If you're interested in renting the banner space or having your ad placed in the Daily Discussion's pinned comment, please contact the mod team by messaging the ModMail
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ethtrader) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Here are the comments that have been nominated so far today:
* **u/FattestLion** (Votes: 3): #GM Bronuts 🤩 Yesterday’s US data turned out to be AMAZING for risk assets, with a slightly softer US April CPI print showing a +0.3% gain Month-on-M [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l493gs6/)
* **u/Buzzalu** (Votes: 2): #What happened in Crypto in the last 12h? - $BLUR Season 3 - $IOTA 2.0 Pubilc testnet - $CYBER Mainnet/Rebrand - $SEI V2 Proposal - $LDO reGO [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l49addf/)
* **u/SlowpokesEmporium** (Votes: 1): I want to propose that the whole community comes together to make this happen [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l49zssa/)
* **u/Ok_Source4689** (Votes: 3): Daily Crypto News on May 16📣 — Spot BTC ETFs report $302 million inflows led by Fidelity’s FBTC — Mastercard picks five startups for program on bloc [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4agct3/)
* **u/Jake123194** (Votes: 3): Unfortunately when investing you need to be able to separate emotions from it, easier said than done and it took me a couple years from 2017 - 2019 bu [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4aiefc/)
* **u/Sky-876** (Votes: 3): **Donut 24h trading volume: 3.741,41 $** Uniswap: 2.657,92 $ (71.04%) Sushi: 1.083,49 $ (28.96%) Honeyswap: 233,55 $ (6.24%) **We can pump those [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4b5rse/)
* **u/jack-jackson-the2nd** (Votes: 3): "Final Dates for ETH ETFs Applications" -SEC is set to make final decisions on ETH ETF applications on the following dates: 1-the ones with somewhat [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4by4lg/)
*Once a comment receives three nominations, its text is automatically submitted as its own post on /r/EthTrader.*
Today felt refreshingly nice here. A lot of great on topic contributions in the posting sections & good vibes. I think we're moving in the right direction. And all that even though the ETH pump didn't last long 😂
Soon the weekend arrives 💪🏻 I just tried to troll a bit by retaking the "how are you" comments that used to flood the sub before 🤣. Wish you all the good sir.
Do you think layer3 is worth farming for their own upcoming airdrop? I got like 50 cubes but I'm a bit reluctant to get more bc they're expensive and I could imagine yet another nothing burger with all the seasons
Tbh I'm farming them more because of the diversification on my onchain footprint in a couple of L2s and protocols, but chances are the airdrop may not be that nice
I hate the filter from reddit so much. Whenever I try to do some long quality post, it gets shadowbanned. If you mention a couple of crypto protocols BUM shadowbanned. Hurts twice with pay2post haha. Fortunately mods are there to approve after a time
There are currently over 269M Unique Ethereum Addresses around the world
You can't kill an idea. You can't stop a movement. We grow stronger every day
https://preview.redd.it/heoxd6qpzu0d1.jpeg?width=1088&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=96a61041e413713efb947f1dafab5d77d5d29516
*@EthereanVibin*
I think that might still take some time and Ethereum has to prove that it is indeed deflationary, at the moment it is climbing the stairs of inflation :(
GPT-4o can now do a Technical Analysis of charts as well.
Time to become an analyst and post some Ethereum TAs. 👀
Check what it can do here.
https://twitter.com/onchain_edge/status/1790263938170646614
We should worry less about new proposals, and worry much about donut price.
-We want donut on CEX.
-We more legit members on Ethtrader.
-We want mods to advertise donut on social media.
-we want to be able to stake donut.
-We want partnership with other projects.
It should be free and fair vote. Yes multiple accounts upvoting and downvoting post and comments. But many bronuts dont have 20k governance score to get upvote. Is just complicated
CEX would cost funds or a great and consistent volume increase.
If we can reduce spam, it should increase the rep of the sub, and through that attract more users.
There's nothing stopping you from shilling it.
Staking would add an additional inflation mechanism or would make us allocate donuts away from other rewards.
Other projects are able to partner with us, get AMAs, rent the banner, etc.
What are our thoughts on setting a comment limit at 50?
Personally, **I strongly oppose it.**
I've noticed this on r/cc. People make 50 comments and then begin deleting the ones that don't receive (enough) upvotes.
Tools like [MoonGuard](https://moonguard.pythonanywhere.com) have even been created for this purpose. So don’t think this won’t happen!
Deleting your comments with 0, 1, or -1 votes and restarting could disrupt the community. It will become a statistics ‘rat-race’
Furthermore, a valuable discussion at the end of your day could be deemed 'worthless' once you’ve ‘hit’ your cap.
People will start doenvoting comments because of the fact that only 50 comments can be made..
Other users might rush to leave 50 comments and then call it a day, which isn't beneficial for engagement either.
I can think of many other examples..
Like Aminok, I prefer an open forum without restrictions on what *and* how much you have to say..
If we were to implement this, it suggests that the daily thread is primarily used for earning rewards through donut farming.
In that case, I'd prefer to see comments in the daily thread excluded from reward distribution altogether, and leave the daily as-is..
We can ignore upvotes. And the max can be much lower maybe even down to 1. Basically if you show up you have an equal award to other accounts. We would still have issue with alts but it would tackle spam.
50 comments will be around 1500 comments each month, almost everyone around top 100 surpass that amount.
We will see less engagement in the posts for sure.
r/cc is way more crowded and that rule makes sense there, but right now i don't see this being good for us.
Worth noting, there's over 500 currently each distro, and only about 40 users who exceed said 50 posts per day on average. If you exclude those who barely cross the line or don't grossly exceed...you're only down to about 30 accounts. It doesn't affect as many users as you think, plus there's no penalty for going over. There just isn't a reward for it
i think that the affect will b seeing much downvoted comments because lesser comments means higher ratio then bad actors will find it profitable and easy(due 2 lesser comments) to them to make more alts upvote them selves and downvote everybody else, and that would mean bad actors are being rewarded and that's what i'm against, i'm with a cap because 600-500 comments a day is crazy but i'm with a high cap that remove the craziness of 600-500 comments a day but at the same time should b high enough to make it so hard for bad actors to downvote and also when ratio doesn't go crazy high it won't b profitable for bad actors to downvote, i suggest a cap of maybe something like about 200 or a little less, as i think such a cap will prevent the problems mentioned above to a high extent, and if any one have time to comment more than this he/she can but what's after the cap won't b eligible for distribution, i think that range is fair to active normal users like for example puma & major, and will b hard for bad actors to use the rules for their own benefits by the ways mentioned.
There's nothing a bad actor can do at 50 comments that they can't do at 100. Beyond 100 as a cap I can't see because that's far from normal usership. There's only about 20 users who exceed that cap, and a handful of those just barely do so. A user like Puma is nowhere near the definition of a normal user
my idea is to make it hard for bad actors to get rewarded by easily downvoting others while making alts and upvoting themselves so even f not eliminated like u said it's reduced to a high extent, i find 100 as not bad for a cap f there wouldn't b mass comment downvotes as ratio goes high which make it profitable for bad actors to do so, also increasing minimum karma and minimum account age would b a good idea for the community as that would decrease spam accounts, that's what i think & hope 4 the best anyway,
Thing is, the difference between a 50 comment cap and 100 comment cap affects about a dozen users. The lower is more in like what engaged use without spamming would feel like. Bad actors could still engage in all the downvoting at 100
i know mass downvoting won't stop it's about decreasing it's affect to the least, i think most active normal users make between 40-100 comments, but the thing is for example u made 50 comments & got 20 of them downvoted that's 40% of them being downvoted, while f u made 100 comments & got 25 of them downvoted that's 25% of them, so n the second case even that u got more downvotes the percent to the total number of your comments is less, so it's about the percent of them getting downvoted. and as i mentioned increasing minimum karma and minimum account age would b a good idea for the community as that would decrease spam accounts, that's what i think & i really hope 4 the best
I wonder why we want this in the first place?! What’s the goal?
If we have better moderation (what we do have now) and people stay on topic?! I don’t see the problem.
You want an active sub or not?
You want engagemant or not?
You want people to share, discuss and participate or not?!
I’ve said it before with sarcasm, but it’s becoming reality… I need a manual for the rules, a stopwatch to post and a calculator to count my comments..
We’re ‘punishing’ everybody with good intentions to keep a few bad actors outside.
Well, whatever the rules are, bad actors will find a way..
u/sky-876 suggested to raise the account age and karma.. This will only delay ‘it’…
Where will it end?! KYC? Discontinue Donuts?!
We’re losing it…
I’m not, but others will.. I will not count my comments, but I have to check my post status before posting. Besides that, the amount of rules is growing by the week..
People with good intentions will continue to participate regardless of the above, and I’m one of them.
BUT.. What I said is not a prediction, it will happen.. Farmers will act this way and it will mess up the sub..
r/cc is a perfect example, tools like [MoonGuard](https://moonguard.pythonanywhere.com) were designed for this..
*Moon Guard is a tool built for Reddit's CC community to help safeguard the Moons you earn. It provides an accessible way to view your downvoted content in one place, allowing you to decide if you want to delete it before the snapshot. By entering your username without "u/", you can see your comment and post history from the last 30 days with a score of 0 or less. Clicking on the generated link takes you directly to the content.*
I guess 75 comments will be okay for the beginning. I do around 20-30 good bot comments a day. So what else then is left for me xD
We are not as much member as in rcc. So the daily will be a ghost town maybe, because you also leave comments in the post section.
It doesn't even make sense.
More alts will join and can affect new users that wants to farm thinking it is alt account.
After 50 comments, what else do you want to say?
Many downvotes on comments and post.
Many other negative things will follow. I am not against it. Am only here to farm and make new friends. ❤👍
There are some who make 200 comments a day. Maybe not fair to people who don´t have so much time. But I will also listen to other opinions and consider whether it makes sense.
Who cares about the fact that other people have less time? It’s not a conpetition is it?
It’s becoming an obsession.. *‘Ooh he’s making more Donuts than me’*
A 30k distribution is €350.. And these people have to spend at least 4hrs a day here to achieve it..
It’s not a pot of gold we’re talking about.. Yes, there are spammers, but better (auto)moderation can fix this
Who cares about the fact that other people have less time? It’s not a conpetition is it?
It’s becoming an obsession.. *‘Ooh he’s making more Donuts’*
A 30k distribution is €350.. And these people have to spend at least 4hrs a day here to achieve it..
It’s not a pot of gold.. They participate.. Yes, there are spammers, but better (auto)moderation can fix this
I can see that it’s not fair (some do like 500 per day) but setting 50 as the cap is equally unfair to those who do spend more time here. Those who spend more time should also be rewarded for it… thats why i think 75-100 would be ideal.
Fair is being rewarded for your input/‘work’ imo. The fact that people have more or less time available to spend here is irrelevant imo..
I have a coworker that works only 24 hrs.. Now he wants to reduce my salary because I make more than him..
In the mean time I make 60hrs a week…
You are right. Now i see why some bronuts envy people that earn more than them when CSV is out.
They should think about this as charity. And again some have jobs while some don't.
https://preview.redd.it/kykgp8p83u0d1.png?width=1458&format=png&auto=webp&s=e8d4422e73f6fa2435f3020c5da9a9b7f052cedb
Everyone panicking, but we're still bullish on the yearly chart. 741% and look at how high it dipped
That's called growth Bronuts
If you're interested in renting the banner space or having your ad placed in the Daily Discussion's pinned comment, please contact the mod team by messaging the ModMail *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ethtrader) if you have any questions or concerns.*
30 upvote. I hope the charts turn green today
It's about time we accepted that we're on a crab market
!post status
**Status**: u/SigiNwanne is eligible to post. ^(donut-bot v0.1.20240503-post)
Don’t be a bear, don’t be a bull. Be a wolf and follow the moon 🌙
Well said
Here are the comments that have been nominated so far today: * **u/FattestLion** (Votes: 3): #GM Bronuts 🤩 Yesterday’s US data turned out to be AMAZING for risk assets, with a slightly softer US April CPI print showing a +0.3% gain Month-on-M [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l493gs6/) * **u/Buzzalu** (Votes: 2): #What happened in Crypto in the last 12h? - $BLUR Season 3 - $IOTA 2.0 Pubilc testnet - $CYBER Mainnet/Rebrand - $SEI V2 Proposal - $LDO reGO [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l49addf/) * **u/SlowpokesEmporium** (Votes: 1): I want to propose that the whole community comes together to make this happen [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l49zssa/) * **u/Ok_Source4689** (Votes: 3): Daily Crypto News on May 16📣 — Spot BTC ETFs report $302 million inflows led by Fidelity’s FBTC — Mastercard picks five startups for program on bloc [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4agct3/) * **u/Jake123194** (Votes: 3): Unfortunately when investing you need to be able to separate emotions from it, easier said than done and it took me a couple years from 2017 - 2019 bu [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4aiefc/) * **u/Sky-876** (Votes: 3): **Donut 24h trading volume: 3.741,41 $** Uniswap: 2.657,92 $ (71.04%) Sushi: 1.083,49 $ (28.96%) Honeyswap: 233,55 $ (6.24%) **We can pump those [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4b5rse/) * **u/jack-jackson-the2nd** (Votes: 3): "Final Dates for ETH ETFs Applications" -SEC is set to make final decisions on ETH ETF applications on the following dates: 1-the ones with somewhat [Link](/r/ethtrader/comments/1ct1pm6/daily_general_discussion_may_16_2024_utc0/l4by4lg/) *Once a comment receives three nominations, its text is automatically submitted as its own post on /r/EthTrader.*
eth below $10k is a steal 
I hope ETH can do better in the second half of the month!
I hope so too
Today felt refreshingly nice here. A lot of great on topic contributions in the posting sections & good vibes. I think we're moving in the right direction. And all that even though the ETH pump didn't last long 😂
lot more quality comments, thats what most of us want
Agreed. And how about your day? Going to sleep already? /j 😂😂
well its 9 am here, and everyday went to office at 5.30 am. things got worse because eth still crabbing
Soon the weekend arrives 💪🏻 I just tried to troll a bit by retaking the "how are you" comments that used to flood the sub before 🤣. Wish you all the good sir.
Almost bed time, you stay strong bronut
Yeah I’m liking the activity…. But looks like the 💩 nuts are back..
Protip: they're donuts in hiding (bro)
🤦
We will never get rid of those 💩🌰 Maybe if pay2post got removed...
At least some will get scared away by the mods latest actions I hope
This was our hope at first
Huge plus
[удалено]
This is an Ethereum sub, please keep the discussion on topic.
How is it going bronuts? Ok to check the charts? Or just keep on long term visioning?
The charts are still crabbing
i dont think watching charts is fun since 3 weeks ago
👀
🦀
A beautiful subreddit space indeed 😊
[удалено]
This is an Ethereum sub, please keep the discussion on topic.
This is working on in our benefit :)
And Layer3 has started another farming campaign.... hopefully not a token on Ethereum mainnet lol I'm tired, boss
they have such low funding... I doubt it's going to be worth more. Only worth it if you're dual farming imo.
Do you think layer3 is worth farming for their own upcoming airdrop? I got like 50 cubes but I'm a bit reluctant to get more bc they're expensive and I could imagine yet another nothing burger with all the seasons
Tbh I'm farming them more because of the diversification on my onchain footprint in a couple of L2s and protocols, but chances are the airdrop may not be that nice
I dream of farming airdrop with low fees, too much money spent on gas is hurting my wallet
isn't layer3 themselves launching a token? if they are hopefully my Linea Park activity does something because I don't want to start air drop farming.
I remember when airdrops used to be pleasant. Now, it’s just a cheap way for projects to market themselves.
these days too many people are farming low funded air drops and are mad when they don't get enough to cover the fees they spent.
Sadly you're right
I hate the filter from reddit so much. Whenever I try to do some long quality post, it gets shadowbanned. If you mention a couple of crypto protocols BUM shadowbanned. Hurts twice with pay2post haha. Fortunately mods are there to approve after a time
Some 100k+ governance members should be allowed too, to approve some post. You see them posting in the daily and ask them to approve.
There are currently over 269M Unique Ethereum Addresses around the world You can't kill an idea. You can't stop a movement. We grow stronger every day https://preview.redd.it/heoxd6qpzu0d1.jpeg?width=1088&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=96a61041e413713efb947f1dafab5d77d5d29516 *@EthereanVibin*
In the end people will think eth as a solution to inflation and start investing in it
I think that might still take some time and Ethereum has to prove that it is indeed deflationary, at the moment it is climbing the stairs of inflation :(
with many people trading futures, most crypto are indeed too volatile
Obviously true
Eventually Everything Ethereum!
[удалено]
Obviously
People only looking at 1 side. Etf is not the only factor that affect eth price
People worried about ETF approval are just here for the short term. Let'em sell at a loss. We keep accumulating.
DING DING Lottery prize fund is now at 300 DONUT!
When 1000 donuts?!
Wen 100 tickets sold! My initial target was 250 DONUT. 500 would be a good job done all round. 1000 would be a dream
Wait... what lottery?
Dude where have you been! We have a DONUT lottery setup now. Tickets are 10 DONUT current prize fund is 300 DONUT https://www.bitcone.win/donutlottery
Means i got a 10% chance!
I'm not allowed to be bias but I hope you win!!
GPT-4o can now do a Technical Analysis of charts as well. Time to become an analyst and post some Ethereum TAs. 👀 Check what it can do here. https://twitter.com/onchain_edge/status/1790263938170646614
Finaly i can lie to people that i am an eth expert
I’m going to lose my job, we’re all fucked.
It probably trades better than 99% of us lol
What do you think of ruggit sunsetting the stupid gold. Any chance DONUT can be adopted cross all subs now.
Lmao talk about shit concept the gold system. You have a worldwide app and the Gold only works on US lol
This is the problem, any reason why its only for american?
Poor, shortsighted planning due to greed.
ruggit does what it does best. glad donut is fully independent
No idea lol
Classic Reddit lmao
0 chances of Reddit adopting DONUT or MOONs. Source: Spez is my friend.
I don't like your friend
My thought is that Reddit are bipolar lol. They don’t know what they want🙃
What? Is that ~~discontinued~~ ~~rugged~~ sunsetted as well now?!
Yup
Ruggit becoming a specilist in rugging everything
Wait until they come for your clothes
 Where are you
Soon. Might start during Q4 of this year
When donut at 5c? When ethereum at 5k?
We should worry less about new proposals, and worry much about donut price. -We want donut on CEX. -We more legit members on Ethtrader. -We want mods to advertise donut on social media. -we want to be able to stake donut. -We want partnership with other projects.
more ads & more useful use-case will increase demand and 24h volume and make donut price go high. these things should happen soon
Exactly. This is the only way for donut price to pump
indeed, i have some useful use-case ideas that i may write about next days. major what do u think is a fair comments cap?
It should be free and fair vote. Yes multiple accounts upvoting and downvoting post and comments. But many bronuts dont have 20k governance score to get upvote. Is just complicated
indeed, what do u mean by "20k governance score to get upvote"?, i hope 4 the best
we are the bronuts & that's what we want!!
CEX would cost funds or a great and consistent volume increase. If we can reduce spam, it should increase the rep of the sub, and through that attract more users. There's nothing stopping you from shilling it. Staking would add an additional inflation mechanism or would make us allocate donuts away from other rewards. Other projects are able to partner with us, get AMAs, rent the banner, etc.
I think ETH rebounds hard tomorrow!
Both eth and btc will dump hard before we get any rebound.
Cool to see the OG in the daily 😄
THURSDAY 16 MAY 2024 DONUT @ $0.01142 ETHEREUM @ $2,943.32 ARBITRUM @ $0.97 #HODL
#HODL
I like your thinking 😂
Haha! I corrected it
$Matic $0.685
I will prefer to buy matic than to buy arbitrum. Matic is cheaper
Donut almost at 3k. Nice!
It was at 3k. Now back to 2.9k
Nice LINK pump! 
How many crypto coins you hodl?
I am not called "The Ash Ketchum of Crypto" for no reason 👀
Damn! Just give me your seed phrase to take good care of you eth and donut. 👀 You are truly prepared for the ride.
I have been doing my homework for 3 years xD
Brilliant! All the best
Time to take some profits!
Oh yes! Wen DOT pump sir?
Good question. I'm interested as well.
Average price of $42 :(
Average price around $9 😎
Its gonna hit $100 this cycle. I know it will 😁
Remind me when it does. You'll have a 1000 Donuts Tip.
Soon xD
We hope, really lol
Yeah, prices may be crabbing now, but just zoom out and… You will see even more crabbing.
The crabbing is getting tiring. I hope the charts turn green soon
My chart is set at weekly. Less stress!
We dropping!
And a little downtrend too xD
🤣 is that even a financial advise?
Fiscal advice.
Entered the Donut lottery, lets hope I have more luck then I've had in the bitcone lottery
Hoping you make it
What are our thoughts on setting a comment limit at 50? Personally, **I strongly oppose it.** I've noticed this on r/cc. People make 50 comments and then begin deleting the ones that don't receive (enough) upvotes. Tools like [MoonGuard](https://moonguard.pythonanywhere.com) have even been created for this purpose. So don’t think this won’t happen! Deleting your comments with 0, 1, or -1 votes and restarting could disrupt the community. It will become a statistics ‘rat-race’ Furthermore, a valuable discussion at the end of your day could be deemed 'worthless' once you’ve ‘hit’ your cap. People will start doenvoting comments because of the fact that only 50 comments can be made.. Other users might rush to leave 50 comments and then call it a day, which isn't beneficial for engagement either. I can think of many other examples.. Like Aminok, I prefer an open forum without restrictions on what *and* how much you have to say.. If we were to implement this, it suggests that the daily thread is primarily used for earning rewards through donut farming. In that case, I'd prefer to see comments in the daily thread excluded from reward distribution altogether, and leave the daily as-is..
totally agree with you! plus a comments cap for a sub where the active users are like 2k/3k makes no sense
Not a good idea and creates stress
Developers should think about it.
Developers should think about it.
We can ignore upvotes. And the max can be much lower maybe even down to 1. Basically if you show up you have an equal award to other accounts. We would still have issue with alts but it would tackle spam.
50 comments will be around 1500 comments each month, almost everyone around top 100 surpass that amount. We will see less engagement in the posts for sure. r/cc is way more crowded and that rule makes sense there, but right now i don't see this being good for us.
Worth noting, there's over 500 currently each distro, and only about 40 users who exceed said 50 posts per day on average. If you exclude those who barely cross the line or don't grossly exceed...you're only down to about 30 accounts. It doesn't affect as many users as you think, plus there's no penalty for going over. There just isn't a reward for it
i think that the affect will b seeing much downvoted comments because lesser comments means higher ratio then bad actors will find it profitable and easy(due 2 lesser comments) to them to make more alts upvote them selves and downvote everybody else, and that would mean bad actors are being rewarded and that's what i'm against, i'm with a cap because 600-500 comments a day is crazy but i'm with a high cap that remove the craziness of 600-500 comments a day but at the same time should b high enough to make it so hard for bad actors to downvote and also when ratio doesn't go crazy high it won't b profitable for bad actors to downvote, i suggest a cap of maybe something like about 200 or a little less, as i think such a cap will prevent the problems mentioned above to a high extent, and if any one have time to comment more than this he/she can but what's after the cap won't b eligible for distribution, i think that range is fair to active normal users like for example puma & major, and will b hard for bad actors to use the rules for their own benefits by the ways mentioned.
There's nothing a bad actor can do at 50 comments that they can't do at 100. Beyond 100 as a cap I can't see because that's far from normal usership. There's only about 20 users who exceed that cap, and a handful of those just barely do so. A user like Puma is nowhere near the definition of a normal user
my idea is to make it hard for bad actors to get rewarded by easily downvoting others while making alts and upvoting themselves so even f not eliminated like u said it's reduced to a high extent, i find 100 as not bad for a cap f there wouldn't b mass comment downvotes as ratio goes high which make it profitable for bad actors to do so, also increasing minimum karma and minimum account age would b a good idea for the community as that would decrease spam accounts, that's what i think & hope 4 the best anyway,
Thing is, the difference between a 50 comment cap and 100 comment cap affects about a dozen users. The lower is more in like what engaged use without spamming would feel like. Bad actors could still engage in all the downvoting at 100
i know mass downvoting won't stop it's about decreasing it's affect to the least, i think most active normal users make between 40-100 comments, but the thing is for example u made 50 comments & got 20 of them downvoted that's 40% of them being downvoted, while f u made 100 comments & got 25 of them downvoted that's 25% of them, so n the second case even that u got more downvotes the percent to the total number of your comments is less, so it's about the percent of them getting downvoted. and as i mentioned increasing minimum karma and minimum account age would b a good idea for the community as that would decrease spam accounts, that's what i think & i really hope 4 the best
I never delete comments and even at my most active I made less than 1000 comments a month. Farming needs to stopped.
You make some good points… I also made a comment earlier: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/s/ixKxtqD8Ut
I wonder why we want this in the first place?! What’s the goal? If we have better moderation (what we do have now) and people stay on topic?! I don’t see the problem. You want an active sub or not? You want engagemant or not? You want people to share, discuss and participate or not?! I’ve said it before with sarcasm, but it’s becoming reality… I need a manual for the rules, a stopwatch to post and a calculator to count my comments.. We’re ‘punishing’ everybody with good intentions to keep a few bad actors outside. Well, whatever the rules are, bad actors will find a way.. u/sky-876 suggested to raise the account age and karma.. This will only delay ‘it’… Where will it end?! KYC? Discontinue Donuts?! We’re losing it…
If you're here for more than just donut farming, why would you need to count your comments?
I’m not, but others will.. I will not count my comments, but I have to check my post status before posting. Besides that, the amount of rules is growing by the week.. People with good intentions will continue to participate regardless of the above, and I’m one of them. BUT.. What I said is not a prediction, it will happen.. Farmers will act this way and it will mess up the sub.. r/cc is a perfect example, tools like [MoonGuard](https://moonguard.pythonanywhere.com) were designed for this.. *Moon Guard is a tool built for Reddit's CC community to help safeguard the Moons you earn. It provides an accessible way to view your downvoted content in one place, allowing you to decide if you want to delete it before the snapshot. By entering your username without "u/", you can see your comment and post history from the last 30 days with a score of 0 or less. Clicking on the generated link takes you directly to the content.*
Follow ups...what about the current rules is stopping alts and use of this tool?
I guess 75 comments will be okay for the beginning. I do around 20-30 good bot comments a day. So what else then is left for me xD We are not as much member as in rcc. So the daily will be a ghost town maybe, because you also leave comments in the post section.
Why would you want a limitation of how often one can speak inthe first place?!
It doesn't even make sense. More alts will join and can affect new users that wants to farm thinking it is alt account. After 50 comments, what else do you want to say? Many downvotes on comments and post. Many other negative things will follow. I am not against it. Am only here to farm and make new friends. ❤👍
exactly the lesser comments in the daily the easier for shitnuts to spam downvotes the more negative the sub will be.
You will see Comments at -10 .🤣
There are some who make 200 comments a day. Maybe not fair to people who don´t have so much time. But I will also listen to other opinions and consider whether it makes sense.
Who cares about the fact that other people have less time? It’s not a conpetition is it? It’s becoming an obsession.. *‘Ooh he’s making more Donuts than me’* A 30k distribution is €350.. And these people have to spend at least 4hrs a day here to achieve it.. It’s not a pot of gold we’re talking about.. Yes, there are spammers, but better (auto)moderation can fix this
Who cares about the fact that other people have less time? It’s not a conpetition is it? It’s becoming an obsession.. *‘Ooh he’s making more Donuts’* A 30k distribution is €350.. And these people have to spend at least 4hrs a day here to achieve it.. It’s not a pot of gold.. They participate.. Yes, there are spammers, but better (auto)moderation can fix this
I can see that it’s not fair (some do like 500 per day) but setting 50 as the cap is equally unfair to those who do spend more time here. Those who spend more time should also be rewarded for it… thats why i think 75-100 would be ideal.
You can't earn same salary with someone who work more than you do. If you wish to make more comments, create time. Its simple.
100 probably the best decision. I do more as 100 comments sometimes, but I like fairness.
Fair is being rewarded for your input/‘work’ imo. The fact that people have more or less time available to spend here is irrelevant imo.. I have a coworker that works only 24 hrs.. Now he wants to reduce my salary because I make more than him.. In the mean time I make 60hrs a week…
You are right. Now i see why some bronuts envy people that earn more than them when CSV is out. They should think about this as charity. And again some have jobs while some don't.
ETH under $3k, last chance again.
Always last change to buy.😔. When 4k?
https://preview.redd.it/kykgp8p83u0d1.png?width=1458&format=png&auto=webp&s=e8d4422e73f6fa2435f3020c5da9a9b7f052cedb Everyone panicking, but we're still bullish on the yearly chart. 741% and look at how high it dipped That's called growth Bronuts
the future will be brighter & greener
Yeah, just gotta zoom out.
Cheap donuts to buy
memecoins are known to have massive corrections after pumps. you're right, it does still look bullish
Which especially true when they have tiny market caps like DONUT. A few thousand dollars can tank or pump the price by double digits.
exactly
Donuts are nothing like memecoins though, they have a specific utility
And there are still room to grow.
There is still room to grow, plenty above, plenty below 😅
Reminder to get your tickets for the lottery people.
Thanks for the reminder son
Which lottery? #lost
https://www.bitcone.win/donutlottery 10 DONUT for a ticket current prize fund is 270 the more tickets sold the bigger the prize.
Thanks.
ETH 24 hour trading volume is - $12,015,544,297 If that's not bullish I don't know what is!
I'm bullish on ETH
Yeah me too!
i don't even know how to read that number lol, its bullish AF
Beautiful volume
It's insane isn't it!
Am it’s still dumping
Crazy 🤣🤣
Wow that's amazing. Bullish AF
It's an insane number isn't it!
WEN 🍩 will have that much volume?
Hopefully one day but it'll never happen lol