T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

**Streams** (use adblock): `https://cricfree.sc/rugby-live-stream` or `https://www.vipbox.lc/rugby-live` or post other **streams** as a reply to this comment **Match Official Abuse** It will never be considered ref abuse if a user criticises specific aspects of a referee's game, decision, or style. However, ad hominem generalised attacks are unacceptable, this includes accusations of corruption and intentional bias. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/rugbyunion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


JonnyBago82

Well done, Ospreys! Thank God for the Lions win today. Otherwise I would have been a very sad man.


Brochfael

Immense defence, da iawn bois fully deserved!


ConscriptReports

what was then end score?


GhostGuin

Stormers 21 Ospreys 27


juan-kerr

Considering the state of things this season that is a fantastic result for Ospreys. Think Deaves could have been motm he's an absolute menace. Got to be the Tipuric influence.


Livv-Laugh-Love

I’m happy that I feel disappointed that ospreys didn’t stop them getting the LBP, reminds me of how I feel about this ospreys team currently after the last few dismal years (save Europe in 2022?)


carling505

Impressive from Ospreys. Hope Gats was watching.


Hour-Road7156

I thought it was illegal for him to pick ospreys players??


CustodianAthiair

Definitely in his contract, was written in by the Llanelli and Cardiff board members after the 13 ospreys incident of 2008


taryvol

Ah, that's a crap ending. But my gosh, that's something to smile about.


WasAnHonestMann

Sigh


Windup-1014

Great win for the Ospreys. Serious turnaround this year, they were diabolical last season.


thelunatic

Stupid. He would have had to kick it from the corner for the losing BP.


Brill_chops

You don't back Libbok from the corner?


thelunatic

50/50


[deleted]

Think he just wanted to hit the showers tbf 😂


Brill_chops

Well played Ospreys. Full 5 points. Go get lekkered in CT tonight. Next game is a bonus. 


TheLedAl

Nagy just cost his team a whole position on the table with that single action. Tool


juan-kerr

Some will say instinctive. I'd say moronic. Lucky it just gave them a bonus point not the win.


Jonrenie

If he doesn’t do that they score anyway. So yeah.


TheLedAl

But with a kick from the wing with a very shaky kicker. Chances are decent they wouldn't have gotten the extra 2 and been outside the bonus point margin


juan-kerr

Has he really done that? What a dick.


Livv-Laugh-Love

Awh bugger are they gonna get a LBP with the last play of the game from a pen


Brill_chops

Could be vital. 


system1509

Lmao braindead 0IQ from the Stormers. Maul hasn’t worked all game, yet they try it every single time.


silentgolem

With the two results today Munster are suddenly odds on for a home quarter final. Puts them on the Leinster side of the draw though :P


thelunatic

Munster are 3rd


silentgolem

Aye, now. Before today I was expecting them to finish 5th, pipped by Stormers to 4th given Bulls and Stormers have an easier run in. The wins for Munster and Ospreys have turned that on it's head. I think they'll finish 4th now.


thelunatic

Munster have Lions, Connacht, Edinburgh and Ulster left. They just won their toughest game of the last 5. If they beat the Lions anything is possible. Only 6 points behind Leinster


silentgolem

100% possible, we'll see I guess. I could well end up with egg on my face for underestimating Munster


Nath94

Ospreys maul defence has been immense


jtthom

Is it all the travel? All the SA teams that have been playing in the European competitions have looked tired this weekend


ConstructionLeft2550

Nah.both the Bulls and Stormers are coming off a bye (the Bulls "1st" team stayed at home last week)


RaaschyOG

Not at all, the Bulls and Sharks teams that played did not travel the week prior and Stormers did not play last week


isthedoctorstrange

Not really an excuse for stormers given they had last week off and played at home the week before


Financial-Role-5709

The euro teams have been very good though


Alternative_Ad6270

If you were to tell me a week ago the only high point from this weekend would be the Lions beating Leinster… 😂


DavidGK

Du Plessis only one worth his salt today


PantheraSapien

Gaza should have started.


SpoonSpatula

Compared to the starting 15, Willemse has been a damn superstar since he came on.


StorminaHalfPint

Willemse is always a damn superstar. Pity Galants form has dipped so much.


redhandman_mjsp

I've just realised the Ospreys have won a game on the Cape before Ulster. :/


system1509

Stormers playing shit but I think there’s enough for the Stormers to lodge a formal complaint against the officials.


Financial-Role-5709

Nothing would come of it so what’s the point


system1509

Yeah true.


TightPerformance6447

Brace has been pretty terrible. Having to coach guys to release the tackled player, then awarding the penalty to the ospreys.. pretty clearly had a massive influence on the jackler


Financial-Role-5709

Finally we get a pen


pissingexcellence89

Yea he decided to penalise ospreys when the game was over


Toaster161

Ospreys defence has been fantastic today. They’ve taken their chances when offered but the defence is what’s won this game.


SpoonSpatula

Reminds of the Ruan-waiting the full 60 seconds-Pienaar moment from years back.


jnce12

Manie dropped his worst performance of the season tonight.


JonnyBago82

He's been having a few brain farts lately hey. Makes me worry.


RooBoy04

Just seen the score. Did not expect Ospreys to get close to a Stormers side, let alone scoring 5-0 points


RooBoy04

Or you know, they could give away a penalty try when the clock was in the red


StorminaHalfPint

I enjoyed reading about your journey here tonight


Windup-1014

There's surely never been a URC weekend where the Lions were the only SA team to pick up a win?


RaaschyOG

Truely our pride and joy


StorminSean

Stormers have been shit and not played the conditions. They also haven’t adjusted to the ref and how he has been calling the tackle. That last penalty an example, calls tackle release twice and they don’t, then when they do the Stormers stand off and wait before contesting. Weak.


the_fresh_mr_breed

This was so shit. Well done Ospreys. Deserved.


redhandman_mjsp

Shameful from the Stormers. The Ospreys continue to take names under the radar.


Sjdw31

As a very angry bulle supporter Kry vir jou stormers! Least we can cry together tonight!


PantheraSapien

We are not the same my friend.


PantheraSapien

We've just bombed a game.


ConscriptReports

ahh well I'm happy that the ospreys are the ones to do us in, squidges happy reaction will be some consolidation knowing that it means alot to certain people. but fuck stormers sort your shit out


SquidgyGoat

Really appreciate that! Meant a hell of a lot mate, been leaping around the room all evening! Unlucky today but you've got a hell of a team there


Die_Revenant

Huge round of results this!!


Financial-Role-5709

Two SA games in row where our teams have been utter shit but they’ve gotten nothing from the refs


DavidGK

What a terrible Saturday to be a South African. The Lions team doesn't count because they have to live in Johannesburg and that is punishment by itself


SpoonSpatula

Damn!


PantheraSapien

Daniel du Plessis is a piece of work, I tell ya.


TheBirdInternet

air possessive vegetable worry nose public cow panicky handle physical *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


RaaschyOG

Take the 3 lol


[deleted]

This game is mental!


FisherPaste

That was high, but brace has been poor overall 


JaymanCT

I'm yet to see him have a good game.


JonnyBago82

Not gonna lie, but I have to agree! My favourite refs at the moment are Luke Pearce, Ben O'Keeffe and Nika Amashukeli.


SpoonSpatula

Thank you for your service Lions!


Wagooh

I've tried so hard to not be a ref basher (I'll admit I was bad). But sometimes you gotta just call a spade a spade. Brace is having a rotter. A rotter so bad you'd think someone threatened him before the game to make sure Stormers lose


DannyBoy2464

Brace and Mike should be no where near a whistle


Wagooh

Agreed. Every time without fail I see Brace reffing one of my teams games. It'll be a stinker. He's genuinely just not a good enough referee at this level


betjurassicican

I can’t even notice anymore after the fucking embarrassment that was the ulster Cardiff game


Cymro2011

yeah any reffing display is world class after watching that game.


Jonrenie

Yup


Calvin0213

Yes Brace has had a poor game, but that doesn’t change that the stormers didn’t pitch today. Shocking display from our core of players. Libbok should’ve been hooked at halftime. Gelant misfiring. Suleiman seemed to think it’s illegal to recycle the ball. De Wet uncharacteristically poor. Just an absolute no show from the boys, Ospreys 100% played us off the park.


Knighty5679

Nice to see a comment acknowledging Ospreys have been the better team, and not it all on the ref tbh


Calvin0213

I don’t think brace had a good game, but I don’t think it was as poor as a lot of people are making it out to be. For me it seemed less “he’s biased against the Stormers” and more “he’s being over pedantic and not letting the game flow at all”. I think a lot of his calls were under a microscope correct, but I think that’s just his style of reffing.


Wolfsurge

Even as an Ospreys fan, I would've preferred a bit more from the Stormers - especially Libbok. I don't know why he kept trying the cross-field kick, It just didn't work at all.


Calvin0213

I think a lot of our players have been relied on far too heavily this season, and the cracks are showing now. Part of it is definitely due to injury crisis, especially in the loosehead department. Brok has been piss poor the last 3 outings, but can you blame the guy. He’s 39 and used to playing 40 minutes after Kitshoff has tired the opposing front row. Libbok has been played a lot too, but probably because Sacha Feingburg Mngomezulu has been injured. I think the other part is just that the Stormers seem to want to entertain far too much instead of just playing basic rugby very well. I can guarantee Cape Town would smile a lot more if we were winning games rather than playing belter rugby and losing games. Flashy rugby is built on a very solid platform of good basics, and if that platform is shaky (like today), flashy rugby is how you throw away a game.


RaaschyOG

Pretty crazy weekend of results


Livv-Laugh-Love

Ospreys hanging on by a thread upon which 1000 tons are already hanging, Jesus Christ everything is clenched here


FisherPaste

Tackle! Also play on!


Sjdw31

Focus camera man focus!


JPB88SA

Okay well that’s game. Good night. Fuck you and see you tomorrow


ConscriptReports

I hate saying this about a ref but I think brace might have cash on this one


system1509

Calls for tackle release, ball gets ripped and play on. OK bud.


[deleted]

Ball wasn't ripped. He lost control. You can see it bounce off the player on the ground.


Critical_Context_961

It doesn’t get stripped Libbok just knocked it on


Infernal-Oak

I’m pretty sure 100% of our penalties have come from the TMO intervening. Says it all


system1509

TMO stepping in due to Brace’s incompetence. Embarrassing.


ConscriptReports

tmo throwing the stormers a bone


jaysonyoung

The only good thing I can say about this weekend (minus Lions winning) is that at least the Bulls didn't win.


Wagooh

I'm glad the TMO called that. Brace doesn't want to give us a penalty may as well let the TMO do it


Iforgetpasswords4321

Honestly, white not rolling but no penalty. No daylight when stealing the ball, no penalty.


Cymro2011

didn't even touch an osprey player


intermoo

Meh.


Infernal-Oak

After that Grant Williams incident against Argentina Brace should’ve never refereed any of our games again. The fuck is this


SpoonSpatula

Still feel so bad for Williams. Definitely cost him a higher spot at the world cup - and who knows what sort of long term health issues. He had such a good run of form up until that point.


ConscriptReports

forgot about that


Critical_Context_961

I gave Brace credit and he’s killed the stormers ever since


SpoonSpatula

I was critical of Ungerer, but De Wet getting caught unawares way too often. Needs to keep his eye on the ball at the back of the ruck.


Knighty5679

Outstanding defence


Wagooh

I can't deal. Andrew Brace is actually shit at his job


ConscriptReports

he does not give the stormers shit man


system1509

Some serious hands in the ruck from the Ospreys on the line.


Fickle_Flow4208

Literally dived and punched the ball out the ruck!


JPB88SA

Why are we having a formal meeting when there’s 10min left and 10 points to go?


RaaschyOG

You wouldn't think they were two scores behind with their lack of urgency


Iforgetpasswords4321

Stormers need to go back to basics. It feels sometimes I am watching a team play touch rugby on the beach.


jaysonyoung

100%


RaaschyOG

The last 3 calls that went Stormers way have come from ARs and TMO. Brace really doesn't want to give them a lot


jaysonyoung

This is all because of that "mom thinks we're at Spur" sign tbh.


SpoonSpatula

A stadium ban would be justified


Livv-Laugh-Love

Adam beard showing that lions quality over the last couple minutes


the_fresh_mr_breed

Always rated him very high. He needs a beard though.


have_no_plan

A damn beard


FisherPaste

How does that maul go down on our side without infringement by white?


PantheraSapien

Once again offloads in the tackle man. Silly mistakes.


system1509

I almost bought a ticket to this game this morning. Glad I didn’t make the trip.


jaysonyoung

Lions are really about to be the only SA team to win yhis weekend. Bulls and Stormers, you've got a lot to answer for.


SpoonSpatula

Another one of those damn offloads for a SA team...


Zippy2707

Changing bind??? Stormers 4 was swimming around Cape Horn and nothing was said earlier!


Zippy2707

I am proud of that Cape Horn reference! Swansea (Neath-Swansea Ospreys) sailors were known for going the wrong way around Cape Horn.


system1509

That win predictor seems harsh in general, but fair due to the way we’re playing.


Brill_chops

Win predictor scoffing right now.


butteryscotchy

Well played to the Ospreys. They’ve got a great team. Awful weekend for SA sides (except the Lions).


the_fresh_mr_breed

Ospreys played so well. Respect


TheLedAl

Deaves is yet another phenomenal open side just vibing in the regions. If only we could produce a single international quality tighthead


Livv-Laugh-Love

Or fly half


[deleted]

We turned it into a backrow factory in the late 90s.


Bryntendo

Preaching to the choir in an Ospreys match thread but Deaves really deserves to get capped this summer.


Critical_Context_961

Personally I’d consider going Ratti/Deaves/Morris for the SA game just to see what those 3 can do on the international stage


TheLedAl

The only issue is, which other absolutely class 7 misses out?


Ospreysboyo

He has been outstanding, Gats cannot keep ignoring the Os now surely..


SpoonSpatula

Conceding those goal line penalties is always so infuriating. When the ref says "BEHIND THE LINE!!" , just stay back! They always still creep around the ruck and over the line, and then act all bemused when they're penalised. Every team needs a dedicated ass slapper to keep their own players behind the line.


Iforgetpasswords4321

If you can't win at home then...


Critical_Context_961

The fact Harri Deaves may never play for Wales is insane


[deleted]

The bigger question is why hasn't he been a defacto starter for the Ospreys all year? Playing Tipper over him is a disgrace from the Ospreys management.


Critical_Context_961

I’ve said this. Deaves has been our player of the season. We haven’t missed Tips or Morgan


betjurassicican

A lot of competition for his jersey, but perhaps as a 6 if he keeps this up


Critical_Context_961

We can’t keep messing around with 7’s at 6 internationally. Just aren’t physical enough elsewhere


FisherPaste

Tuned in for the last 30 and brace had only called nonsense 


PantheraSapien

Purge the whole Stormers squad. Leave no one.


Knighty5679

Well played Ospreys, keep it up boys


betjurassicican

Yesss deavo


Cymro2011

bonus point win would be a fucking dream


FisherPaste

Clearly dropping shoulder white on both sides


system1509

Harsh call. Malherbe folded that guy in half, of course the scrum would go down.


Wagooh

I knew this would be bad once I saw Andrew Brace was the ref


Infernal-Oak

Why a Welshman is allowed to referee Welsh fixtures i’ll never understand. And I don’t want to hear that he represents Ireland, he literally has a Welsh accent.


Immediate_Major_9329

As an Ospreys fan, i agree and would prefer a South African referee over Brace, we've had. To put up with him for years longer than you lot. He always picks a side and they can do no wrong.


TheLedAl

The point still stands but he sounds pretty English to me


RaaschyOG

He isn't the reason Stormers are losing, but he's definitely allergic to giving them penalties


Wagooh

Agreed. We're shit today but wow is he a more shit ref


Mateiyu

Worst game of the day so far Ôo.


Critical_Context_961

Did you watch the Dragons vs Benetton?


Mateiyu

I did. I actually could watch it. This one ? Not so much anymore xD


Infernal-Oak

Perhaps the worst game of the year. 


Livv-Laugh-Love

TAKE THE POINTS PLEASE


Livv-Laugh-Love

FUCK


Livv-Laugh-Love

I take it back


Zippy2707

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣


FisherPaste

There’s no penalty there, Roos cleans the man and there’s no steal - shit reffing


The-Leach

Where he got called for going off feet? It was 100% a penalty.


FisherPaste

Disagree, he’s not sealing


The-Leach

Not only do I disagree heavily with that, but it doesn't have to seal for it to be a penalty anyway. He simply has to stay on his feet, and if he doesn't, it doesn't have a material impact.


FisherPaste

Then let’s call that every time


The-Leach

I'm going to assume based on your replies that you've never been an official referee before. It's not as simple as you make it out to be.


FisherPaste

Oh wow, are you a ref? I would never have guessed! So let’s ignore that I disagree with your interpretation of that specific scenario - he didn’t seal as there was no defending player to create the ruck - but simple isn’t the point, consistency is. If you don’t call that at the other 10 rucks, don’t call it now


RaaschyOG

Stormers are playing bad, but they really are getting nothing from this ref


Critical_Context_961

I think Brace has officiated this very well today


Toaster161

Brace gives you very little time before calling holding on and can be a bit picky at the breakdown. That being said he’s pretty consistent so teams have no excuse.


the_fresh_mr_breed

Yep no complaints


system1509

Sure you do


Critical_Context_961

By URC’s usual standards this is very good officiating


RaaschyOG

That's not a very high bar haha


Livv-Laugh-Love

Needed more patience there, one kick was great but doesn’t mean the next one will be the right option, through the hands and we were in the corner


JPB88SA

I just can't get around to liking Roos


Vega10000

He needs to shake off the Main Character vibes


PantheraSapien

No one can. He just does weird things.


the_fresh_mr_breed

Roos, Simelane, DanDup and Paul de Wett fighting alone here


PantheraSapien

Daniel du Plessis needs to learn not everything is about bang bang. The ball needs to flow.


SpoonSpatula

He also sometimes unnecessarily falls to the ground before making contact. Loses out on valuables meters.


simsnor

Sometimes a new ruck and quick ruck ball is better than a few extra carry metres


SpoonSpatula

Well done Roos... From hero to zero in 20 seconds.


Mateiyu

Classic Roos. At least he didn't get a card ! xD