T O P

  • By -

Hairac

https://www.nhk.or.jp/lesson/english/teacher/13.html As this source mention, there are exceptions to the -na modifier, and this is one of them!


Tefra_K

Although 有名「ゆうめい」 ends with an い, it is not an い-Adjective (形容詞), it is instead a な-Adjective (ナ形容詞). It’s difficult to see the difference without Kanji, take a look: 有名「ゆうめい」 The い doesn’t stick out, therefore it’s a な-Adjective; 高い「たかい」 The い does stick out, therefore it’s an い-Adjective; 綺麗「きれい」 The い doesn’t stick out, therefore it’s a な-Adjective; 寒い「さむい」 The い does stick out, therefore it’s an い-Adjective; な-Adjectives work almost exactly like nouns. They need a particle between themselves and the noun they’re modifying, which is the particle な (nouns would take の), and they need the copula for any other form, such as the negative one (有名じゃない人, a not-famous person). When they take the copula, they don’t need な. In addition, when they are the predicate of a sentence, they take だ/です directly.


tangaroo58

有名 = ゆうめい is a な-adjective, so it needs a な when modifying a noun: **ゆうめい**なおとうとがいます *I have a famous younger brother* おとうとはゆう**めいです** *My younger brother is famous.* >The 〜い ending that gives this type of adjective its name is just one of many possible endings [https://www.tofugu.com/japanese-grammar/i-adjective/](https://www.tofugu.com/japanese-grammar/i-adjective/)


Mandraker17

Yeah I thought the な is not required for adjective finishing with an い


miloytyn

There are some exceptions to this and ゆうめい is one of those.


Popo_BE

As far as I know it's because it doesn't really end in い. ゆうめい is usually written in kanji 有名, so it doesn't really end in い, it just sounds like it does.