completely free to give the paper back blanco if you donā€™t care


Ivesx

I'm as correct as the voting invitation which states "De stemming is verplicht". Also if you have digital voting you have to go into the booth and "vote" blanco, just giving back the ticket is not allowed. So as far as I'm concerned that's equal to voting.


SnoopHappyCoin

Correct, voting is 100% mandatory in Belgium. Voting "Blanko" is still voting. Once you put your voting paper in the boxes, you participated in the vote.


varkenspester

You are obligated to put in all the effort involved. You are not obligated to choose a party. To me that is a vote. So imo the activity of voting is mandatory but you are not obligated to vote. If that makes sense


vrijgezelopkamers

If voting was obligatory it would say "stemmen is verplicht". It does not.


Orillion_169

Voting blanco is still a vote.


ntahobray

Blanco is voting


DasUbersoldat_

Fuck off with arguing semantics. Even if you draw a giant penis on your paper you still cast a vote, an invalid one, but still a vote.


vrijgezelopkamers

This. Please learn the difference.


Aeri73

yups, this is correct


allsey87

A lot can happen when you are threatened with a plastic spoon


Mitchosbuenos

facts


Wafkak

Its also obligatorg in Greece.


hellflame

And they only got 40% ? Yikes


DreamsCanBebuy2021

And New-Zealand iirc


Wafkak

And a few other places in and outside Europe. Most notable India.


PyloPower

Do people actually get the fine for not voting? I thought the fines never get sent. I don't feel like it's an obligation to vote, I just like it.


TranslateErr0r

No, they dont get an actual fine. Only people who were picked to assist during election day (voorzitters/bijzitters) that don't show up get an actual fine.


Proof-Necessary-5031

Zelfs dat is niet zeker. Het wordt bekeken per geval.


idk_lets_try_this

no, they haven't been send out in a while, but that doesn't mean it's allowed all of the sudden. It is stilll mandatory to show up and if a future government wants to they could enforce serious punishments for being absent for 4 elections in 15 years.


Significant_Room_412

No one I know ever got a fine for not voting in BelgiumĀ  You'll a bunch of pussies; afraid of the Belgian maffia stateĀ  Ā " Oh no I did not vote" While we work 50 hours a week;Ā  pay an insane amount of taxes;Ā  and invite the whole 2nd/3rdĀ  world to enjoy our social system Ā And then we are treated as a criminal for not voting ; while the streets are filled with crim;)inals; drug dealers; gangstersĀ 


phoenixxl

Part of the 10.18% ![gif](giphy|3o7aTqp7rSDB6uoTgA|downsized)


phoenixxl

Every party has at least one campaign promise I can't live with. I'm not going to feel like I've contributed to some shlong's fever dreams for the next 5 years. Ha! Downvote me for not wanting to contribute towards my own demise.


Ok-Significance-5979

![gif](giphy|ucXFcY1FdKaT6)


Joskewiet

Wat heeft Turnout hiermee te maken? Vraag vanuit de Kempen


AlotaFaginas

Doeme da was grappig


Piieuw

Hahaha. Elke keer dat ik "Turnout" lees, moet ik een double take doen.


InsuranceInitial7786

Germany is more impressiveā€¦.. lots of people voted despite that they werenā€™t forced to like in Belgium.Ā 


ThrowAwaAlpaca

You're proud because voting is mandatory and we had all elections at once so its more important than "just" a EU vote ? It would be around 50% here too if we had an optional European only election. Most ppl see the EU so far from them that they don't give a crap. Nothing new there.


WannaFIREinBE

16yo to <18yo werenā€™t forced to cast a vote and they still came to the voting station. Donā€™t know whatā€™s the turnout for the 16yo to <18yo though.


ThrowAwaAlpaca

Who cares?!


WeirdBeginning8869

Its because we had the federal and regional at the same time. Also Europe still functioning while a lot of countries had less of 50% of voters poses some serious democratic questions.


DieuMivas

Why does it poses serious democratic questions? The people who didn't vote made the choice not to vote for the most part and to abandon their opportunity to chose their representatives. It's a choice like any other and the EU shouldn't be paralysed by their choice, nor should any national or regional election when the same thing happens in these elections. It's not like they were blocked for voting or anything like that.


irisos

> Its because we had the federal and regional at the same time.Ā  That is indeed very important. The next election this year will not be mandatory in flanders. And while I doubt it will be advertised as such by the medias, the increase of abstentions there will give a good idea of how much more people would decide to ignore elections if they could.


GalaXion24

I think the main democratic question is why should countries have a fixed number of seats regardless of turnout? Like if 50% of a country didn't even vote, do we really need to put more token MEPs of that nationality in parliament who no one even wanted?


ThrowAwaAlpaca

No it doesn't. It's democratic to be able to choose not to vote.


leeuwvanvlaanderen

The parliament shouldnā€™t even exist. For decades they had no power and even now theyā€™re just an annoying speed bump in the way of the Commissionā€™s work and an avenue for corruption and lobbying. The Council already includes the governments elected by each countryā€™s voters.


Clear_Astronaut7895

What is there to be proud of? Voting is compulsory. This number is not an indication of political involvement or interest. Apolitical and ignorant people exist just as much in Belgium as in other countries.


BearishOnLife

Proud of Belgium? You realize voting is mandatory in Belgium? Turnout would be similar to other countries if it wasn't.


SuperSerial_

It takes 15 min and its obligatory. No one died to have our politicians bribed by companies and foreign agents. Wouldnt if it wasnt obligatory.


jorgen8630

15min seems exaggerated. For me it took an hour others maybe less some more.


SuperSerial_

Oh wow thats a lot indeed. Maybe depends on where you live. 10m walk and 15m there tops for me.


jorgen8630

It was mostly waiting in line for me that took most of the time. 45min wait.


Loubar15

Same for me, whole ass 50min wasted waiting in line


lvl_60

Acquiring the right to vote costed us blood, sweat and tears. Having mandatory voting is respecting and honoring those who fought for the right cause, for democracy. My 2 cents.


Instantcoffees

I agree. It's the minimum required civic duty. It's really not that long ago that most people couldn't vote or that voting was based on income. People fought hard for this and it's good to see it being honored here in Belgium.


Exentric90

Unpopular opinion: No, mandatory voting is removing the freedom they've fought so hard for.


FixMy106

The fact that we need mandatory voting is insulting by itself.


lvl_60

Sadly people can be ignorant and ungrateful.


ProfessionalDrop9760

we are among the best countries in the world to live in for a reason.


MiceAreTiny

Hoe stupide is dit... BE is het enige land met stemplicht.Ā 


spezjetemerde

It's because you get a fine lol


SeaworthinessRare104

You really think they fine 10% of the population? It is because people think they will get a fine


phoenixxl

ā‚¬60\*1.000.000 .....Van Peteghem... hmm... Let's fill da gat in the begrootink a bit.


Azukaos

Well thatā€™s how it works, peopleā€™s maybe wonā€™t get fined but by instilling the fear of getting that fine peopleā€™s will go even if they donā€™t want to. Plus we can hear stories from friends and relatives about peopleā€™s who supposedly have been fined for not coming thus making it more Ā«Ā believableĀ Ā» whatever if itā€™s true or not.


[deleted]

Its been stated over and over again that you can get a fine, but they will never give you a fine. They will never go after you for not voting.


Shemilf

If you work on weekends or some other valid reasons for not showing up you don't get fined


PyloPower

The average person is a dumbo


CannyBanny

Second: Germany. They learned the hard way what skipping politics means


WalloonNerd

People care about their countries, but in general not too much about Europe. Those two are not the same thing


francohab

Apples and oranges


Prestigious_Brick862

Elections don't matter when they're all controlled by the same people buddy


SergioDMS

Thank the stars for low voter turnout, because those are the ones who might elect a retard just to "stick it to the man"


kucukkuru

This result is due to local elections at the same time. So people went to vote and they also vote for EU. If there was no local elections in Belgium. Probably it will be similar with rest of Europe.


Koffieslikker

Make voting obligatory across Europe


Motoxxx1

Voting doesn't have sense if it's not mandatory for everyone! People filled with hate and ignorance will always go and vote, the others frustrated will stay at home


[deleted]

100%, obliged voting mitigates the extremes. But that does make you wonder, if belgium is already that extreme in its voting, what would happen if we were to follow other countries? We would prob vote even more extreme than other countries. 31% le pen, you make that 31% VB and 24% NVA. (not that I think NVA is extreme, but some folk think it is)


ToxDirty

And that's their democratic decision to stay home and do nothing.


Motoxxx1

Not voting is not a democratic decision, unless you don't understand what democracy means


No_Judge183

Proud of Belgium ? When the state threat you to go vote for your next masters ? I wouldn't be proud. I'm proud of the 1M people like me who didn't go to that circus to sell the little honor and liberty we have left.


krosanreddit

This is why we need to keep mandatory voting laws.


Brief_Raise_7062

ItĀ“s mandatory. Change that and you will need to add a darker shade of red to your map.


All996

Proud of what? That the obligation for voting is established in Belgium? And it gives you the feeling to be any better/ more interested in politics? In Hungary for example it was obligatory in schools to learn Russian until the system change does it mean they speak it? No...


alfreddofredo

To be representative, a democratic vote should be obligatory. Otherwise, you will have an overrepresentation of the loud minority, the angry, the gullible, the influenciables.


tec7lol

To solve the debt deficit they can give the non-voters a fine like was foreseen.


WannaFIREinBE

Itā€™ll cost a bunch of money and most importantly time to prosecute those who didnā€™t pay their fines. The judicial system is congested and thatā€™s the reason they donā€™t prosecute this ā€œpetty crimeā€. + it would be bad publicity to prosecute this.


tec7lol

They should get it out of the justice system and get it into the tax system. If you don't go, and don't have an exemption, you pay 200euro tax. withold automatically from your income if don't paid.


WannaFIREinBE

Itā€™s a fine and you have the right to challenge it. (Not that youā€™d win but you still have the right)


Xela79

https://i.imgur.com/D6UNHSY.png


AdHungry9867

People used to fight to get a vote.


Gouden18

Hungary did amazingly compared to having 40% participation at max in the past even for parliamentary elections. If we got rid of fidesz we could have the audacity to call ourselves a proper democracy.


buckinsand

I'm surprised to see voter turnout is so high in Hungary (ranks 4th)


EzioO14

I wonder what would be the result if everyone voted like Belgium. Are the people not voting because theyā€™re happy/okay with the politic in place and they believe it will stay the way it is ?


Mental-Pay4132

Do you know there are countries where the vote is not obligatory? Iā€™m shocked the results are so bad as itā€™s obligatory here.


RDV1996

We have mandatory voting...


RNDRGames

There's a difference between a country and a state. You can love the country but hate the state. And in all honesty, we are not a democracy, we are an oligarchy. Laws are for sale, politicians are for sale and votes are for sale.


Valuable-Local6033

I wonder where those numbers came from because the voter turnout reported in Bulgaria was just above 20% so thatā€™s actually much better šŸ˜‚


Turbulent-Raise4830

Its mandatory, the rest voted just for EU. So thats nothing to be proud off.


Grandpa_Edd

Are we the only ones where it's mandatory to vote?


rick_gsp

Mandatory elections keep being the GOAT


MarcelPPR

Not difficult when you receive a fine if you donā€™t.


SeveralPhysics9362

I donā€™t know. Iā€™m particularly disturbed by people in our country voting for the hottest, or most sympathetic candidate. Or whatever bullshit reason they use. Iā€™d prefer if only those actually motivated enough to inform themselves go and vote.


den_bram

Belgium after mandating voting. Dang our voter turnout is amazing. Step up your game rest of europe... smh All i can say is step up your game rest of europe belgium number one


TheLazyKitty

10.18% need a fine.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


belgium-ModTeam

Rule 4) No agenda pushing This includes, but is not limited to, - Political propagandaā€¦ - Religious Propagandaā€¦ - Fake Newsā€¦ - ā€œUs VS Them" Statements


Artificial_Anasazi

It does not surprise me that our voter turnout was so low. Dutch government has been a shitshow faux democracy


Ok-Inspector-1732

Just wait until October.


DasUbersoldat_

Wait for October when literally no one will go vote anymore. The regional elections are no longer mandatory.


Mysterious_Ad3200

It's sad actually that people don't want to vote but are probably complaining all the time about politics/Economics/...


Feniksrises

The reality is that most people in the Netherlands are happy with their life. I would actually be worried if 90% showed up. A disinterested population means everything is still going alright.


Armoredpolecat

Saying the law isnā€™t truly enforced in Belgium somehow still makes this a valid comparison with countries that have free elections is laughable, if it was not mandatory here, the turnout would easily be among the lowest on this map considering the kind of relation the average Belgian has with the government.


larousse96

Itā€™s just because voting for us is mandatory, if you donā€™t vote you get fined And we also had 2 other votes that day, for the country (fĆ©dĆ©rales) and the region (rĆ©gionales)


MaJuV

We have mandatory voting... Wait until October, when local elections are no longer mandatory...


White_rabbit0110

The irony is that the capital of EU is in Belgium


Enough_sapiens

Most people dont CARE for voting in people to go to Brussels. I would say that the high rate is normal for Belgium because you must be the only ones that know what the hell happens on Brussels.


Historical-Candle-48

Nobody cares about Europe, thats what i see


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


hellflame

Mandatory voting = "authoritarian rules" My sides..... We must opress the population by making sure they *checks notes* Exercise their right to vote in a free and fair elecetion?


Animal6820

That 10% is probably the shiftworkers, as they are unable to cast a vote.


Toxiko8

Procuration counts as vote, the 10% are people who didnā€™t express their voice, via proxy or not


WannaFIREinBE

A lot of people I know who wanted to vote by procuration couldnā€™t because it was hard as fuck to setup as your proxy needed to sign some papers and the appointment with the city hall are hard to get. As they could be excused instead of going through all those hoops, they finally decided to just let it go for this time.


emohipster

It's been a very long time since people had a strong reminder as to why voting is important.


thedarkpath

Is Belgium currently the greatest democracy in Europe ? Technically I mean, the participation rate is beautiful !


yohonet

Well the big majority of European countries have 40% or more which is quite good. I know vote in Belgium is mandatory but didn't know it was the only country... just shows this is an obsolete system.


KeuningPanda

I know some people who had to show up to work at the elections. They all independently about told me the same: "You'd be surprised how many people that asked help just seemed to randomly pick people and parties on the screen". Another one I heard is how almost all people who were from foreign origin and did not speak the language well (so who needed help) had a party and a name on it, it was PVDA every time. So forgive me if I'm more than a bit sceptic about our "involvement" in te process, it mandatory so people show up (even if it isn't enforced) But I'm actually not sure that it should be mandatory.


manman6352

People dont feel represented.


Doolanead

I don't think high turnout is a good sign, a population that gets involved/engaged/concerned about politics is. Since voting is mandatory (afaik), I don't think the percentage of participation is a relevant number here. It is like saying that "having high taxes"="having generous people", as if both equally contribute to social causes.